Newbie 2063 | Sweets | Game Over

[Meuh]

Until Bulge starts talking I'm going to go with

VOTE: The Bulge

PS: There are a lot of votes that weren't counted on last page. Probably because the voter forgot to unvote their last choice. E.g I should have at least 1 vote on me.

I agree. We need to put some pressure on this

VOTE: The Bulge until they post something game-relevant.

...and post 83

[VFP]

And you don't find that suspicious at all?

[Meuh]

*87

are you sure you're not being disingenuous here, VFP?

No I don't find it suspicious, it's the same reason I have my vote where it is.

[VFP]

I might just get off my chest why you're scum here.
Let me think on it for a moment and I'll post shortly if I want to.

Pedit you're truly trying to seal you're fate here.

[The Bulge]

feeling

VOTE: Symbiosis

Could you elaborate?

complaining about early TRs is what pinged me first, big newbscum vibes. then she threw an awkward townlean down on VFP only to walk it back immediately after Meuh called their content NAI. she didn't react to any of VFP's new posts in between, she changed her read based solely on what Meuh said, and I don't mean in a "well you've convinced me!" way, I mean in an appeasing way. also worth noting that symbi had both the loudest voices as her original townleans. changing her reads on a whim, throwing unsubstantiated early townreads on the 2 loudest players and no real reads anywhere else, and then also sheeping meuh's weuler read all looks very very much to me like newbscum pocketing and trying to gain an advantageous position.

[The Bulge]

feeling

VOTE: Symbiosis

Also this is weird. It seems like a random vote but it's well past RVS. Not sure if this is AI though, just want to know why you did it.

not loving this reaction either. reads somewhat nervous, like she knows full well it isn't a random vote.

[The Bulge]

VFP getting the discussion going despite joking about stuff is enough to get me a very very slight townread out of them

I will say for Meuh as well that I while I understand timezones and omg people have busy lives, Pear and Bulge

are being a bit quiet

and what do you think that means?

[The Bulge]

why is that noteworthy when weuler himself was the other replacement?

I don't think the mod said to you or weuler "hey, this person is also replacing".

no, but I think it's odd that you didn't give any kind of room for those kinds of assumptions

like, it's not natural to assume first that 'something is off' because Weuler was aware of the replacements. the far far easier assumption is that he simply saw the post because it also concerns him.

[The Bulge]

Weuler (M)

83, he votes The Bulge without voting him.

?

The Bulge (//M)

I was expecting more than this from an SE slot, could just be a playstyle thing but The Bulge fails to deliver any reads and proceeds to vote one of my townreads If they don't start doing more I think they could always work as today's elim since we won't be losing much regardless, I really don't wanna see The Bulge in like, an endgame scenario, that sounds awful

holy hell slow down lmao

a guy's really not allowed to work afternoons and be busy most evenings huh

[The Bulge]

esp after being kidnapped for this game when I thought I'd be chilling the queue for another couple weeks

[The Bulge]

I see where VFP is coming from vs Meuh even if the logic has some holes, but I don't know what slip they're talking about. I think they probably do believe they've found something tho, regardless of either of their alignments. VFP either thinks they've found scum or is scum who thinks they've found something solid to push. but it doesn't sound contrived so I'm curious to hear about this slip

[Meuh]

Weuler (M)

83, he votes The Bulge without voting him.

?

The Bulge (//M)

I was expecting more than this from an SE slot, could just be a playstyle thing but The Bulge fails to deliver any reads and proceeds to vote one of my townreads If they don't start doing more I think they could always work as today's elim since we won't be losing much regardless, I really don't wanna see The Bulge in like, an endgame scenario, that sounds awful

holy hell slow down lmao

a guy's really not allowed to work afternoons and be busy most evenings huh

1. I meant to say without scumreading him, so like it was a non-committal vote.

2. I was anticipating you to keep posting the same way you were before, although that's probably not a fair assumption to make considering we were in early day 1, but yeah if you were gonna keep making posts like 62 I wouldn't want you in the endgame
I was more referring to that than activity, my bad for not being considerate of that

[Meuh]

I might just get off my chest why you're scum here.
Let me think on it for a moment and I'll post shortly if I want to.

Pedit you're truly trying to seal you're fate here.

I'm really excited for you to

decimate

me!

