Micro 992: Are You My Partner?

[Klaus Hargreeves]

—

Skip to Next Vote Count

—

---

@Ben Hargreeves: Do you have an answer to question 49?

[Five Hargreeves]

You asked me a question, I answered

[Klaus Hargreeves]

You asked me a question, I answered

It was hard to tell because the message was so long after me.

Do you have anything valuable to say?

In light of your answer, I will modify what I am asking of Ben Hargreeves. I would still like to know why he thinks it would be suspicious to vote for someone suspected in the RVS. But now it’s clear you don’t really doubt Allison Hargreeves. Once this is known, my additional question for Ben Hargreeves is if he still doesn’t like your entrance.

[Pogo Hargreeves]

Do you mean that you voted for Allison Hargreeves for no reason? You used to seem to agree with something.

Yes. It was RVS and I joined a wagon, it would be odd to have a reason given the number of posts in the game. I agreed that Allison had the weirdest opening based on virtually no info.

Allison, Vanya and Ben seem the oddest to me at the moment. Initially I townread Ben but I think that may have been a bit hasty. The post between Vanya and Ben I commented on looked like open wolf whistles to me. I didn't want to point it out and help scum find each other faster but this seems like the current trend in thread.

[Jingle]

Vote Count 1.2

Ben Hargreeves (2): Allison Hargreeves, Vanya Hargreeves
Allison Hargreeves (2): Five Hargreeves, Pogo Hargreeves,
Pogo Hargreeves (1): Klaus Hargreeves,
Diego Hargreeves (0):
Five Hargreeves (0):
Klaus Hargreeves (0):
Luther Hargreeves (0):
Reginald Hargreeves (0):
Vanya Hargreeves (0):

Not Voting (4): Ben Hargreeves, Diego Hargreeves, Luther Hargreeves, Reginald Hargreeves,

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to eliminate!

Deadline is in (expired on 2021-01-12 18:00:00)!

@mod: You are missing the votes of Allison Hargreeves and Vanya Hargreeves.

So I did. Their votes were completely valid and should have counted. I am slightly less likely to make errors like this if you put votes at the beginning of lines, but I should be able to catch votes in that format as well.

Please point out any further errors exactly like this should you notice them.

[Five Hargreeves]

If I had to trust any of you not to start an apocalypse I would not at this point.

[Five Hargreeves]

And every post has some value, the fact that you don't value my posts just means you aren't reading hard enough

[Pogo Hargreeves]

Ego.

Ego

VOTE: Allison

Claiming to know whom we all are. Seems suspicious to me

I'm Five.

No

You asked me a question, I answered

If I had to trust any of you not to start an apocalypse I would not at this point.

And every post has some value, the fact that you don't value my posts just means you aren't reading hard enough

I think you're being unfair five, sometimes helping others read you is better play than expecting people to know your alignment, this is especially true when we have no meta to work with.

[Ben Hargreeves]

then someone else came in saying they didn't like (ok, sure) but then votes them? I get it's rvs but the light justification for their "random" vote felt unneeded and again, awkward

I don’t understand why voting a suspicious person would be a problem, but I understand how that reason is weird if it’s a serious reason.

No

What?

#####

@Pogo Hargreeves: Why haven’t you answered my question in 37?

the problem with it was their justification of the vote felt scummy to me

[Ben Hargreeves]

I still didn't like his entrance but I'm not going to stick on it much

[Five Hargreeves]

Turns out there was an entire page I missed because my fingers are clumsy. I'll read it tomorrow and maybe have something

[Luther Hargreeves]

we have someone post then a couple minutes later ego post from their main

I can only really assume this ego post was to signal to their partner who they were

On rereading I've been bamboozled by this.

If mafia received their roles in the same manner we did then, hypothetically speaking, how would revealing your main signal to a mafia buddy that you are their partner?

For this to be a signal then mafia would have to receive role PMs that say something like "you're mafia and your partner is *main account*" and if this is indeed the case then a couple of people may have slipped already.

Interesting.

Seeking: Once per day, you may choose a player that you believe is your partner. If you are correct, you will be told so. If you and your partner are both correct, or your partner dies, you will receive access to the Mafia PT where you may talk at any time and choose to publicly change the game into a mountainous setup.

That makes sense why people are voting Alison.

[Luther Hargreeves]

You all need to hide yourselves better! I have already figured out who

two

of you are just from the post tone alone. How dare we give mafia daychat and let them tie themselves together in thread?
Let's keep who we are under wraps on Day 1 if possible and then we can choose to ditch the feigning on Day 2. VOTE: Ben Hargreeves

This is a highly suspicious post.

And you know we’re not allowed to out our mains.

