Titus v Nancy Drew (Game Over)

[Battle Mage]

"I call it "the DK tell"
If someone that is typically unlikeable and not charismatic is suddenly charismatic and towny, they are scum. If you agree with everything they say and find them an absolute beacon of towniness, they are scum. Period."


wow, charming thanks. so your foolproof scum case is "BM is usually a big smelly jerk, and he's being nice and useful here. Let's kill him NOW"? The big flaw in the case is, your flattering assessment of my personality is...not AI. Or are you saying I'm unlikeable and not charismatic as town, but charismatic and friendly as scum?

to be fair I'm convinced and am willing to vote you sorry

lol no probs

[Saudade]

I'd do it for the memes honestly

[Batsunami]

wow, charming thanks. so your foolproof scum case is "BM is usually a big smelly jerk, and he's being nice and useful here. Let's kill him NOW"? The big flaw in the case is, your flattering assessment of my personality is...not AI. Or are you saying I'm unlikeable and not charismatic as town, but charismatic and friendly as scum?

no but if I always find town you an absolute scumbucket but think ur the towniest beacon of light here, you are most definitely scum here.

[Saudade]

have you ever caught scum BM before

[Battle Mage]

jesus christ you just called battle mage unlikable and uncharismatic while wanting to eliminate him

i mean technically she said i'm normally a douchebag but here I'm being nice, but it doesn't matter I should be killed regardless.

[Nancy Drew 39]

BM last time got miselimed for being absent, being scummy, he argued more, can't exactly remember all the details but he was met with suspicion pretty early and then mastina cased him into the grave.

This game shares the similarity of someone hard tunneling him convinced it's him, although this time it's because he's playing noticeably in a way that is a lot more towny and agreeable. It's not enough for a high scumread from me but i did notice the difference without Noraa pointing it out to me. BM is quite towny as scum -- I'm not really trying to say we should scumread him for playing protown, it's more just the vibes he gives off than anything else. We've yet to see whether or not he fits to playing with a town agenda or not, i just find the way he's presented himself so far interesting

~Bat

Okay, definitely something to think about. I just don’t want to see anyone get run up this early until I have a broader read on the gamestate but both you and Pyro are agreeing here, so something I probably shouldn’t ignore.

[Batsunami]

Can you elaborate on this? I recall you had killer reads in the dead thread last game.

give me specifics.

I want you to explain your readslist.

I might post a wall on this later when I have time. It'll take like a solid hour for my to write tho cuz explaining my thought process is hard so sit tight and wait.

[Battle Mage]

wow, charming thanks. so your foolproof scum case is "BM is usually a big smelly jerk, and he's being nice and useful here. Let's kill him NOW"? The big flaw in the case is, your flattering assessment of my personality is...not AI. Or are you saying I'm unlikeable and not charismatic as town, but charismatic and friendly as scum?

no but if I always find town you an absolute scumbucket but think ur the towniest beacon of light here, you are most definitely scum here.

or you just improved at reading me....and then bottled it and started second guessing yourself?

[Batsunami]

have you ever caught scum BM before

Yeah but he repped in and his slot was already doomed so I wouldn't take too much credit for that.

[Saudade]

BM if she's wrong, would you want her lynched the day after?

[Nancy Drew 39]

I don't get responding to the scum stump at all. Every time someone does it, I keep thinking it has potential to be wacky distancing, or they're just easily annoyed.

This post is responding to me.

How do you figure that?

[Batsunami]

wow, charming thanks. so your foolproof scum case is "BM is usually a big smelly jerk, and he's being nice and useful here. Let's kill him NOW"? The big flaw in the case is, your flattering assessment of my personality is...not AI. Or are you saying I'm unlikeable and not charismatic as town, but charismatic and friendly as scum?

no but if I always find town you an absolute scumbucket but think ur the towniest beacon of light here, you are most definitely scum here.

or you just improved at reading me....and then bottled it and started second guessing yourself?

no. reads do not change like that.

[Battle Mage]

BM last time got miselimed for being absent, being scummy, he argued more, can't exactly remember all the details but he was met with suspicion pretty early and then mastina cased him into the grave.

This game shares the similarity of someone hard tunneling him convinced it's him, although this time it's because he's playing noticeably in a way that is a lot more towny and agreeable. It's not enough for a high scumread from me but i did notice the difference without Noraa pointing it out to me. BM is quite towny as scum -- I'm not really trying to say we should scumread him for playing protown, it's more just the vibes he gives off than anything else. We've yet to see whether or not he fits to playing with a town agenda or not, i just find the way he's presented himself so far interesting

~Bat

Okay, definitely something to think about. I just don’t want to see anyone get run up this early until I have a broader read on the gamestate but both you and Pyro are agreeing here, so something I probably shouldn’t ignore.

Nancy, can you please quickly summarise for me what the argument from Noraa is, in totality, for me being scum?

I'm assuming it's not purely this thing about me being nice?

[Battle Mage]

BM if she's wrong, would you want her lynched the day after?

no, im pretty sure she's town

[Battle Mage]

wow, charming thanks. so your foolproof scum case is "BM is usually a big smelly jerk, and he's being nice and useful here. Let's kill him NOW"? The big flaw in the case is, your flattering assessment of my personality is...not AI. Or are you saying I'm unlikeable and not charismatic as town, but charismatic and friendly as scum?

no but if I always find town you an absolute scumbucket but think ur the towniest beacon of light here, you are most definitely scum here.

or you just improved at reading me....and then bottled it and started second guessing yourself?

no. reads do not change like that.

alternatively, maybe i am just being townier than normal here...as town.

[Batsunami]

I'm assuming it's not purely this thing about me being nice?

good one.
But that tell has caught many scum before. it is something very big that is enough to make you more than confscum in my eyes. That is how accurate that tell is.

[Battle Mage]

although in fairness im normally pretty townie

[Nancy Drew 39]

Who’s “redacted”? Do we get to find that out or no? Well, this will definitely help me the next time I play with DK!scum.

You'll find out soon enough who [redacted] is

Can’t wait.

[Saudade]

Well now that we know who we are eliminating today, lets talk about other people

[Saudade]

lets talk about me

[Battle Mage]

I'm assuming it's not purely this thing about me being nice?

good one.
But that tell has caught many scum before. it is something very big that is enough to make you more than confscum in my eyes. That is how accurate that tell is.

you're joking right...?

please actually tell me if that's it, or there's something else?

[Saudade]

me and my BIG

[Nancy Drew 39]

Nancy I'm bringing my A-game because I feel it's owed. I hope this isn't mistreated...

How do you mean, “mistreated”?

[Batsunami]

alternatively, maybe i am just being townier than normal here...as town.

No. This reeks of scum DK. Trying to explain to me why I find you townier is not the right response.

When I questioning DK, they told me "Nora have you ever considered character development"

No. things do not work like that. People do not change that drastically that fast.

Town do not explain to me. Town tell me "Noraa stop bullshitting"

Scum try to explain.

[Gamma Emerald]

what the fuck is this game