Raw, Unfiltered, UPICK Game Over !

[Grendel]

I dont necessarily think Titus/Grey are scum together. I think its a possibility worth acknowledging. But dont really have anything that points to it specifically.

I think that Titus mentioning that I should be worried about the players not scum reading me is interesting. I think that Titus wouldn't say that if Mark was her buddy. It seems like a set-up for a tunnel tomorrow on Titus's PoV. I mean i flip today and she comes in tomorrow swinging at Mark. afaik Mark is the only one openly saying that im town right? I guess it could also be a point against Cass/Dannfour teams with Titus as well. Tho im not worried about a world where Cass AND Dann are scum.

In a titus scum world i would just sub in Jesse/Pooky and Grey, as the next place to go.

[Grendel]

Pooky is somebody to keep an eye on. I've heard from others and the bear himself that his scum game is flawless.

[MathBlade]

I think Jesse is a good place if not Grendel

[MathBlade]

Staring at the setup I think I know how scum “vig” could exist and why no CC just am waffling hard on how to prove it.

[MathBlade]

VOTE: Jesse

Let’s do this

[MathBlade]

Then Grendel shoots Grey

[MathBlade]

Thoughts?

[MathBlade]

Nah Grendel doesn’t shoot Grey.

[Titus]

Staring at the setup I think I know how scum “vig” could exist and why no CC just am waffling hard on how to prove it.

VOTE: Jesse

Let’s do this

Why this stance back to back? Why not just explain your idea?

[MathBlade]

Staring at the setup I think I know how scum “vig” could exist and why no CC just am waffling hard on how to prove it.

VOTE: Jesse

Let’s do this

Why this stance back to back? Why not just explain your idea?

Because I am not 100% fleshed out and trying to balance it in my head and which of you/Grey scum it requires.

If I am wrong whichever of you is scum will 100% take advantage.

So I am voting currently the player I think is scum regardless of Grendel’s alignment.

[Dannflor]

VOTE: jessie

[Titus]

I still think Grendel is the proper play here, but if I am outvoted pressuring a sub for content isn't bad.

VOTE: Jessie

[MathBlade]

I still think Grendel is the proper play here, but if I am outvoted pressuring a sub for content isn't bad.

VOTE: Jessie

Grendel is the smart play if he was anything besides vig.

There’s no way to tell if it’s a factional soup or if it’s an actual vig.

If it’s a factional flavor vig (and Grendel is scum) then I am the only one but I have claimed multiple flavors and scum have to guess which is correct to hit me. Where as if it is a vig, I can ask Grendel to holster or hit scum.

It can’t be a factional role vig as Vax’s role was unclaimed along with Kop.

So by doing claims the way I did, it ensures that I am the kill when if Grendel is town my PR was useless as I am blocked anyway. This is more about buying time for everyone to figure it out and limiting fake claims.

The Oracle (if Misty is town) should be able to ask questions based on category claims based on the wiki if she is town that way it wouldn’t be alignment indicative but catch scum.

So then if I live, scum considered Misty the bigger threat which means scum blocked me probably leaving PRs to do their thing and the focus will be on the non conf town

[MathBlade]

VOTE: Unvote

Preventing quick hammers

[Marky Mark]

Yeah let's not vote slots actively being replaced. Doesn't really achieve pressure and I'd want to hear what they have to say first anyway seeing as math seems to think he can make useful deductions from the claim

[Marky Mark]

Ah wait ignore my previous its been a long day. I've just twigged that pookie IS jessie

[Marky Mark]

nah wait, he's not. He's NK15.

[Marky Mark]

To summarise my train of thought live in the thread, voting jesse slot here doesn't achieve loads

VOTE: Pookie is better here for what you lot are trying to achieve. Let's have their category claim.

[Marky Mark]

VOTE: Unvote

Preventing quick hammers

Also, a quick hammer doesn't feel super likely to happen here and would be a borderline scum claim, so I'm wondering how much an experienced player like you actually believes this

[Marky Mark]

I'm still yet to hear an argument that would convince me that grendel could have more than a tiny chance of being the mafia faction. SK is more believable, but I'm just TRing mistyx too hard for that theory to seem plausible to me

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

sup

[Marky Mark]

Outside hero call here that math is scum. Blocked loyal X ought not to be too hard to fake and the push on jesse while the slot is vacant feels opportunistic. Nothing esp useful has come out of the semi-claim yet either, as far as I can see

[Marky Mark]

sup pookie, let's have your category claim pls

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

i dont fit into any category

call me a chocolate townie

[Marky Mark]

Interesting. Where do you sit on the whole grendel situation? Do you think he is caught scum/SK from Math's loyal targetting or do you think he is legit town vig and math was either RBed or is himself scum?