I had that Murder was solidly town because I thought that Kanna would push him herself instead of using Infinity as a medium and I think the progression was reasonable.In post 3427, Something_Smart wrote:Really?In post 3426, midwaybear wrote:Also, are you not townreading Murdercat? I felt like he was super town off of the Kanna flip.
Murdercat:
- hard pushed Cakez
- voted SB when the wagon was already high (6th vote if I counted right)
- did not unvote when SB softed, but unvoted when she claimed (in a way that was directly contradictory to her soft), saying he needed more time to think about it
- continued to shade her, including saying "let's just flip her" twice... but also suggested starting wagons on both Cakez and Maria
- didn't revote her ever
Also, he sticks out like a sore thumb if you look at a comparison of SB's reads to the playerlist sorted by post count (2589); he is in the middle by post count but at the top of her reads, which might imply an ulterior motive for putting him there.
I don't really see what is wrong with voting Cakez instead of Spring Breeze. I think unvoting at her claim is not super suspicious (after all most people were pretty hesitant at that time). I'm not sure shading her while proposing alternatives is necessarily AI.