Open 807 | Town Win

[Something_Smart]

theres no way this is a town thing to do in what fantasy world does town play this way

I mean... you have met A50 before, right?

[Almost50]

theres no way this is a town thing to do in what fantasy world does town play this way

Proof you don't even come close to knowing my play, dude. I'll be using this as evidence in future games.

[Scipio1]

i see no reason for scum!a50 to retract when he was convincing me of pooky!scum and probably would've won the dome

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

ive literally never seen any1 fake a guilty as town in mylo before what

[Almost50]

theres no way this is a town thing to do in what fantasy world does town play this way

I mean... you have met A50 before, right?

^^^

EVen more surprised S_S knows me more than Pooky (I've been playing with Pooky for like 5-6 consecutive games now)

[Almost50]

ive literally never seen any1 fake a guilty as town in mylo before what

You did now.

[Scipio1]

i don't think pooky's reaction is particularly town indicative, and i still think it's odd that he wasn't NKed

[Something_Smart]

ive literally never seen any1 fake a guilty as town in mylo before what

I don't think I have either, but I also don't think I've ever seen scum claim and retract a guilty like this.

I don't want to say too much before Salsa claims, but I'm having a hard time understanding why scum-A50 would switch his target to Salsa, whom multiple people had just called town.

[Something_Smart]

i don't think pooky's reaction is particularly town indicative

Agree with this. I think Pooky probably reacts pretty much the same regardless of alignment.

[Almost50]

i still think it's odd that he wasn't NKed

I do too. tbh, but "maybe" it was done precisely to set him up? I dunno. I just "feel" (GOD, I HATE to use this word in Mafia) like if he was Scum he would have reacted in a different way. I just can't explain it in words.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

lol burden of being alive

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

UNVOTE: A50

[implosion]

A50, why not target me, the claimed VT, who has a ton of suspicion on him?

(also; we are no-limming and a50 is targeting me here, yes?)

[Salsabil Faria]

@Salsa why is SS last in your PoE?

Mainly because of

PookytheMagicalBear

's position in my list. I still townread them but if they are the scum here, then clearly I'm in their deep pocket? I also townread

Something_Smart

, so between these 2, with the consideration of scum!

PookytheMagicalBear

's pocketing attempt,

Something_Smart

is townier than them.

btw we should no-elim today, right

Wait, we will be on mylo tomorrow on Day 5, aren't we? Then no elimination will be the best for the town ig.

UNVOTE: Almost50

VOTE: No Elimination

VOTE: Pooky

Never thought that the CAPTAIN of the Police Department was indeed our Kira. Well done, "Light Yagami "

I guess I should claim now. I am the Nea, and Scipio is a VT, while Pooky is not. My first check was on N_M but he died on the same night. (which is why I got frustrated bc I picked N_M thinking NO WAY he eats a bullet on N1)

Umm... after the nk1, it was/is

almost

cleared that the scum team didn't take any PR role for them (?), which means the town only had 2 PRs those are already dead. I don't even understand what role you claimed but

nice try

you know!

Before anyone asks; I decided to check Pooky for 2 reasons: (1) Him being alive while being "the leader" didn't make much sense to me,

i don't think pooky's reaction is particularly town indicative, and i still think it's odd that he wasn't NKed

Their being alive while being the leader didn't stop the last 2 miseliminations, which means scum is having benefit from not killing them?

salsa has a50 in her sights so of course he makes the desperation fake claim at mylo cuz he only needs one more miselim to win the game.

VOTE: a50

Am I a good rookie then?

Salsa -> me -> Scipio for the remaining claim order?

VT

you don't check the guy that's gonna be limmed the next day as an investigative cus they're dead anyways... optimally you check the players who aren't super scummy or super towny

We should stop replying for others

salsa>implo>s_s imo, although I'm not confident in this

Salsa?? I thought you said she was likely Town! What caused you to change your read there??

it's ordered from town to scum, sry

Why do you scumread

Something_Smart

?

a50 is spewing Salsa as town and Scipio as town, means the last scum is between Implo and SS.

Ummm.... he spewing

Scipio1

as town ig?
Do you still think it's

implosion

?

hm

the only thing I find a bit weird is that a50 tried to NK bait by ‘soft’ ccing mini which wouldn’t make sense to do as a PR. A50, can you explain?

I can now. A bit too preemptive, but if I go on further it could result in a town loss.

My actual guilty was on SALSA, not Pooky. HOWEVER, I wanted to take a shot in the dark and reaction test Pooky (just in case). I am not 100% confident still, but I think his reaction is more Townie than not.

Your question here pings me as Town too. Let's take this one step at a time:

1- Scum already know how many TPRs are left alive. If 0 they know my claim is BS, and if 1 they found their final NK target.

2- Based on the above; S_S is Town by virtue of calling for the mass claim after I fake claimed

3- ALSO Scipio is Town because Scum have no incentive to throw shade on what they already know/think is a fake/true TPR claim. Either way "their job" is being done for them.

4- Scum will be more reluctant than Town top actually VOTE Pooky here. They have a winning situation if one more vote is casted on Pooky and they can then quick hammer. UNFORTUNATELY; I didn't get to test that and will have to abort my gambit prematurely, but I think I got what I needed.

So Salsa + implo is my soleve.

@Pooky: I can't believe YOU fell for THAT. I mean, you did know it was a bluff, but I'm surprised you failed to see what it was done for.

In fact, if A50 is traitor, it makes perfect sense for him to do this if Salsa is main scum and didn't realize she was pushing her own traitor.

Is this allowed that the last scum and the traitor can give hints to each other in the day phase?

A50, why not target me, the claimed VT, who has a ton of suspicion on him?

@Almost50

...

[Something_Smart]

VT.

[Something_Smart]

(also; we are no-limming and a50 is targeting me here, yes?)

Yes.

[Something_Smart]

Is this allowed that the last scum and the traitor can give hints to each other in the day phase?

Sure, why not?

I mean, if A50 is the traitor, then he's hinting to his partner whoever they are, because they obviously know that there isn't another PR. But at that time, it made sense to me that he might want to hint specifically to you, so that you would know to stop pushing him. (Obviously, it doesn't make sense anymore.)

[Something_Smart]

VOTE: No Exe

[implosion]

also a50.

if you're gonna do reaction testing BS why did you say that your actual guilty was on salsabil... before she claimed VT? Couldn't she have been a town PR?

[Scipio1]

i'm confused now

Umm... after the nk1, it was/is almost cleared that the scum team didn't take any PR role for them (?), which means the town only had 2 PRs those are already dead. I don't even understand what role you claimed but nice try you know!

what does this mean

[Almost50]

I don't think No Lim is the way to go, but... I am only one vote out of six.

@implo: I very much doubt scum would pick a PR to give to the Traitor and keep one of them (the flipped) as a Goon. It made no sense to me, so I expect to be the last PR alive.

[Almost50]

i'm confused now

Umm... after the nk1, it was/is almost cleared that the scum team didn't take any PR role for them (?), which means the town only had 2 PRs those are already dead. I don't even understand what role you claimed but nice try you know!

what does this mean

She's saying I am fake claiming.

[Almost50]

I also don't see why I need to check anyone else. The "Traitor" returns a "VT" result to Ne (unless they did get a PR which is something I don't think is true). Like, if I checked everyone alive -other than Salsa- I would get "Vanilla Town", so what's the point?

[Something_Smart]

The "Traitor" returns a "VT" result to Ne

...no they don't? traitor is not VT...

[Almost50]

Check the Traitor's wiki page (and note that this is an OPEN not a NORMAL)