Mini Theme 2222: Open Draft Mafia [Game Over]

[Infinity 324]

This really confuses me.
So it seems like in your push against House you’re asking them to show more town motivation, but you’re not really explaining what this supposed town motivation that has been lacking from House’s posts is. Which makes me sorta indifferent to your push there. What is House doing here that he wouldn’t as town in response to being pushed??

The response to being pushed isn't really the problem, I felt like 640 had a pretty reasonable scum motivation (trying to look unbothered by my vote) but no town motivation that I could see. His response, I guess, is that he was just being frustratingly pedantic, which I do actually think could be reasonable after thinking about it more. But that was the idea behind my push.

UNVOTE:

[NorwegianboyEE]

Post 744 is a huge waste of text where Mastina leads us down this rabbit hole of how open and honest she is about her time, she's not in the right headspace, etc etc. Much ado about nothing.
Mastinas play pretty much fits what i expect to see from scum!her, which is short bursts of spam texts with longer breaks in-between, with the grand bonus being this incessant tunneling.

[Dwlee99]

I think t3 is scum and I don't like his weird hop on to Norwee because it doesn't feel like a bus hop to me.

Why?

I feel like you're trying to pocket me and I don't like how you're analyzing the game. You also have associatives with a50 when you say stuff like 770. I don't feel like you're taking a position.

[Taly]

Norwee do you still think one of Taly/Mastina has to be scum here? Taly comes across townie by play and I think Mastina declaring a 1v1 like that is bold if it's coming from scum.

I mean i feel like all the players voting me are scummy. Especially T3 that claimed they townread me but now when it's convenient they find "my tone off" and vote me.

There are FIVE votes on you. There are only THREE SCUM.

Town is voting you in some way and some form. You can't dismiss your votes off the premise that it's all scum motivated anymore.

Who is town on your wagon?

Out of playing on MS for years I've seen only a handful of games where all 3 scum are on a designated D1 mislim. So I really need convincing if you think Taly/Mastina/T3 ever exists here.

[Flea The Magician]

@Mod, Limited access due to massive pain flare requiring *those* medications.

usual drill to be honest, I'll still be here but its just good to cover bases.

Cross post

[House]

Someone remind me why we're making house answer every question three times.

Huh? House didn't answer my question the first two times.

I don't have a read on flea.

That's because you wouldn't have had to ask it at all if you had been reading my posts.

[House]

This really confuses me.
So it seems like in your push against House you’re asking them to show more town motivation, but you’re not really explaining what this supposed town motivation that has been lacking from House’s posts is. Which makes me sorta indifferent to your push there. What is House doing here that he wouldn’t as town in response to being pushed??

The response to being pushed isn't really the problem, I felt like 640 had a pretty reasonable scum motivation (trying to look unbothered by my vote) but no town motivation that I could see. His response, I guess, is that he was just being frustratingly pedantic, which I do actually think could be reasonable after thinking about it more. But that was the idea behind my push.

UNVOTE:

Me nitpicking lies & fallacies is NAI. It's just a personality trait.

[House]

Norwee do you still think one of Taly/Mastina has to be scum here? Taly comes across townie by play and I think Mastina declaring a 1v1 like that is bold if it's coming from scum.

I mean i feel like all the players voting me are scummy. Especially T3 that claimed they townread me but now when it's convenient they find "my tone off" and vote me.

There are FIVE votes on you. There are only THREE SCUM.

Town is voting you in some way and some form. You can't dismiss your votes off the premise that it's all scum motivated anymore.

Who is town on your wagon?

Out of playing on MS for years I've seen only a handful of games where all 3 scum are on a designated D1 mislim. So I really need convincing if you think Taly/Mastina/T3 ever exists here.

/subscribe

[T3]

I think t3 is scum and I don't like his weird hop on to Norwee because it doesn't feel like a bus hop to me.

Why?

I feel like you're trying to pocket me and I don't like how you're analyzing the game. You also have associatives with a50 when you say stuff like 770. I don't feel like you're taking a position.

I don't know. It's WIFOM.

[Dwlee99]

What is?

[Infinity 324]

Dwlee you're too reasonable I'm scared

[T3]

What is?

The a50 claim.

[Infinity 324]

I think I townread t3 at this point

[Dwlee99]

I've literally never been unreasonable before I don't see what you mean.

What is?

The a50 claim.

No, look for intent. A50 isn't doing anything. He doesn't have a town motive to make that "play."

[T3]

Actually that makes sense.

[Infinity 324]

I've literally never been unreasonable before I don't see what you mean.

I don't think you were unreasonable ever per se but it's harder to see your personal biases/strong opinions influencing your play like in c9++

[Dwlee99]

A50 is low-key lurking out my push and I'm trying to not derail like other times. And I'm like the only one on him other than himself rn :I

[Infinity 324]

A50 could be scum, I feel like it's mostly a matter of the people who know a50 best and mastina/bingle think he's town so.

I feel similar about norwee tbh. I feel like at this point in the day I'm ok just limming anyone outside of my townreads because I don't think I'm gonna get a good scumread.

Do you townread norwee?

[Infinity 324]

Townreads: mastina, dunn, cyrus, NDMath, taly, T3 somewhat

[Dwlee99]

I slightly townread norwee cause he went out of his way to try to interact with me and I feel like his frustration with the push is townie.

[Taly]

Dwlee

, darling, I very much appreciate your courage in doubling down on a scumread over a slot who is both generally townread on either a playstyle or mechanical reason.

Even more so by your willingness to whiteknight the one and only slot that has come to L2 in this game so far.

But if

Norwee

wobbles into this thread again only to ignore my previous posts specifically about him, I'm going to deathtunnel that slot.

Save the precious, divine scum!

Norwee

the heartache and L1 him.

[Bingle]

I’m refraining from commenting on Taly’s push to see how Norwee reacts, but I definitely want to come back to it.

[Bingle]

A50 is low-key lurking out my push and I'm trying to not derail like other times. And I'm like the only one on him other than himself rn :I

Is he though? Like… what exactly do you think monkey should be doing that he isn’t?

[Bingle]

Flea the Magician
Taly

Almost50
Dwlee99
Dunnstral

cyrus62
Bingle
House

NDMath


Infinity 324


T3



Momrangal/NorwegianboyEE

Ngl, I don’t really hate this list. Or at least the middle bit of it. I don’t agree with it, but I can see where the reads originate. That doesn’t really make me less concerned that you’re scum.

I will point out that you not being in thread due to the RL absence doesn’t really fix the lack of town vibes while you’re here, but this could just be a case of you being too checked out to bleed town. Talk to me about Taly, because I feel like he has significant scum equity if you’re town. Also, if you have a game or two that you think shows norwee scum I’d appreciate it, because I’m pretty sure he’s told me his scum game is easy to catch before and I don’t remember ever seeing it.

[cyrus62]

im here