I guess I could see why Luther appears to be TMIing with all the townreads but I'm not sure scum can even TMI in this setup since they don't actually know who their buddy is and thus they can't know for sure who they're townreading is town. It would be a slightly better guess than ours since they have an 87.5% chance of correctly guessing town vs our 77% chance of guessing correctly. A stronger case is needed here.
In post 377, Pogo Hargreeves wrote:I guess I could see why Luther appears to be TMIing with all the townreads but I'm not sure scum can even TMI in this setup since they don't actually know who their buddy is and thus they can't know for sure who they're townreading is town. It would be a slightly better guess than ours since they have an 87.5% chance of correctly guessing town vs our 77% chance of guessing correctly. A stronger case is needed here.
Once you discern enough people's mains you are informed at that point.
I don't think I will mate. You are obvious scum here voting yet white knighting a villager.
Luther, I still maintain that. I just wanted to see what the reaction to declaring hammer would be. We should lim outside. I think Vanya's identity is clear based on playstyle. Just because Ben is appearing to be town solving doesn't mean they are town. That is a bad reason to townread someone.
I don't think I will mate. You are obvious scum here voting yet white knighting a villager.
Luther, I still maintain that. I just wanted to see what the reaction to declaring hammer would be. We should lim outside. I think Vanya's identity is clear based on playstyle. Just because Ben is appearing to be town solving doesn't mean they are town. That is a bad reason to townread someone.
A TMI tell = Too much information = player has access to extra information usually a scum player knowing people's alignments. "TMIing" is easier than explaining the above.
In post 377, Pogo Hargreeves wrote:I guess I could see why Luther appears to be TMIing with all the townreads but I'm not sure scum can even TMI in this setup since they don't actually know who their buddy is and thus they can't know for sure who they're townreading is town. It would be a slightly better guess than ours since they have an 87.5% chance of correctly guessing town vs our 77% chance of guessing correctly. A stronger case is needed here.
Once you discern enough people's mains you are informed at that point.
Assuming the player discerning knows most of the player list.
In post 266, Ben Hargreeves wrote:Also, I'm going to out my read because I feel like it. I meta read Mini, the person who ego posted after Diego. Mini is Vanya. Allison has had awkward interactions with Diego and myself, including scum reading me for no reason after I scum read the slot assumed to be Mini. Her reason to scum read me was applied inconsistently, voting me for not "hiding my identity" but ignoring commenting on Diego much who did the same.
Once I meta read Mini and realized they were Vanya I thought it was interesting that Minis slot just so happened to be scummy, and I've also gotten a decent amount of pushback for basically no reason today. I assume assume of this is mafia who didn't like my Mini read so pushed me
Allison fits that perfectly and is also scummy in her own right
Allison and Vanya are mafia
Why are you so sure Mini=Vanya?
But it’s odd that Allison would be voting a slot she keeps insisting is town.
But yeah, Vanya is my best guess for scum and Allison’s reasons for calling you scum and Vanya town aren’t making a lot of sense to me - least of all is her reasoning for voting them.
In post 384, Diego Hargreeves wrote:tmi isn't really possible in this setup especially at this point unless someone has somehow found their scum partner
Not true -> Scum receive a red check on what IS their partner's main. Therefore, anyone who is read as a different main is known town.
I don't think I will mate. You are obvious scum here voting yet white knighting a villager.
Luther, I still maintain that. I just wanted to see what the reaction to declaring hammer would be. We should lim outside. I think Vanya's identity is clear based on playstyle. Just because Ben is appearing to be town solving doesn't mean they are town. That is a bad reason to townread someone.
Then why are you stll voting them?
Beetlejuice
Vanya hasn’t even posted since I think yesterday morning, what are you even talking about?
In post 266, Ben Hargreeves wrote:Also, I'm going to out my read because I feel like it. I meta read Mini, the person who ego posted after Diego. Mini is Vanya. Allison has had awkward interactions with Diego and myself, including scum reading me for no reason after I scum read the slot assumed to be Mini. Her reason to scum read me was applied inconsistently, voting me for not "hiding my identity" but ignoring commenting on Diego much who did the same.
Once I meta read Mini and realized they were Vanya I thought it was interesting that Minis slot just so happened to be scummy, and I've also gotten a decent amount of pushback for basically no reason today. I assume assume of this is mafia who didn't like my Mini read so pushed me
Allison fits that perfectly and is also scummy in her own right
Allison and Vanya are mafia
Why are you so sure Mini=Vanya?
But it’s odd that Allison would be voting a slot she keeps insisting is town.
But yeah, Vanya is my best guess for scum and Allison’s reasons for calling you scum and Vanya town aren’t making a lot of sense to me - least of all is her reasoning for voting them.
If you’re trying to get me to switch my read on Vanya, this is having the exact opposite effect. Having reversed readslists is something I’ve seen scum do in games and you not only have me first but two of my strongest townreads immediately follow and you have Vanya last? How are you town here with this shitty a readslist?
If you’re trying to get me to switch my read on Vanya, this is having the exact opposite effect. Having reversed readslists is something I’ve seen scum do in games and you not only have me first but two of my strongest townreads immediately follow and you have Vanya last? How are you town here with this shitty a readslist?
Good thing I don't have to convince scum that I'm town to win lmfao
In post 391, Allison Hargreeves wrote:You came back, and interacted with an old post rather than addressing any current post about you.
It’s not an “old” post if I haven’t read it before. If you’re going to throw out slang shade at people, it might actually be a good idea to bother to understand what it actually means first.
In post 391, Allison Hargreeves wrote:You came back, and interacted with an old post rather than addressing any current post about you.
It’s not an “old” post if I haven’t read it before. If you’re going to throw out slang shade at people, it might actually be a good idea to bother to understand what it actually means first.
If you’re trying to get me to switch my read on Vanya, this is having the exact opposite effect. Having reversed readslists is something I’ve seen scum do in games and you not only have me first but two of my strongest townreads immediately follow and you have Vanya last? How are you town here with this shitty a readslist?
Good thing I don't have to convince scum that I'm town to win lmfao
No if you’re actually town here and this bad, we might lose because of that.