[Luther Hargreeves]

diego scum

wait there's so.mant scummy entry posts what are y'all doing

I'm going to lock mafia diego regardless

Hello

Because their opening post was a “hello”? Why can’t town open with a post like that? Conventional wisdom says that greeting the game posts are presumably scummy but I’ve done that in lots of games and that’s definitely NAI for me.

I could find textbook examples of obvscum opening posts but imo, a “hello” opening is NAI.

[Ben Hargreeves]

luther, he's scum cause he posted an entry post and soon after ego posted with his main so their partner knows who they are

this is my theory at least

[Klaus Hargreeves]

Do you mean that you voted for Allison Hargreeves for no reason? You used to seem to agree with something.

Yes. It was RVS and I joined a wagon, it would be odd to have a reason given the number of posts in the game. I agreed that Allison had the weirdest opening based on virtually no info.

Allison, Vanya and Ben seem the oddest to me at the moment. Initially I townread Ben but I think that may have been a bit hasty. The post between Vanya and Ben I commented on looked like open wolf whistles to me. I didn't want to point it out and help scum find each other faster but this seems like the current trend in thread.

I consider it a reason.

I've changed my feelings early Allison Hargreeves wagon. It doesn’t bother me as much with either participant. I think what I took was mainly due to players who deliberately tried to act differently. UNVOTE:

Why did you first townread Ben Hargreeves?

then someone else came in saying they didn't like (ok, sure) but then votes them? I get it's rvs but the light justification for their "random" vote felt unneeded and again, awkward

I don’t understand why voting a suspicious person would be a problem, but I understand how that reason is weird if it’s a serious reason.

No

What?

#####

@Pogo Hargreeves: Why haven’t you answered my question in 37?

the problem with it was their justification of the vote felt scummy to me

The first part "then someone else came in saying they didn't like (ok, sure) but then votes them?" meant that you had disliked the voting.

I don’t think adding a little justification to a non-serious vote is scummy. People do it all the time on RVS.

VOTE: Ben Hargreeves

PEDIT: Luther Hargreeves posts things.

[Luther Hargreeves]

btw like 4 people have called me scum so I'm thread spewed

Who has called you scum other than maybe Vanya Hargreeves?

Good spotting Watson.
VOTE: Allison

Why did you decide to join this wagon?

I like Klaus, Pogo not so much.

[Klaus Hargreeves]

You all need to hide yourselves better! I have already figured out who

two

of you are just from the post tone alone. How dare we give mafia daychat and let them tie themselves together in thread?
Let's keep who we are under wraps on Day 1 if possible and then we can choose to ditch the feigning on Day 2. VOTE: Ben Hargreeves

This is a highly suspicious post.

And you know we’re not allowed to out our mains.

That is what she says.

[Luther Hargreeves]

luther, he's scum cause he posted an entry post and soon after ego posted with his main so their partner knows who they are

this is my theory at least

Yeah that’s definitely bad. I almost did the converse but then realized I would be outing who I was, so yeah. I like your avatar eventhough Jingle chose it. It’s Diane Nyugen in case anyone cares.

We are all warned against doing that and you absolutely shouldn’t if your town and if you do an ego post on your main, you should wait a reasonable amount of time, so no one ties it to your alt. I didn’t primarily because I didn’t want to risk main slipping.

[Luther Hargreeves]

Problem with scumreading that is it’s just so blatant, I think scum would be more inclined to try to drop obvious hints.

[Luther Hargreeves]

hello everyone

VOTE: Ben Hargreeves

You broke the chain.

Leggo my ego

Hmmmmm . . . .

[Luther Hargreeves]

Ben, have a banana you townly man. I can't tell if Klaus is worthy of one or if he needs to be killed with fire.

I suppose time will tell.

What did Klaus do that was scummy?

[Luther Hargreeves]

I can only really assume this ego post was to signal to their partner who they were, the alternative is that someone else randomly ego posted after their entry, which, while possible... meh

That really is a childless, and absurd idea 6, wherever did you get such an idea that the mafia would ever make such a blatant move that could put themselves under pressure. As much as they want to find their partner, they need to be careful as to how they are to move about the day. I would suggest other means of figuring out who is and isn't mafia

Liking this post.

[Luther Hargreeves]

I do believe that Ben is of Town Alignment here. Would anyone else object to this line of reasoning here? Also I do quite apologize for the recent absence, the New Years celebrations got to me and I have been recovering all afternoon.

If you’ve posted about this on your main, people in this game could possibly figure out your identity from that.

[Luther Hargreeves]

For whatever reason, I feel a little like Reginald Hargreeves is a townie.

Yep, I think both of you are likely town.