Guns & Roses V [Game Over]

[Akarin]

And this too, specifically how you were also getting 3-4 townreads on page 1.

Tanner:

i am slightly +town on bell for post 16. it struck me as an anti-town thing to say, however it rings like one of those anti-town things that scum are less likely to say. if it's accurate, his post felt like a "warning" to scum about albert - that i imagine scum would probably keep to a scum pt.

Johnny:

Your answer sets you up to have to bus your buddies before you even know whether you want to or not.
Or at least vote them at inopportune times.

It's not very strong, rvs etc. But gut.

It wasn't 3-4 reads, where did you think the 4th was anyway? Bell immediately 2nd guessed the Hiraki read.

I think Bell looking at these things this way is town indicative of Bell. (And Tanner for similar reason.)

I don't know if I agree on the Dunn read or not but my ability to read Dunn off so little is probably compromised right now by things that have nothing to do with this game. I'll need more from him before I have a read.

[Akarin]

I think Akarin is quite likely to be mafia and could be a partner for Bell. She entered the thread sussing me but wi try out saying why beyond “I don’t like his post about Bell”. But she didn’t actually explain what she didn’t like.

Why do you think scum is likely to come into the thread sussing you without saying why?

[Akarin]

Yeah, this is about the best I can say about the current Bell handwaving here. "Too scummy to be scum" isn't a thing if the person is capable of not being scummy. Bell has done that in other games.

So you think Bell is

that

scummy still?

[Akarin]

Yeah but are you reading it? Gun is actually playing the game - Rose is floating.

post 146: Bell is picking fights and Rose thinks he's pure of heart. ABR feels barricaded and careful. Uncrowned has a good reads list and seems towny.

post 151 Sandman is "acknowledging the Bell is starting conflicts by being inflammatory, but also saying he's suspicious for trying

not

to engage in conflicts." Vote: Sandman

Why doesn't this count as playing the game?

[Akarin]

She's the worst, she goes first.

What % of this is about font color?

[DrippingGoofball]

She's the worst, she goes first.

What % of this is about font color?

85%

[Bell]

Sorry, job interview early tomorrow morning, not gunna focus on this.

[Hiraki]

Yeah, this is about the best I can say about the current Bell handwaving here. "Too scummy to be scum" isn't a thing if the person is capable of not being scummy. Bell has done that in other games.

So you think Bell is

that

scummy still?

What do you mean still? It's still Day 1 and we're on Page 9. Am I supposed to forgive and forget because he hasn't posted in awhile?

Yeah but are you reading it? Gun is actually playing the game - Rose is floating.

post 146: Bell is picking fights and Rose thinks he's pure of heart. ABR feels barricaded and careful. Uncrowned has a good reads list and seems towny.

post 151 Sandman is "acknowledging the Bell is starting conflicts by being inflammatory, but also saying he's suspicious for trying

not

to engage in conflicts." Vote: Sandman

Why doesn't this count as playing the game?

1) Calling out someone for doing something and labeling at townie should have a reason behind it. An action in itself is not townie but the motivation behind it. If there's no explanation of the motivation, there's no real reason to believe that person is town.

2) You said it right there. "ABR feels barricaded and careful." Literal IIoA in the flesh.

3) I've already called out Uncrowned's readslist to be bad.

4) That's not what Sandman said and it doesn't lead to scum. Even Rose acknowledged that in the same post -

"Y'know, that's shoddy reporting at best

, and malicious at worst. Let's pay em a visit and see what he thinks, yeah?"

It's quite honestly one of the weakest votes I've seen in years. And it's supposed to be an example of Rose doing anything other than floating by???

Good luck Bell!

[Akarin]

So having thoughts Hiraki disagrees with = not playing the game?

[Akarin]

Like I'm 99% sure that ABR comment was a scumlean not just IIoA. It's not even that much information, because obviously you're not reading it as effort, which is the whole

point

of IIoA.

[Hiraki]

So you're saying that you

think

Rose has scumlean but there's nothing in the post that says that? Sort of like if Gun was just saying that ABR was doing X and Y but Gun also never got to a conclusion?

Besides, who told you to think for Rose?

[Hiraki]

Actually nail in the coffin - wouldn't it have been easier to summarize that ABR was a scumlean for Rose rather than saying the direct quote? But you couldn't do that because Rose never said that so now you're just putting words in Rose's mouth? Weird to me.

[Akarin]

I'm saying I'm pretty darn sure Rosé has a scumlean and I'm dead certain that Rosé is playing the game and not just doing totally empty RP like you suggested.

[Akarin]

Besides, who told you to think for Rose?

What the heck is this?

If I'm not allowed to have an opinion about other people's play and other people's posts what exactly do you think we're doing?

[Hiraki]

You didn't want to ask?

[Hiraki]

The whole point of our conversation is that Rose hasn't said anything and all you've done is shown that you've been able to interpret what Rose is saying. That's good and all but I'm not here to put words in anyone's mouth.

[Akarin]

You didn't want to ask?

The important thing to me isn't what Rosé's read on ABR is. The important thing is that you're not paying attention to the actual content of Rosé's posts while accusing them of IIoA and empty posting.

[Akarin]

VOTE: Hiraki

[Uncrowned]

I have nothing more to say about my Ico read

[Uncrowned]

Scum are more likely to roleplay too. I love getting into character when I'm about to put a knife in someone's back.

how nonsensical

[Hiraki]

VOTE: Hiraki

Good luck.

[FakeGod]

VoteCount 1.2

Dunnstral [3] - Bell, Gún, Albert B. Rampage
JohnnyFarrar [1] - Tanner
Mr Sandman [2] - Iconeum, Rosé
Hiraki [1] - Akarin
Bell [2] - Mr Sandman, Hiraki
Akarin [1] - Uncrowned
Rosé [1] - DrippingGoofball

Not Voting [3]

- JohnnyFarrar, Paragon of Mafia Hunters, Dunnstral

With 14 alive it takes 8 votes to be executed.

Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2020-12-14 10:01:04)

[FakeGod]

Gamma Emerald replaces Paragon of Mafia Hunters.

[Gamma Emerald]

I see we have three votes on Dunnstral, what’s up with that? I’ll probably catch up in the morning, unless I do it now.

Also I noticed while peeking in earlier there’s some complaints about roleplaying, I don’t plan to myself but I won’t discount it entirely. I do think the idea of it being a scum façade might hold weight though?

[Hiraki]

Vote: Bell

@Mod