Spoiler:

Why do Meuh and wingedcatgirl stand out to you Marci?

from what i know, meuh usually posts more.. but she could just be busy maybe LOL

omg marci scumreading me on page 3, throwback to last game i just haven't bothered catching up until now I do also like Esooa's vibes so far

the read on Winged is something I kinda like, not actively engaging with other players while posting is a bit scummy...

I'd say my page 3 scumread™ is on Kitty, I really dislike the vibes in their posts, it feels like they're trying to hard to sound memey/engaging in memeing with other people, I generally don't mind memeing, but this feels like scum forcing it in an attempt to look like a townie to others.

Literally all these takes are cut and pasted from other people's posts.

You are outed mafia.

This all just reminds me of this (I was town)

[VFP]

Fuck it, I'll say.

I am claiming Cop. Either we only have 2 goons or doc will be on me tonight. If I am killed or not killed this answers what scum have.
This means that we are in A1 or C1.

This is where the slip comes in. Scum are looking for roles. And what roles appear on both A and C? That's right, it's Masons.
Meuh is Mason hunting and the slip in below shows their mind set.

could be masons

This is obviously a spoken about topic knowing that masons can be a thing in the scum thread. There's no way on earth town ever comment as who the masons can be.
So as scum Meuh is actually trying to get information out on who the masons are in any.

This suggests that we are more in C1 though and I'm the only town PR.
I am confident, almost 100% sure that Meuh is scum here.
Sym as the buddy.

[VFP]

I also don't want anyone trying to say that's not a scum slip either.
It's is and Meuh actually doubled down on this narrative of me as scum. Keep in mind using meta and non meta as the argument.

[VFP]

There's no reason to not lim Meuh here.
I don't care if you wait until the last second to do it, but this is the lim today.

[VFP]

Sorry Meuh, I guess you and Sym picked the wrong player to shade there.

[Meuh]

Fuck it, I'll say.

I am claiming Cop. Either we only have 2 goons or doc will be on me tonight. If I am killed or not killed this answers what scum have.
This means that we are in A1 or C1.

This is where the slip comes in. Scum are looking for roles. And what roles appear on both A and C? That's right, it's Masons.
Meuh is Mason hunting and the slip in below shows their mind set.

could be masons

This is obviously a spoken about topic knowing that masons can be a thing in the scum thread. There's no way on earth town ever comment as who the masons can be.
So as scum Meuh is actually trying to get information out on who the masons are in any.

This suggests that we are more in C1 though and I'm the only town PR.
I am confident, almost 100% sure that Meuh is scum here.
Sym as the buddy.

I felt like you and/or T3

had knowledge of the other's alignment

, not just that you were interacting weird, so I considered if there was a way you could still both be town and remembered masons are a potential, which is why I mentioned it. I didn't really think it'd significantly help scum out to say that.
You didn't really need to claim cop to make your point since 2/3 of the columns have masons anyways as you said, but I don't see why you'd be claiming it here as scum, so I see ne reason to be doubting this.

[VFP]

Okay Meuh.

[VFP]

And I did have to claim Cop here to show that my opinion is only town based.
You are the lim today.

[Meuh]

Sorry Meuh, I guess you and Sym picked the wrong player to shade there.

You can elim me, but I hope you reconsider Symbi, her behaviour has all been pro-town since the very start, I really don't understand how you can't see that. All they've posted has been helpful genuine newb!town.

[VFP]

As I said, town do not bring attention to town pairs.
If you thought 1 of us or even both of us was scum, but you fucked up.

[VFP]

Sorry Meuh, I guess you and Sym picked the wrong player to shade there.

You can elim me, but I hope you reconsider Symbi, her behaviour has all been pro-town since the very start, I really don't understand how you can't see that. All they've posted has been helpful genuine newb!town.

If you flip green I'll take it into consideration.
I'm confident here though. I don't reveal my role unless it's E1 or I'm sure it's getting us a scum.

[Meuh]

As I said, town do not bring attention to town pairs.
If you thought 1 of us or even both of us was scum, but you fucked up.

What? You can say that it isn't pro-town to bring these things up but to act as if pointing out a singular pair is major scum behaviour is a huge stretch. Townies don't engage in behaviours that help town 100% of the time, ultimately. Weuler made 67, not taking the opportunity to help town, but it doesn't make him automatically scum. I happened to mention masons because of the way my thought process naturally progressed.
I'm honestly really interested as to what everyone thinks of this and I hope your tunneling won't be holding us down in the long term at least
Knowing that masons exist isn't something that only applies to mafia members lmao

[The Bulge]

.....................................................



welp