Open 800 - Donner Party | Game Over

[pob long]

well johnny isn't town so that's a problem

why'd you think this?
I ate johnny because he seemed like a consensus SR from what I remembered

I thought in general he was playing at the level of background noise, staying out of the way of really pushing anyone, and I didn't like the way his read on Thomas progressed. Day 2 he just seemed to pop in and add momentum to the triforce wagon and not really do much else. Unfortunate result, but I don't really regret saying that.

I'm not really trusting of Aristophanes's claim, but in terms of play, at least, I do think he looks better than chkflip and pob long, who both fell into the "saying just enough to make me not want to kill them" category. The fact that gamma wasn't shot, at

least, implies that guillotina was not the roleblocker. I think probably

right now pob seems to most suspicious to me.

why

[chkflip]

why couldn't guillo have been RB?

I hadn't really considered that, but that'd mean they stopped a kill. Who would they have blocked? Aristo?

at least, I do think he looks better than chkflip

Do you bite your thumb at me, sir?

ok seriously what the fuck does pob want

i`m not answering this way too personal question.

Here I am shitting my pants laughing again.

[catboi]

well johnny isn't town so that's a problem

why'd you think this?
I ate johnny because he seemed like a consensus SR from what I remembered

I thought in general he was playing at the level of background noise, staying out of the way of really pushing anyone, and I didn't like the way his read on Thomas progressed. Day 2 he just seemed to pop in and add momentum to the triforce wagon and not really do much else. Unfortunate result, but I don't really regret saying that.

I'm not really trusting of Aristophanes's claim, but in terms of play, at least, I do think he looks better than chkflip and pob long, who both fell into the "saying just enough to make me not want to kill them" category. The fact that gamma wasn't shot, at

least, implies that guillotina was not the roleblocker. I think probably

right now pob seems to most suspicious to me.

why

Scum didn't shoot the claimed vig last night, and the only plausible explanation is that they were hunting for other PRs (or attempting to cross-kill, but that seems like it'd be a very bad strategy)

[Gamma Emerald]

I hadn't really considered that, but that'd mean they stopped a kill. Who would they have blocked? Aristo?

Or SK got hit
Or two people targeted the same person

[chkflip]

If Guillo was hit by both teams as role blocker I imagine either scum knows Ari is lying or scum would counterclaim and I'm not seeing any of the latter here.

[Gamma Emerald]

Well what about the former?

[chkflip]

Then it sort of solves itself or no

[Gamma Emerald]

how

[chkflip]

If scum knows Ari is lying they nk him?

wdym how

[Gamma Emerald]

why? Wouldn't it be smarter to let him get miselim'ed?

[chkflip]

We're crossing into WIFOM bullshitville, idk

[Gamma Emerald]

eh okay
do you think I'm being bad by TRing catboi here?

[Aristophanes]

I mean, I'm not lying but the theories are interesting

[chkflip]

eh okay
do you think I'm being bad by TRing catboi here?

Why cat over pob?

I mean, I'm not lying but the theories are interesting

I don't think you are, but if you were I wouldn't worry about it today.


VOTE: No Elimination

[catboi]

Why would you vote no elim on 3:1:1?

[Aristophanes]

If we nolim here it's a huge risk. Assuming you don't shoot, you and I could both die, Gamma, leaving 1v1v1 with town as a kingmaker. It's a rough place to be.

If we elim today, you kill one of the remaining and I rb the other, we do a proper spread of things.

If we lim the last townie today, we lose. But that happens in any spread.
So long as we get 1 of the scum today, we go into the night with the scum either killed bý you or blocked by me. Come in tomorrow with either a victory from your kill or a confscum from my block.

We have a 66% base chance of hitting one of the scum today. We should take the risk.

Actually, if we get the SK that works.
If we get the Mafia then you have to holster as they are 1shot nk proof and 1shot rb proof meaning despite being able to confirm them we would run the risk of 1 too many deaths if you make a kill attempt.

I guess that goes back into the nk, I rb and you kill a target.

Uggh I don't think Ive been in a donner party where we got this far with no public flips. It's tougher than I'd thought

[Marashu]

Official Vote Count 3.01

Elimination

With 5 votes in play, it takes 3 to eliminate someone.

Not voting

(5): Gamma Emerald, Aristophanes, pob long, catboi, chkflip

Deadline:

(expired on 2020-12-04 18:37:34).

Mod notes:

Reminder: No Elimination is not an option in this setup.

[Aristophanes]

Official Vote Count 3.01

Mod notes:

Reminder: No Elimination is not an option in this setup.

OH FUVK I FORGOT LMAO

[Aristophanes]

Hoooookay so back to my post then...

[Gamma Emerald]

Why would you vote no elim on 3:1:1?

to test if that's the case?

[chkflip]

Ah.

Hm.

[Aristophanes]

I think we do pob today.

[pob long]

well johnny isn't town so that's a problem

why'd you think this?
I ate johnny because he seemed like a consensus SR from what I remembered

I thought in general he was playing at the level of background noise, staying out of the way of really pushing anyone, and I didn't like the way his read on Thomas progressed. Day 2 he just seemed to pop in and add momentum to the triforce wagon and not really do much else. Unfortunate result, but I don't really regret saying that.

I'm not really trusting of Aristophanes's claim, but in terms of play, at least, I do think he looks better than chkflip and pob long, who both fell into the "saying just enough to make me not want to kill them" category. The fact that gamma wasn't shot, at

least, implies that guillotina was not the roleblocker. I think probably

right now pob seems to most suspicious to me.

why

Scum didn't shoot the claimed vig last night, and the only plausible explanation is that they were hunting for other PRs (or attempting to cross-kill, but that seems like it'd be a very bad strategy)

no body knew Johnny was the dietician

[Gamma Emerald]

do we have any potential hints as to johnny's n1 target, actually?

[pob long]

If Guillo was hit by both teams as role blocker I imagine either scum knows Ari is lying or scum would counterclaim and I'm not seeing any of the latter here.

why? Wouldn't it be smarter to let him get miselim'ed?

????? why would he lie if hes town