Typically people don’t like when someone opposes their game plan. I brought up information I deemed important to make these decisions, and stand by my choices to prefer someone to lead than someone for the role itself.In post 146, Servant Assassin wrote:I have yet to see anything that comes off as scummy, though beserker's appeal to cabd and the resultant thought to elect a charismatic town leader was off-putting.
The off-putting part was less about the mechanical element (though that comes into it) but more about the concept of a potential charismatic town leader. I don't find those types to have nearly as much value as their lofty name would suggest. I'd be perfectly happy with a potato in the slot if I knew it was town over that.In post 151, Servant Berserker wrote:Typically people don’t like when someone opposes their game plan. I brought up information I deemed important to make these decisions, and stand by my choices to prefer someone to lead than someone for the role itself.
Lancer is town. I respect them not wanting to lead, but they are town. 85 is self reflective on their own qualifications to lead, as well as actual need and optimization of them receiving the master. I also think that everyone, regardless of alignment wants to be the master, so the “Why is that?” is more about trying to get a read and feels like an unfair nitpick.
Foreigner isn't impressive so far either, although it's still early.In post 153, Servant Archer wrote:Not a big fan of Rider's iso atm lol.
You have anything to say other then just your vote?
In post 17, Servant Berserker wrote:Anyone who has not done so already should go read Cabds comments from the first game on the preliminary master vote. The short version is decide on a charismatic player to receive it, and let them either lead town or get taken out entirely if scum.
With regard to Lancer, I mostly liked this sequence on the first page. The response didn't feel like one scum would make, I would've expected somethng more self-conscious. Posting since then has been largely mechanical so I wouldn't say it's the strongest read, but as far as early vibes go they've been all right.
Caster. I’ve come around to the idea that we just have polar opposite approaches to the game, but I did not like their constant reinforcement to focus on abilities anyway. I think it’s a pitfall, but there’s clearly more than just them that believes it.In post 158, Servant Archer wrote:@Berserker - I was looking back over the game, and I am curious who were you referring to in post 50
Scum in this situation can promise everything. Once they win elections they are tree stumped anyway, no risk of being killed for lieing. It shouldn't be used as indication.In post 89, Servant Saber wrote:Both would depend on the utility of the target selected. Mine could be better or worse depending on various hypothetical game states. I can't guarantee mine would be better than a cop shot, no.In post 87, Servant Assassin wrote:Would you say it's better than a guaranteed cop-shot? That is my offer.In post 77, Servant Saber wrote:My noble phantasm involves me making judgments about what other people find useful
You would choose someone for the master vote solely on the basis of activity?In post 165, Servant Foreigner wrote:Lancer 3
Berserker 1
Alter 1
Lancer is the most active person and should be selected
of courseIn post 168, Servant Alter Ego wrote:You would choose someone for the master vote solely on the basis of activity?In post 165, Servant Foreigner wrote:Lancer 3
Berserker 1
Alter 1
Lancer is the most active person and should be selected
the person that assassin shades is actually a lancer, who got townreadsIn post 149, Servant Assassin wrote:Giving this another once over, Lancer is pinging me for scum.
I mostly dislike posts #85 and #100, the first being what the kids call LAMIST and the 2nd is simply that if you are town, you understand the pull that would draw one to wanting to become master. Even if me and Saber did not have strong mechanical reasons to want master, there is a pull that wants to get townread and make the most of your slot, and becoming master achieves that immediately. The "Why is that?" from Lancer basically should already be understood from a town perspective.
my first two posts are 2 scum reads and 1 town readIn post 170, Servant Foreigner wrote:Caster keeps talking but doesn't say anything about other players. First scum got caught.
