mini theme 2229: MBOS 13 schweppes' pulpy potions daya 5

[schadd_]

Spoiler:

votey 1.3.00.01.0 !

Bingle (2):

mastina, NorwegianboyEE

Dwlee99 (2):

Titus, RCEnigma

The Limit Does Not Exist (2):

Green Cap Boys, T3

Titus (1):

Dwlee99

RCEnigma (1):

Bingle

T3 (1):

The Emperor

not voting (2):

The Limit Does Not Exist, Fairy Circle

with 11 alive, it takes 6 to cause someone to Wet. day 1 ends in (expired on 2021-08-17 12:30:00)

modorator notes

• Squease

[NorwegianboyEE]

Serioisly though does anyone townread Fairy Circle? I feel like that could be scum indicative. As in they are not being too townie and none of their teammates would wanna openly townread them if scum here.

[NorwegianboyEE]

I'm just gonna follow my gut.
VOTE: Fairy Circle

[NorwegianboyEE]

I'm also slightly concerned with Norwee's progression wrt me. He seemed to have a pretty strong town read of me that he dropped for very little reason. It's possible that he's just sheeping mastina based on her catching him last game (his justification) but I felt like his read on me was more solid than that given T3's conflicting meta examination and

I'm not playing to please you or anyone. Just to catch scum.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Mastina seems surefire on their read and i trust them so that makes me trust you less.
I still wanna vote Fairy Circle though.

[Titus]

Dwlee, I was busy. Tomorrow I still intend to avoid the thread like I did today. I am deliberately giving you space to see if you can be curious or sort anyone. I didn't see it today in your posting but you did do marginally more than whine about me (you still did that some though). Given I got something closer towards scumhunting, I do want to give you space. My read on you hasn't changed because you aren't hunting. I'm giving it the opportunity to change. I can't do it long though because the deadline. If you're town please give me something. I am not looking for a wall. I just want to see some curiousity somewhere.

[Green Cap Boys]

what's your read on bingle independently of mastina pushing him?

@norwee

-D

[NorwegianboyEE]

what's your read on bingle independently of mastina pushing him?

@norwee

-D

A bit torn. Because i think their tone is good, but what they said about their role was scummy.
I wanna say light townread if i were to base it only on my reads and ignoring Mastina’s points.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Scum is just Titus. I really don't get what there is to townread in her shit push on me.

I just feel like a couple of their stances seem unlikely to come from scum.

Explain which ones and why?

The listing of their 3 reads, if all town. Seems pretty bold from scum. And also pushing someone that is unlikely to ever become an elimination with conviction also feels like something unlikely coming from scum. I think Mafia generally play a bit more safe and go for low hanging fruit rather than what Titus did.

[Green Cap Boys]

but what they said about their role was scummy.

what was scummy there?

-D

[NorwegianboyEE]

That their ingredient was poison.
Unless i’m misunderstanding here. Each town slot is supposed to receive potions with numerous ingredients. Why did Bingle only have poison?

[Green Cap Boys]

i had to spend like 2 minutes staring blankly into space before being able to continue typing

there's a chance a slot gets zero potions. idk how big (because lol math) but it's there. but in order to confirm for the game, you need to not only repeat your alignment, but also one ingredient from a potion. but if you don't have a potion, you have no ingredients, so you cannot confirm like that.

so schadd decided to add a random ingredient into a potionless role pm so that you can still confirm an ingredient even if you don't have a potion. the sample potionless role pm requires you to acknowledge the broken bottles.

so again, what is scummy about bingle's claim, and how the hell did you miss all of this but still ended uo thinking that he's scummy for his claim and ended up voting him even though he was on your "never vote" list prior?

-D

[NorwegianboyEE]

so again, what is scummy about bingle's claim, and how the hell did you miss all of this but still ended uo thinking that he's scummy for his claim and ended up voting him even though he was on your "never vote" list prior?

What do you mean in the last part? I was voting mostly because of Mastina’s case and i trust Mastina. Not really the role claim.
I won’t talk too much about the mechanics stuff because i didn’t even know it was possible to not have potions i thought everyone got the same amount.
I also thought Bingle might have had only harm potions because of the potions and that seemed scum indicative.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Because of the ingredient*

[NorwegianboyEE]

how the hell did you miss all of this

Do you really need to ask this question to me?
I think it’s been made pretty clear i’m not good at paying attention to complex mechanics.

[Dwlee99]

He either slipped or faked a slip that he has no duplicate potions

Uh no I didn't?

[Green Cap Boys]

because if you're apparently townreading someone so hard that you declare them as "never voting this slot", and then later on you *do* vote them under the excuse of "sheeping", and when you're asked about your independent read on them, the only reason you have for them being scummy is mechanics, mechanics that you obviously didn't even understand... yeah it's gonna raise a few eyebrows, don't you think?

pedit: my problem isn't you not paying attention to mechanics. my problem is you not paying attention to mechanics and then saying bingle is scummy because of mechanics.

-D

[NorwegianboyEE]

You might as well ask: "why are you the way that you are"

[NorwegianboyEE]

pedit: my problem isn't you not paying attention to mechanics. my problem is you not paying attention to mechanics and then saying bingle is scummy because of mechanics.

I was comparing it to my own role.

[Dwlee99]

Town players are much more likely to have no potions than scum. Bingle should not be the lim today.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Anyway quit being baffled by the Norwee and solve elsewhere Datisi. I am town.

[Green Cap Boys]

gut tells me this is townie ignorance but holy fuck do i want to scumread you for this

-D

[NorwegianboyEE]

Yawn

[NorwegianboyEE]

Why can’t you at least ask something interesting.

[Dwlee99]

Green Cap Boys
The Emperor
T3
NorwegianboyEE
Dwlee99
Bingle

RCEnigma
Titus
mastina
Fairy Circle

(Unordered between tiers)

Here's where I'm at. If Titus is town I'm just at the other three in there being evil by PoE. In the top list I could see me being tricked by maybe the emperor? I feel good on Norwee, the cap boys, and bingle. T3 I think is townie but my worry is that he seems townie cause he is trying too hard. So a list including confusing slots would be

Green Cap Boys
NorwegianboyEE
Dwlee99
Bingle

The Emperor
T3

RCEnigma
Titus
mastina
Fairy Circle

VOTE: Fairy Circle