Large Normal 231 | Etymologies | Game Over

[quiet]

Yeah I’ll wait to respond to the real Bypasser, but quick thoughts:
I figured DGB would be a controversial read. I can do a dive to justify if you want.
Don’t know why locktown andres is all that controversial. I’d be curious why that pinged
Nero is one of my least confident reads, but I liked them better than the people in null. It was the last I put on the list.
Vax and Mom, I think the pings are probably fair.

Strong disagree with you that Bino is obvtown, which is a take I think you gave in reference to their NotMafia response.. They have two games, one scum, one mason, and both post exactly like this. I think them saying “I think NotMafia put me on top of the readlist to try to shade me by association” is just...Binatog.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Vax and Mom, I think the pings are probably fair.

What?

[Norfolk Boy1]

N_M wasting his vote on a slot that’s not got any other votes and ignoring the other leading wagon is weird if scum.

It doesn't seem rational to be hung up on having one vote on you when the vote count has 2 rolling wagons and traction on a third.

What is it about Not Mafia's vote that's got to you?

I’m not allowed to be curious why someone is voting me?

Poor response. Answer, please.

[NorwegianboyEE]

N_M wasting his vote on a slot that’s not got any other votes and ignoring the other leading wagon is weird if scum.

It doesn't seem rational to be hung up on having one vote on you when the vote count has 2 rolling wagons and traction on a third.

What is it about Not Mafia's vote that's got to you?

I’m not allowed to be curious why someone is voting me?

Poor response. Answer, please.

No.

[Bypasser Catcher]

i agree with the No, this line is pointless Norfolk.

[quiet]

What?

I don’t think my stated reasons why I put Vax or Mom where I did were super clear or effective. I think it’s fair for him to not like them.

[NorwegianboyEE]

What?

I don’t think my stated reasons why I put Vax or Mom where I did were super clear or effective. I think it’s fair for him to not like them.

Do you have a more clear reasoning for both those reads then?

[Titus]

Lots of shiny wagons. I like this in the long term.

In the short term, I'm conflicted bc the people I don't think are town are agreeing with me.

And who might that be.

Norwat, Ranny, BBMolla

[Rannygazoo]

Galaxy brain: different browsers for different accounts

[Rannygazoo]

Lots of shiny wagons. I like this in the long term.

In the short term, I'm conflicted bc the people I don't think are town are agreeing with me.

And who might that be.

Norwat, Ranny, BBMolla

I didn’t realize I was your scumread, but I’m mostly curious what I said that you agree with.

[Titus]

Hayker is basically a newbie (based on their meta and play style), and generally newbies look scummy as either alignment. I’m willing to give him a little more leeway than PlusJOYED, given the context.

This makes little sense comparing join dates as BC comments.

[Titus]

Lots of shiny wagons. I like this in the long term.

In the short term, I'm conflicted bc the people I don't think are town are agreeing with me.

And who might that be.

Norwat, Ranny, BBMolla

I didn’t realize I was your scumread, but I’m mostly curious what I said that you agree with.

Hawker vote

[Titus]

I didn’t say meta necessarily supports PlusJOYED over Hayker, I said I’m willing to give Hayker more leeway as they’re basically a newbie.

Really reevaluating my Luca read.

[Titus]

Ok, I missed NM claiming. What was it?

[NorwegianboyEE]

It was an even night weak neighborizer claim and then a tracker crumb just afterwards.

[Titus]

Intent to vote Hawker but I don't want to accidentally hammer.

[Rannygazoo]

im gonna point out what reads i find a bit egregious, or rather I have massive pings on wrt how im viewing the game atm vs ur explainations. yellow = mild red=major

Look, I find quiet’s read list to be without substance too, but I don’t think putting it through the wringer (ringer?) is going to help at this stage. With day 1, 20 players, and a lot of junk without a flip, asking someone to have really sophisticated reads right now is asking a lot.

Quiet’s list might be useful going forward because we can watch if there’s a natural progression going forward, but I don’t think it’s useful now.

[Titus]

It was an even night weak neighborizer claim and then a tracker crumb just afterwards.

Thank you.

[NorwegianboyEE]

I actually like 1441 a lot.

[NorwegianboyEE]

I find it really annoying that Hayker went AWOL just like Cheeky once becoming a wagon.

[Rannygazoo]

Hawker vote

Ok, I missed NM claiming. What was it?

Uh, this is pretty lazy. I voted Hawker because NM claimed and I was sheeping others to get off that wagon. I even said later that I don’t know what makes Hawker stand out from other lurkers. Is lazy the new Titus meta?

[Bypasser Catcher]

im gonna point out what reads i find a bit egregious, or rather I have massive pings on wrt how im viewing the game atm vs ur explainations. yellow = mild red=major

Look, I find quiet’s read list to be without substance too, but I don’t think putting it through the wringer (ringer?) is going to help at this stage. With day 1, 20 players, and a lot of junk without a flip, asking someone to have really sophisticated reads right now is asking a lot.

Quiet’s list might be useful going forward because we can watch if there’s a natural progression going forward, but I don’t think it’s useful now.

I was marking what I thought was bad for future reference in case I die, not primarily for current discussion.

[Bypasser Catcher]

I like to leave a "path to solve the game" for people in the case I die since I tend to die the night before I get my "aha" moment or am on the right track, etc.

[Bypasser Catcher]

Hawker vote

Ok, I missed NM claiming. What was it?

Uh, this is pretty lazy. I voted Hawker because NM claimed and I was sheeping others to get off that wagon. I even said later that I don’t know what makes Hawker stand out from other lurkers. Is lazy the new Titus meta?

judging by recent games I don't think there's anything AI u can gather from the shift in playstyle here from her usual play. Just follow her pushes and judge from there.

[Rannygazoo]

Ok, I thought you were about to tear into it