Silent Star 4: Yin and Yang

[pj harvey dent]

¶

Votecount 1.6

[3] Robert M Hunter:

Tanner, Satoru Nakata, Infinity 324

[2] Morning Tweet:

PookyTheMagicalBear, clidd

[1] Tanner:

Robert M Hunter

[1] Ircher:

NorwegianboyEE

[1] Amy Dunne:

Chara

[1] Chara:

Morning Tweet

[1] Infinity 324:

Ydrasse

[3] Not Voting:

Amy Dunne, Ircher, Flea The Magician

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to sentence. If there is no majority by the deadline, plurality will decide.

The deadline is in (expired on 2021-07-07 18:10:20).

Joint moderator ISO.

[clidd]

Yin hasn't posted yet despite being asked questions. What do people think about that?

was there a point to asking this?

slight town ping on robert

, mostly because his intro gives me a vibe similar to my own. ircher feels tonally scummy but i'm not too interested in pushing that right now. if anyone who's town on ydrasse could let me know why, that would be cool.

hmm.

Yin

, how many actual criminals are there in the pit?

(the first person to say "wow, are you scum trying to townslip???" is getting slapped. alright thanks.)

I mean, Tanner had a town ping on Robert before 219 happened.

Scum!Robert would simply ignore this to ''forge'' a false reasoning to scumread Tanner?

[clidd]

What's wrong with an good old-timey Ircher wagon.

I'll probably get into this wagon depending on what conclusion I get about Morning and Robert.

I'm not familiar with Ircher's townmeta, but his post has vaguely reminded me of scum!Ircher in Titus vs Nancy.

[Morning Tweet]

i like Amy. tanner has a lot of bite which i think is lightly good

to answer why i said i liked robert earlier, i think a lot of his reads are surfacey level but it randomly spiked to being serious ish on Tanner -- and he didnt explain his thought process until prompted by tanner, and he didnt make a push out of it really. It just didnt seem particularly scum motivated to me, i think he's been scummy on a basic level and has attracted attention for no gain

@Amy

Her question was bad imo, and her posts on the last pages didn't give me an impression of "this is town! Morning" or "town reasoning/perspective for sure".

Confused what was bad about it.

What do you make of me changing votes in ai terms?

You voted Robert and then voted Amy within the next 60 seconds -- so it was unlikely you had read material between the votes. I was interested in your thought process for the switching votes, since it has the possibility of being performative or towny depending on your response. I didnt really get anything out of it but 0 minute vote swaps are usually intriguing to me early game

[Morning Tweet]

I am curious as to why you found the question bad though now, if i may ask

[Morning Tweet]

amy saying yang would be obviously town aligned made me question the alignments in a different way

the possibilities are like, town/mafia, but i don’t know if we should put stock into one as definitively one or another as they might be their own independent things...?

I'm not sure they can have alignments because they're not players -- "Non-Player Characters"

Course, it's Hectic so I suppose anything is possible. i like the idea that they're observers/governors of the game a lot more though

[Morning Tweet]

Yin

, why did your account's identity change to Kaitou Kid?

[Morning Tweet]

Tweet was solving in mafiascum rpg more, and I can't know this for sure but I feel that mech was more important to focus on in that game

There was no creativity involved with that mech so i wasnt into it

also, i know it's been a while, but i actually didnt start solving til day two. I was a consensus scumread day one (≧∀≦)

[Morning Tweet]

She says I'm town which is silly cause I've barely been playing.

i townread the below post cause you've used a frustrated emoticon in response to being called scum in every game i've played with u thus far LOL

Silly sure but i also have a large tendency to townread you. Did you know ive townread you in every game we've played thus far? That's gotta be at least five games

you're off your game infy

are you a baddie or something

No :/

[Infinity 324]

I feel like you had good reasons to townread me in the other games but ok

[Morning Tweet]

I probably should've mentioned that I decided that earlier

PEdit: am I wrong about how much solving tweet would do at this point? Maybe I am

She did a lot of mech in rpg

you're completely off the mark on that one

You're judging the mech based on how important it is rather than how invested I am in it, which is a little odd. I'm prioritizing fun, not optimal play

I agree the mech in that game was arguably more important. But i didnt like how there was a best strategy and i didnt take a lot of time to learn it cause i was afk the first couple days (see: volunteering for guillotine D1). Whereas this game is mysterious and fun, like a puzzle. And im also in a much better place for this one.

