DEFCON Mafia 5.0: GAME OVER - NEW AMERICA FORMED

[Save The Dragons]

POOKY NO

OUR PRES HAS BEEN ASSASSINATED

LONG LIVE LLD'S REIGN AS PRES

One of these two is scum. Mark my words.

this seems like an easy attack based on a trope that's probably false

[gorilla]

why T3?

see 1367

full disclosure: I didn't really think mastina was flipping scum but saw no reason to oppose the wagon. I don't think T3 looks any better in light of the flip

[Save The Dragons]

the post that pinged me from Save the Dragons on rr 1595. it feels like he is too aware of the fallacy of mognet's argument.

like i feel bad about this read in a sense cuz he was defending me there. but my intuition tells me that town reading my argument w/ mognet would be more likely to be unsure... or even just have their eyes glaze over.

i'm guilty of saying "i think" or "probably" all the time because i never want to be sure if i'm not 100% sure so i'm pretty in tune with that argument. people read it and make the mistake of thinking you're not confident or that you're admitting you're wrong when in reality sometimes i'm 99.9% sure but since i have that little bit of doubt i don't say it with full confidence.

[Save The Dragons]

why T3?

see 1367

full disclosure: I didn't really think mastina was flipping scum but saw no reason to oppose the wagon. I don't think T3 looks any better in light of the flip

missed that in my skimthru, you can be off the shitlist i think you're not wrong that it seems forced

[Bell]

We should probably be killing VFP he's thread avoiding on purpose.

[Bell]

Happy mother's day.

[Et Al]

And if she is not chainsawing because she is town then you’re still a scumread.

Sure, that's reasonable. I was just thrown off because the positioning of your vote in between comments made me think that the vote was related to the comments.

-S

[gorilla]

VOTE: VFP

[Nexus]

POOKY NO

OUR PRES HAS BEEN ASSASSINATED

LONG LIVE LLD'S REIGN AS PRES

One of these two is scum. Mark my words.

this seems like an easy attack based on a trope that's probably false

It's you then. Sadge.

[Save The Dragons]

do you think i'm the terrorist?

[VFP]

We should probably be killing VFP he's thread avoiding on purpose.

Ew, your one of those players...
I've posted in a game that finished today. It's a busy day and I'm not here to post on demand for you.

That aside.
Why is Marry not eliminated yet?

[Titus]

Why should she be eliminated?

[VFP]

Why should she be eliminated?

Because they're scum.
Yesterday, they came in, soft defended mastina and then backed off from the smallest amount of heat.
If you're going to defend someone, you stick by it or agree with the reasons given to you.
Comes into the thread today and tries to buddy up to LLD.

[joqiza]

i feel like marry would've been more collected there as scum tbh

[VFP]

i feel like marry would've been more collected there as scum tbh

It's pretty hard to stay collected in that situation with fake defends.
Any experience to share that suggest why you think this?

[Mognet]

VFP, assume Marry is scum. Why does scum Marry fake claim eavesdropper multiple times?

[marry]

POOKY NO

OUR PRES HAS BEEN ASSASSINATED

LONG LIVE LLD'S REIGN AS PRES

One of these two is scum. Mark my words.

this seems like an easy attack based on a trope that's probably false

i didn’t even acknowledge the post with a response bc i thought the same thing so im glad someone said it

[joqiza]

well i've seen her play mafia before and she knows how to bus. actually she's hardbussed several times before and she rarely defends her partners as directly as she did w/ mastina against LLD. i think her frustration with LLD was genuine too altho the frustration is less AI.

also like i said earlier i really doubt the mastina wagon was some big shock to scum. there was a fair amount of pressure on her the day before. also LLD wasn't even the first vote on the mastina wagon. she was the one that actually effected the lim but i believe she was the third or fourth vote. so the wheels were already starting to spin at that point.

[Nexus]

POOKY NO

OUR PRES HAS BEEN ASSASSINATED

LONG LIVE LLD'S REIGN AS PRES

One of these two is scum. Mark my words.

this seems like an easy attack based on a trope that's probably false

i didn’t even acknowledge the post with a response bc i thought the same thing so im glad someone said it

See, not responding was the town response, but then you had to go and mess it up with this dumb post. Silly sausage.

[marry]

oh yall are talking about me rn. VFP i catch what youre putting down, but i really dont have an explanation for you other than i learned a new scumhunting tactic/scope? from lady (mastina long baseless readlist) and good faith’d it, theres no shame in backing down when you think youre wrong???
furthermore not sure why as scum id fake claim eavesdropper, realize it was gonna confuse people, joke about it more, and my scum partner immediately flips eavesdropper? like please think about that

[marry]

Nexus my need to be a sausage overrides my towniness sometimes ):

[marry]

i shoulda just claimed eavesdropper... im im shambles at the lost opportunity...

[joqiza]

marry btw since you're here i think the reason i didn't vibe with your sam comment is i adore sam and would never policy lim him ever

[joqiza]

it's irrelevant now i was just thinking about it

[VFP]

VFP, assume Marry is scum. Why does scum Marry fake claim eavesdropper multiple times?

Well since mastina was eavesdropper , it's probable scum discussed and wanted to use it with no CC risk.
I didn't take the claims I saw as hard claim though. mastina flipping eavesdropper negates that as any argument here.