Mini Theme 2222: Open Draft Mafia [Game Over]

[Dunnstral]

If you're town and grab one of them all the better

Which one would you suggest?

Probably the rb, since there are two strongmans and it can't be completely denied

[cyrus62]

Though tbh I don't think it's fair to say I haven't looked for scum, I've pushed t3, a50, and house

You pushed them after others did. You don't have any reads of your own.

[Infinity 324]

I was the first person to vote a50

I think you have weird/unreasonable expectations for what town should do

[Infinity 324]

I guess there was an a50 wagon earlier but still

[cyrus62]

Losing 4 games in a row has made me want to try something diffent so i will scum read all and work my way back wards.

[T3]

Why is House town?

[T3]

Why is House town?

@Almost50 and to a lesser extent everyone.

[cyrus62]

Why is House town?

I will find out if house is scum or town come night.

[Dwlee99]

So far I am roughly at (groups in no particular order. I used the mod's player list):

Honouable Judge:

Almost50

The Jury:

House mastina Taly T3 NDMath

Pool of Suspects:

Dunn Flea Bingle Infinity Dwlee cyrus Momrangal/NorwEE

Were you in that last game day one?

[T3]

Losing 4 games in a row has made me want to try something diffent so i will scum read all and work my way back wards.

> Literally townhunting.

[cyrus62]

Also if I am nk then feel free to vote house off d2 haha so house if I die tonight you die d2 lol.

[T3]

Also if I am nk then feel free to vote house off d2 haha so house if I die tonight you die d2 lol.

N1'ing you seems mildly insane.

[cyrus62]

Also if I am nk then feel free to vote house off d2 haha so house if I die tonight you die d2 lol.

N1'ing you seems mildly insane.

Scum use me in hope of winning. Yes I have only been nk once.

[Almost50]

Why is House town?

@Almost50 and to a lesser extent everyone.

Tone and stances so far make more sense as coming from a town mindset

[Almost50]

Were you in that last game day one?

?? There has always been a last game that I was in on D1.

[House]

Though tbh I don't think it's fair to say I haven't looked for scum, I've pushed t3, a50, and house

I wouldn't call a flaccid, unexplained vote with no questioning or accusations much of a push.

[House]

Were you in that last game day one?

?? There has always been a last game that I was in on D1.

Perfect response is perfect.

[Dwlee99]

I'm asking how you can play with Cyrus there and then look at this and not see how he is dripping with townie intent.

[Almost50]

I'm asking how you can play with Cyrus there and then look at this and not see how he is dripping with townie intent.

1- Meta is NOT my primary scumhunting tool
2- When I do use it; it's not off of one or two games

[Dwlee99]

I hate meta too that's not my point here.

[Bingle]

Ah ok, so mafia has scum abilities. And A50 is claiming to have those particular scum abilities as town that mafia will lose access to if town!him is eliminated.

Not quite. A50 is claiming that he has abilities that are disproportionately powerful in scum's hands; they can still theoretically be used by town. (Sman can modify vig and roleblocker is utility for town as well as scum.)

If mafia chooses Sman over neighbor out of A50's pack, however, and then passes the pack to town, then the town player can tell us that a specific player has an Sman shot. We then have the avenue of WHY they chose Sman over neighbor to investigate and a known suspect should a doc protect ever fail, meaning that in order to obfuscate the SMan the scum team would have to link themselves together by passing the packs between solely themselves.

Additionally, the scumteam will presumably have seen 6/11 packs on D2, which means they will have the majority of the setup info and we can claim the composition of packs (or rather, the presence of specifically problematic roles in our packs).

[cyrus62]

I would rather be thought scum then town .ok I give up I'm scum this time . Lol

[Bingle]

So far I am roughly at (groups in no particular order. I used the mod's player list):

Honouable Judge:

Almost50

The Jury:

House mastina Taly T3 NDMath

Pool of Suspects:

Dunn Flea Bingle Infinity Dwlee cyrus Momrangal/NorwEE

Talk to me about Mastina and Dunn.

[Bingle]

If you're town and grab one of them all the better

Which one would you suggest?

Probably the rb, since there are two strongmans and it can't be completely denied

Definitely the roleblocker. Using it N1 is a pretty strong move as it is unlikely scum will have access to a Sman to make the kill go through anyway and 90% of the investigatives can't be used N1.

[NDMath]

VOTE: norwee
Liking my vote here more than on t3 now.

Why is House town?

I still think post 39 comes directly from a town mindset.
They were the one who pushed you over your mastina read, which you later conceded:

Spoiler:

You're right. My read on mastina is bad and the points I'm making about mastina are NAI.

You're right. My read on mastina is bad and the points I'm making about mastina are NAI.

Be candid, is this sarcasm or honesty?

Honesty.

I think he's on the better side of the interaction between him and Bingle where they repeated their opinions back to eachother.
His progression on A50 looks natural.