Micro 998 | The Binding of Isaac Mafia | Game Over

[Costello]

You have given extremely, extremely little beyond immediate answers/reactions of you being broadly wary, that in total leave your overall feelings outside of me ambiguous.

The most substantial post is 596.

[madeline]

sure if that's what you take from it

[Costello]

The issue here is there's little reason to categorically refuse to give a brief summary, or engage in even remotely good faith the last 10 minutes, for any reason other than spite.

In contrast, while I am absolutely voting you out of spite and am currently voting to concede because I'd rather lose than carry you to a town win, you have every incentive to play the paranoid moron who never outs any other reads of substance as scum.

[madeline]

The issue here is there's little reason to categorically refuse to give a brief summary, or engage in even remotely good faith the last 10 minutes, for any reason other than spite.

In contrast, while I am absolutely voting you out of spite and am currently voting to concede because I'd rather lose than carry you to a town win, you have every incentive to play the paranoid moron who never outs any other reads of substance as scum.

if someone else were interested, do you think the situation would be the same? like had hectic or ydrasse or farkran or flea or bugspray asked?

[Costello]

The issue here is there's little reason to categorically refuse to give a brief summary, or engage in even remotely good faith the last 10 minutes, for any reason other than spite.

In contrast, while I am absolutely voting you out of spite and am currently voting to concede because I'd rather lose than carry you to a town win, you have every incentive to play the paranoid moron who never outs any other reads of substance as scum.

if someone else were interested, do you think the situation would be the same? like had hectic or ydrasse or farkran or flea or bugspray asked?

I would fucking hope so, jesus christ

[Costello]

Hope that it was different*

[Costello]

I have been more than happy to this point to assume the worst in you, and would be extremely happy to leave questioning you to others!

If only anyone actually bothered to call you on garbage, but they don't. They do like I have and have left you to sit. And so the task falls back to me.

And while I'd like to just concede the game immediately and get out, there is fortunately one more option: If we vote right, I'm only stuck in here for 4 more irl days!

So here I am! Step 1!

[madeline]

like you get upset with me, keep saying i'm terrible, decide that i need to prove to you specifically i am town once again, and i am supposed to just assume you are town? because you say things like 'i am constantly reevaluating' which simply means that as mafia you would know to do things like 'farkran is definitely mafia' ope 'farkran is town now!'

[madeline]

just add me to the 'assumed town' pile

{costello, hectic, madeline}

and tada

[Costello]

like you get upset with me, keep saying i'm terrible, decide that i need to prove to you specifically i am town once again,

and i am supposed to just assume you are town?

because you say things like 'i am constantly reevaluating' which simply means that as mafia you would know to do things like 'farkran is definitely mafia' ope 'farkran is town now!'

This is my intent if I am scum

Spoiler: This is not at all my intent if I am town.

[Costello]

Also Farkran has literally never left my PoE lol, he's never dropped below #2.

[Costello]

You have to do work to prove that I am mafia and convince other people to vote me.

If you don't want to dialogue with me you don't have to, but let me be clear: Me forcing this conversation is doing your job for you.

[Costello]

The line about Farkran is great, but is there more? And why do I have to pull teeth to get something you should be laying out to other players?

[Costello]

because you say things like 'i am constantly reevaluating' which simply means that as mafia you would know to do things like 'farkran is definitely mafia' ope 'farkran is town now!'

Can you be a bit more specific as to why I need to make this switch?

[madeline]

because you say things like 'i am constantly reevaluating' which simply means that as mafia you would know to do things like 'farkran is definitely mafia' ope 'farkran is town now!'

Can you be a bit more specific as to why I need to make this switch?

as mafia it would be to give a believable read and because it works in favour of the clearing yourself through endgame

[madeline]

like function as though my scumread is town until f3 and then kill them!

[madeline]

like function as though my scumread is town until f3 and then kill them!

is your gameplan

[Costello]

I'm satisfied for now.

UNVOTE:

Onto Ydrasse.

Unclear what the distinction is between "believable read" and my actual read on Farkran is, also that plan doesn't actually work because it nets town a free clear. The better angle here is that I'm expected to play optimally as town, ie. get the overnight clear, and am forced to swap for that reason.

[madeline]

Onto Ydrasse.

like if you're town and confident hectic is town finding one town in {ydrasse, bugspray, flea, farkran} solves the game so i get it

[Costello]

The town in that, without even needing to reread, is bugspray and it's not even close.

It is not enough for me, as a player and a human being, to merely be correct, and it is not enough to win the game even if it were.

[madeline]

It is not enough for me, as a player and a human being, to merely be correct, and it is not enough to win the game even if it were.

? how would four towns right now not be enough to win the game

[Costello]

Does the game end if I, individually, am correct?

[madeline]

Does the game end if I, individually, am correct?

oh i guess i was equating your 'winning the game' with my 'solving the game' sorry

[Costello]

If you felt my swap from Farkran was opportunistic/scum motivated-is there a reason you didn't press it or ask for elaboration earlier?

Looking at Gacha Mafia you are a lot more direct about asking players about progressions.

[madeline]

If you felt my swap from Farkran was opportunistic/scum motivated-is there a reason you didn't press it or ask for elaboration earlier?

Looking at Gacha Mafia you are a lot more direct about asking players about progressions.

i was mafia in gacha mafia...