FGO: Mafia in the Lostbelt - 2 Game Over

[Servant Alter Ego]

I refuse to believe any town player, even one fresh out of the newbie queue, could be this bad

You're still treading on breaking the site rules.
Attack the play not the player here. I've told you to stop, now do it.

Don't try to rules lawyer to silence me

[Servant Avenger]

Now when you say moon cancer's posts are not scummy, can you explain specifically why you don't think moon cancer's read on alter is scummy?

Because there's nothing for me to really go by on it.
I just don't read Moon as scummy though.

[Servant Beast]

This is a very unfortunate time to be busy with stuff.

@Berserker @Shielder, tell me who to vote and I'll sheep.

so it doesn't get lost.

[Servant Avenger]

Yeah cause we didn't know it was going to be a fucking gladiate???????

What day powers would I do that would need to be used if votes shy away?

[Servant Alter Ego]

Now when you say moon cancer's posts are not scummy, can you explain specifically why you don't think moon cancer's read on alter is scummy?

Because there's nothing for me to really go by on it.
I just don't read Moon as scummy though.

Lol, again, he can't defend the read because it's pure fucking bullshit

[Servant Archer]

No.

Not for me at least.

This play proves that you don't have the greatest judgement

Okay, say I flip town, Moon flips town and foreigner flips scum.
Is my judgement still bad?

Yes. Even then. You choosing to do this gladiate right now, is bad judgement, even if you end up being right.

Like, I am not sure how you could have looked at this situation, and thought that this would have any result other then you being eliminated.

And I also don't see how you could believe that you making this play would result in any of us taking your read on foreigner more seriously.

So for you to think that this is a good play, tells me you have bad judgement.

The sheer hubris required for you to be this confident in your scum read on Day 1 -- Willing to get yourself miselimed for it, and willing to set the town up for 2 miselims in a row if you are wrong-- all before we have had any flips is... a bad play

[Servant Alter Ego]

Avenger just refuses to engage in good faith and is resorting to pedantry, whining, and pointless hypotheticals to try to spin away the fact that his usage of the gladiate here is absurdly scummy

[Servant Lancer]

honestly I'm super steamed

there's a small chance that avenger is town because assassin said something that made sense about saving moon cancer being a really bad look

however, since avenger refuses to remove the gladiate, and I'm townreading foreigner, my vote stays on avenger.

[Servant Lancer]

Yeah cause we didn't know it was going to be a fucking gladiate???????

What day powers would I do that would need to be used if votes shy away?

your post was super vague and confusing, and I read that as you were going to use your NP on foreigner to get them to stop talking to which I was like, weird but ok

[Servant Avenger]

Me removing the gladiator shouldn't change the vote from me and foreigner.
Either I'm scum trying to survive or I'm right by doing so. So why would I remove the gladiator as either alignment there?

[Servant Alter Ego]

It'd be funny if it was scum trying to tie himself to town moon cancer, but I really doubt that's the case. Scum don't always play rationally, the idea that impulsive behavior only comes from town is a fallacy.

[Servant Lancer]

Now when you say moon cancer's posts are not scummy, can you explain specifically why you don't think moon cancer's read on alter is scummy?

Because there's nothing for me to really go by on it.
I just don't read Moon as scummy though.

I want you to comment on moon's read on alter. And why you don't think it's scummy.

[Servant Lancer]

Me removing the gladiator shouldn't change the vote from me and foreigner.
Either I'm scum trying to survive or I'm right by doing so. So why would I remove the gladiator as either alignment there?

ok so my vote stays

[Servant Avenger]

Yeah cause we didn't know it was going to be a fucking gladiate???????

What day powers would I do that would need to be used if votes shy away?

your post was super vague and confusing, and I read that as you were going to use your NP on foreigner to get them to stop talking to which I was like, weird but ok

Huh?
I said my 1st day power.
I said I had 2 powers and the NP (be it I think I said something like power up ability)
How would I be able to use my NP though?

[Servant Avenger]

Now when you say moon cancer's posts are not scummy, can you explain specifically why you don't think moon cancer's read on alter is scummy?

Because there's nothing for me to really go by on it.
I just don't read Moon as scummy though.

I want you to comment on moon's read on alter. And why you don't think it's scummy.

I don't understand the read. Why would that make it scummy?
Be it, Moon is probably right with the read.

[Servant Lancer]

like I said, I was super confused but I didn't really care about your claim enough to figure out what you were actually saying. because my plan, and berserker's plan, and literally the whole townbloc's plan, was to solve in moon cancer/saber.

[Servant Avenger]

Me removing the gladiator shouldn't change the vote from me and foreigner.
Either I'm scum trying to survive or I'm right by doing so. So why would I remove the gladiator as either alignment there?

ok so my vote stays

Shocker.

[Servant Avenger]

like I said, I was super confused but I didn't really care about your claim enough to figure out what you were actually saying. because my plan, and berserker's plan, and literally the whole townbloc's plan, was to solve in moon cancer/saber.

So you didn't care about my claim.
Well you do now at least

[Servant Lancer]

Now when you say moon cancer's posts are not scummy, can you explain specifically why you don't think moon cancer's read on alter is scummy?

Because there's nothing for me to really go by on it.
I just don't read Moon as scummy though.

I want you to comment on moon's read on alter. And why you don't think it's scummy.

I don't understand the read. Why would that make it scummy?
Be it, Moon is probably right with the read.

Moon cancer voted alter because he was getting "too townread" and then when asked for more reasons, referred everyone to their ISO, which only contained "Alter thinks too much and their reads have too much uncertainty" which is very much not how I would characterize Alter's posts. Explain why you think this is not scum-indicative.

[Servant Alter Ego]

Also sheeped my votes despite me being their biggest scumread.

[Servant Avenger]

Now when you say moon cancer's posts are not scummy, can you explain specifically why you don't think moon cancer's read on alter is scummy?

Because there's nothing for me to really go by on it.
I just don't read Moon as scummy though.

I want you to comment on moon's read on alter. And why you don't think it's scummy.

I don't understand the read. Why would that make it scummy?
Be it, Moon is probably right with the read.

Moon cancer voted alter because he was getting "too townread" and then when asked for more reasons, referred everyone to their ISO, which only contained "Alter thinks too much and their reads have too much uncertainty" which is very much not how I would characterize Alter's posts. Explain why you think this is not scum-indicative.

Well it starts saying that Ego has too much uncertainty. That's different to just town read.
I'm not sure why I'd directly find this scummy rather than Null?

Just because someone has a reason which isn't great doesn't mean it's scummy. Otherwise foreigner's original scum read on me should be one the favoured. But yet, we're here.

[Servant Caster]

Words can't describe how sad I am that I won't get to flirt with Notsci.



Also what's going on I haven't caught up yet

[Cabd]

With 14 players alive, it takes 8 votes to burn a servant. Only Foreigner and Avenger may be voted for.

Avenger (5): Lancer, Foreigner, Alter Ego, Saber, Archer
Foreigner (2): Ruler, Avenger


Deadline: (expired on 2021-07-12 00:17:51)


Page Usage: 20/42

[Servant Caster]

VOTE: Avenger

I think this is what Notsci would've wanted from the post he slipped on

[Servant Alter Ego]

Well it starts saying that Ego has too much uncertainty. That's different to just town read.
I'm not sure why I'd directly find this scummy rather than Null?

Just because someone has a reason which isn't great doesn't mean it's scummy.

This is complete crap, you're not even answering. Why is any of that supposed to be a real reason to find me scummy, how is it a real thought, why can't they explain it despite being repeatedly asked, why should you think this is coming from a town player at all?