Post 3--So, not just the title of the game, but the first mod post to start the day explicitly talks about peaches. I know this is hit on a little bit throughout the day, but still worth pointing out.
Post 9--Starting on the first page, Midwaybear talks about “townreading” MurderSunny based on their bringing up peaches. Only worth mentioning given the discussion that happens later. (Retracted in
post 67.)
Post 24--SPF opens by discussing changes she’s planning on making to her typical playstyle here. Always exciting to see someone be so upfront with how they plan to play.
Post 26--First time Noraa jumps on the peach bandwagon.
Post 34--I don’t like this post from SPF. I get that it’s RVS or whatever and nothing matters, but rereading, it gives me bad vibes.
Post 74--Being the third vote on anyone in RVS (also does RVS still exist? what is site meta? What am i doing here?) (which this game quickly starts shifting out of soon) just feels weird and opportunistic, and it’s what SirCakez does here. I agree with Midway’s
post 77 to that effect.
Post 95--WITH THAT SAID, I do like SirCakez vote here, but is it because it’s what I’m thinking too? Idk tbh. I’m just happy I have my computer back.
Post 103--i have not liked a single post SPF has made thus far in my reread and this is no exception.
Post 106--Is this just Noraa? If I’ve been scumreading her because this is how she plays, that’s fine, I guess, but I don’t understand what she’s doing here. The deflection based on her emotional state, the nonsensical posting, the sheer clutter of the game thread...I don’t like any of it, but I might have been hasty to say it’s alignment indicative.
Post 138--Adding this to the list of SPF posts I don’t like. Along with several on this page.
Post 163--This post from SPF deflects with zero explanation. She can then piggyback on more substantive posts later from others. Just scummy stuff.
Post 191--Spring Breeze jumping on the Cheetory train with a clean vote, absent explanation, reads bad.
Post 200--MurderSunny’s lackluster reactions in the first few posts on this page aren’t that helpful, but...who am I to talk?
Post 232--I like this post from midwaybear in general, even if I don’t wholly agree with the conclusions.
Post 237--This post feels opportunistic at best from Zaiden. Maybe I just don’t like the third votes on wagons.
Post 246--What is Noraa doing here at this point?[/post]
Post 270--SERIOUSLY what is Noraa doing? (Coupled with
post 272 and
post 293 where she...softclaims PR? I’m not even sure. Scumreading Noraa hard here.
Post 294--Maybe I’m just blind, but I also don’t understand Jake’s post here, going to town-reading Noraa based on *gestures wildly* THIS.
Post 314--ARGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Post 318--I’m a big fan of Jingle’s post here.
Post 474--Just to respond to this from SPF, I tend to be quite noncommittal in these games, it’s a Mafia game character flaw I have. But I understand why it looks bad.
Post 482--Despite my concerns with Noraa so far, I do agree with SPF’s post here, even if it’s self-interested for me to do so. I’m curious, though, because Noraa’s behaviour SPF townreads appears to be a significant departure from the rest of her posts this game.
Post 500--This feels like a leading post from MWB to Zaiden but maybe I’m reading too much into it.
Post 536I like Spring Breeze’s analysis of SirCakez here, and by “like”, I mean it’s something I agree with.
Post 544Clidd seems eager to defend midwaybear with his first substantive post.
Post 575--Highlighting this question about my team’s experience with noraa to ensure I respond to it later.
Post 624--This vote from SPF feels out of nowhere compared to her previous posts.
Post 628--As much as I love Jingle’s post leading the town earlier, I’m not as big of a fan of Gypyx’s naked speculation here.
Post 635--I think Zaiden is town.
Post 651--I’m baffled at Noraa putting us as town here, based on those explanations, but as I’ve made abundantly clear to myself at this point, Noraa baffles me.
Post 706--Noraa telling everyone how folks are supposed to read two slots if they are town is not good.
Post 725--I really don’t like this post from Pink Ball given that Pink is pushing...Spring Breeze, at this point? Someone who they haven’t mentioned in a hot minute, and don’t try to push immediately after this post. Pink goes on this page to mention that they’re exclusively focusing on Spring Breeze, but...don’t focus on Pink Ball.
Post 770--Is Gypyx’s thought accurate here, that longer days give scum an advantage?
Post 774--I don’t like someone voting somewhere exclusively because they’re told to, and then stating that as the reason for the vote, like Gypyx does here.
Post 788--This is one of many posts that I don’t quite get from Gamma. Unlike Noraa before him, he’s saying, well, not even a LOT while saying nothing.
Post 798--I liked Zaiden’s previous posts, but the AtE to get votes off his back here isn’t great. Still lightly townreading him though.
Post 823--I don’t understand what mwb’s problem with Jake is here, given that MWB admits that Gamma’s response to Jake’s query wasn’t great.
Post 876--Going off PB’s logic from before, he didn’t feel like pushing his scumread Zaiden before (who got a fair number of votes), but did feel like immediately jumping on a Noraa wagon?
Post 891--I generally like Morning Tweet’s opening read thread here. Good observations broadly, but I would have preferred to see any thoughts on scummy things.
Post 904--MT asks if it’s helpful to do what I’m doing right now, in this post. Now I’m starting to get concerned.
Post 935--MT’s summary is pretty good, and I feel suspicious of Noraa for a lot of the same reasons they point out here, which is biasing me to town read her (MT).
Post 953--SPF puts into words some bad vibes I’ve been having re: Gypyx and Cheetory for a bit but haven’t managed to elucidate yet.
Post 998--Noraa believes that S_S is scum and also that Midway is scum, but is voting for Jingle.
Post 1008--This is just weird and insincere-reading to me. (Also
post 1013 is forced as hell.)
Post 1086--Noraa still had ME in the town bucket as of the previous page of this game, but notes that “overwhelming confidence in flimsy reasons generally comes from scum or noob town”. Is she intentionally being farcical?
Post 1195--Zaiden’s wall was hard for me to read, took me fifteen minutes to get through. I’m still townreading Zaiden though. I think he’s generally earnestly engaging with the game.
Post 1294--I’m notably against self-meta (even though I think I break my own rule in this post). But Maria is generally a null-read for me now anyway.
Post 1343--I hate this post from Noraa. Soft-confirming the “claim” and while she’s having a fair amount of heat...I really don’t like it. (she also implies that scum never self-destruct in
post 1349 which just seems blatantly wrong?)
Post 1412--This post from MurderSunny feels out of nowhere but idk. I am interested in what he thinks the link between Cake and Maria comes from. (Never really got an answer on this.
Post 1464--I think Cheetory and Zaiden are both town (though I’m more confident in Zaiden town).