I stepped up D2 and beyond in order to coordinate the night actions which i had some fun with though, yeah. You're forgetting that I didnt get invested in the game til a lot further down, though

[Morning Tweet]

I feel like you had good reasons to townread me in the other games but ok

i think i did too ya

Especially deja and rpg

My point was that i think the way you play usually comes off as towny to me though -- exhibit a, finding the frustrated emoticon use towny. I only bring that up cause i've townread that type of post in all our games, i just didnt mention it in those games cause it was so small in those ones and they were usually later in the game.

[Morning Tweet]

she also didn't do anything for the first couple of days if I remember correctly

harsh!!! True though

No, I'm not vibing with the Robert wagon.

There's a decent chance he's weird-town instead of weird-scum (although the lack of participation after the ''what'' was scummy).

I like your thoughts on Robert and Amy

[Morning Tweet]

I mean, Tanner had a town ping on Robert before 219 happened.

Scum!Robert would simply ignore this to ''forge'' a false reasoning to scumread Tanner?

doubtful, i didnt even notice that. More reasoning to think Robert's just awkward. Im struggling to see the scum motivation

Pretty sure clidd asked me for my thoughts somewhere

@Morning

Can I see your impressions on the players?

Amy Dunne - i like her posts today
Ydrasse - correct evaluation of my play now versus rpg, could be a good sign if infinity is scum but also might just be Ydrasse reading me better cause she knows. will need more
Flea The Magician - idk flea's good
PookyTheMagicalBear - idk pooky's good. Someone mentioned he doesnt come across as evil this game which i think is lightly true, i usually scumlean pooky more by now
Ircher - idk
Infinity 324 - Random townping as i mentioned, still evaluating her read on me
clidd - i like a lot of your thoughts and i think your read on me might just be wrong and not bad motivated
Morning Tweet - bat
Robert M Hunter - ive prolly gone over this enough
Tanner - has a bit of edginess and yeah others pointed that out already but i do kinda like it
Satoru Nakata - idk
Chara - idk
NorwegianBoyEE - i like his early game and this was my first townping although its probably comparatively weaker than others

can you tell ive got a lot of energy today

[Morning Tweet]

the cumulus fact does not seem right, but i don't know enough about meteorology to confidently say it's incorrect.

Aren't those stratus?

Yeah wow yin get your shit together

cumulonimbus i thinkj

And yeah, as Ircher said, it is close. Cumulus is usually a signal of good weather though which kind of irks me about it.

[Infinity 324]

Don't trust my SR on robert

[NorwegianboyEE]

Eww, reads lists.

[clidd]

Alright, welcome back to townping.

UNVOTE: Morning Tweet

[clidd]

The question was ''bad'' in the context that you could have questioned other points in my posting, such as my scumpings/townpings/nulls etc (that would help you understand me more), but the focus was placed where you would extract less information.

[clidd]

Maybe it's just your mental process, but I don't understand how interpreting an exchange of votes occurring in seconds would give you any idea of ​​performative/genuine action from me. Regardless, I'm comfortable with you atm after seeing your recent posts.

[Ydrasse]

i have an idea of how you play @mt but also have an idea or rather assumption that infinity should recognize these things and not jump to the vote that readily

[Ydrasse]

also she didn’t have any gutpings about you when she voted you which especially early game i attribute to infinity

[Morning Tweet]

Maybe it's just your mental process, but I don't understand how interpreting an exchange of votes occurring in seconds would give you any idea of ​​performative/genuine action from me. Regardless, I'm comfortable with you atm after seeing your recent posts.

Voting someone than going "hm, actually" and voting someone else is something i consider doing as scum a lot to give the appearance of thought behind my vote without using any effort

Whereas as town i'd have some kind of actual thought process or just actually vote the right person first. i try to decipher the difference between town/scum thoughts on the action although idk if there is an easily tangible one or not. Still something i always question when i see it!

i have an idea of how you play @mt but also have an idea or rather assumption that infinity should recognize these things and not jump to the vote that readily

also she didn’t have any gutpings about you when she voted you which especially early game i attribute to infinity

I think your evaluation is very fair.

[Morning Tweet]

Yang

, by your estimate, what nonnegative integer number of batlings do I have?

[Chara]

Tweetie i want some of your energy. let me siphon it. is it bad to just coast and let Tweetie play day 1 for me?

is what i might say. in another life. i feel like i'm looking at town Tweetie here, and i want to say that about Ydrasse too.