Titus v Nancy Drew (Game Over)

[ItalianoVD]

Also I don’t know who Saudade is. Is it common for him to troll Day 1 and get more involved thereafter? I’ve seen more posts today that seems like he’s putting forth effort? I see a few people scumread him, but what is it really? I’m voting him based on my gut and our interaction, but if that’s not feasible I need someone to tell me why.

[clidd]

He trolls as both alignments, but I noticed that he plays the game better as town comparatively and it is possible to tell when he is engaged in solving or not.

So far I am interpreting the slot as scum.

[Saudade]

I think you want me to be scum more than you believe me to be scum

[clidd]

I've heard that argument before.

[clidd]

Do you think I should townread you here?

[Saudade]

I'd townread me

[Batsunami]

I think voting for italiano was nonsensical since italiano is clearly playing a lot different than he does as mafia, not just you but sherlock & watson + gamma should know that as well

but primarily I think your over the top abrasiveness is deliberate to make yourself seem too bold to be mafia

This hearkens back to this, i assume

I'm too cynical to not think of it as a strategy

Again, though, i wonder how much of this is covered by Saudade's baseline play which is very abrasive to begin with.

Ooh, so you expect Saudade to know better with regards to Italiano's alignment. but saudade's vote came really early, like within italianos first few posts. Have the three of you played together before to the extent where it makes sense to expect town!Saudade to read him correctly and quickly?

~Bat

[ItalianoVD]

He trolls as both alignments, but I noticed that he plays the game better as town comparatively and it is possible to tell when he is engaged in solving or not.

So far I am interpreting the slot as scum.

Okay I see, but what I’m trying to figure out is if he only seems to care more specifically on Day 2’s because it’s actually in his meta to have terrible starts or because he’s getting some heat today.

[ItalianoVD]

I’d ask him, but I’d prefer a non-troll answer.

[Saudade]

You're so defensive and insecure over my vote at page 20 and I hope its because you're scum and not a character trait of yours

[Batsunami]

Feel like Sherlock would be less likely to press that as scum

Is this a meta thought?

Thoughts on replacements, in my experience, are kinda unsavoury things that make a townie get really sure and confbiased on a read even though it's kinda eh to bring it up. I find it more likely that Sherlock would want to immediately slam dunk BM so hard + utilizing reasoning like that as confirm biased town rather than scum.

It's still possible for him to do as scum I just lean against it because it makes more sense in my mind for town to do. this also generally goes along with the idea that scum (for the most part) wouldn't feel the need to push BM very hard

Oh, and here's my interpretation of where scum is most likely to be based loosely off of where my townreads aren't as well as where i'd predict them to go

Spoiler:

VOTE COUNT 1 . Final

• Battle Mage
  --------- 9 ( Morty and Rick, Sherlock and Watson, Fey, Titus, Pyro,
  Dunnstral, Red Eye Knights, Starcrossed, ItalianoVD,
  Batsunami )
  Flipping
  
  
  Saudade
  ------------- 3 (
  War and Peace, clidd, Gamma Emerald
  , Nancy Drew 39 )
  F- 6
  
  
  War and Peace
  ------- 1 ( 5uffering )
  F- 8
  
  
  Fey
  ----------------- 1 ( Saudade )
  F- 8
  
  
  Sherlock and Watson
  - 1 ( Battle Mage )
  F- 8
  
  
  
  Not Voting
  ---------- 2 (
  SaraharaS(1), Toogeloo(27)
  )

I think there's 2-3 in the red and 1-2 in the orange.

~Bat

[Saudade]

Noraa do you love me

[Batsunami]

Noraa do you love me

yeah.

[Saudade]

SEE ALISAE I DONT NEED YOU

[clidd]

Morty, Sherlock, Fey and Pyro are a very strong set. I don't think they are all town.

[clidd]

5suf is also strong, but my paranoia about him has dissipated. I believe he's likely town.

[clidd]

Saudade still has to actively engage and show some town brilliance, if he's town here.

[Saudade]

is this guy just scum

[Saudade]

nothing you say about me is connected to reality lol

[clidd]

Do you think I'm scum?

[Saudade]

Scum or a very
very
very
delusional player

[clidd]

I've heard that argument before too.

[ItalianoVD]

You're so defensive and insecure over my vote at page 20 and I hope its because you're scum and not a character trait of yours

My annoyance and frustration is/was real and has nothing to do with my alignment. I’ve played with players who believe they are God’s gift to this game. I’ve been mislynched by them and I’ve been partners with them and they think they are better than they actually are. These people generally have poor scumhunting percentages, but focus on the few times they caught scum early and run big on that. The actual good scumhunters don’t boast how amazing and “brilliant” they are.

I surmised what type of player you were from our interaction and so I immediately placed you in that group. In my experience your jump onto me play is a scum/wolf play. You’re interaction with the playerlist is also scum/wolf play, but you’re Day 2 postings makes me question whether your trolling backfired on you and you’re trying to save face or you are actually trying to get more involved because that’s just your early m.o.

[clidd]

So .. Is the brilliance going to happen, Saudade?

[clidd]

You've built a narrative and trying to fit me into it.

You said before that I was trying to fit you into a narrative.

I would like you to expand what kind of narrative.