Newbie 2075: Icecream Cake (Game Over)

[T3]

Wheme I'm getting intense townvibes from.

[Quiet Owl]

Same thing with Quiet Owl - I'm trying to digest this concept of pro-town PR hunting. If you out town!Psyche as PR, doesn't he just die and we lose him? Also, I don't think T3 is town, but I'm willing to compromise on Whemestar.

How about I dump my theory here then. We have either five or six vanillas and two mafia. Even if Psyche dies, if I'm right about Meg and Wheme, then we've won the game.

Confirmed vanillas:

sea monkey

,

Kerset

Likely vanillas:

T3

- Claimed vanilla earlier. Reads more like "oh my god i give up" than "ah shit i've been caught". Very weak reason, but it exists.

Cook

- I don't think she's mafia, for reasons that I have already explained, and if she had a power role, she would be participating in her strategy.

Roles unknown:

Myself

- No I'm not going to be roleclaiming, for obvious reasons!

Psyche

- Town sabotaging town by doing very little. I am putting them as town because they seem to be genuinely frustrated with the game and they're a possible PR. But if you're that disappointed in the game, why aren't you replacing out?

Dorsey

- Town! The towniest of towns.

Null reads:

Meg and Wheme

- The only two people who I can't and probably never will be able to read in this game. Since everyone else reads as town, I will assume that these two are the two mafia. VOTE: WhemeStar

Looking back at it this read list is weird. Are Meg and I your two scumreads? Why do you have us as null and not scum? Are we null and you have no scumreads? Why do you think the 2 clunterwagoks to a town miselim are both town. Do you think town was way off day 1?

The list is the result of townhunting. I have no scumreads, but I can't read either of you at all which makes me suspect you're scum doing the bare minimum to stay in the game.
I explained my reasoning for Psyche and Cook.
What do you mean by way off? In hindsight I think the sea monkey wagon was a very bad idea, if that's what you meant.

[Quiet Owl]

Wheme I'm getting intense townvibes from.

Asked questions that could be easily answered by skimming through my iso. I get that people's time can be limited but I don't see how this is intense townvibes.

[WhemeStar]

Same thing with Quiet Owl - I'm trying to digest this concept of pro-town PR hunting. If you out town!Psyche as PR, doesn't he just die and we lose him? Also, I don't think T3 is town, but I'm willing to compromise on Whemestar.

How about I dump my theory here then. We have either five or six vanillas and two mafia. Even if Psyche dies, if I'm right about Meg and Wheme, then we've won the game.

Confirmed vanillas:

sea monkey

,

Kerset

Likely vanillas:

T3

- Claimed vanilla earlier. Reads more like "oh my god i give up" than "ah shit i've been caught". Very weak reason, but it exists.

Cook

- I don't think she's mafia, for reasons that I have already explained, and if she had a power role, she would be participating in her strategy.

Roles unknown:

Myself

- No I'm not going to be roleclaiming, for obvious reasons!

Psyche

- Town sabotaging town by doing very little. I am putting them as town because they seem to be genuinely frustrated with the game and they're a possible PR. But if you're that disappointed in the game, why aren't you replacing out?

Dorsey

- Town! The towniest of towns.

Null reads:

Meg and Wheme

- The only two people who I can't and probably never will be able to read in this game. Since everyone else reads as town, I will assume that these two are the two mafia. VOTE: WhemeStar

Looking back at it this read list is weird. Are Meg and I your two scumreads? Why do you have us as null and not scum? Are we null and you have no scumreads? Why do you think the 2 clunterwagoks to a town miselim are both town. Do you think town was way off day 1?

The list is the result of townhunting. I have no scumreads, but I can't read either of you at all which makes me suspect you're scum doing the bare minimum to stay in the game.
I explained my reasoning for Psyche and Cook.
What do you mean by way off? In hindsight I think the sea monkey wagon was a very bad idea, if that's what you meant.

I mean by thinking that all 3 wagons from day 1 were town

[WhemeStar]

you're scum doing the bare minimum to stay in the game.

Is this how you think scum would play this game?

[GuyInFreezer]

VC 2.03

Psyche (1):

MegAzumarill

WhemeStar (2):

Dorsey, Quiet Owl

Quiet Owl (1):

Psyche

MegAzumarill (1):

T3

Not voting:

WhemeStar, Cook

With

7

alive,

4

votes to eliminate

Deadline:

(expired on 2021-08-27 13:13:51)

Psyche is being replaced.
MegAzumarill = V/LA until 28th
Deadline has been frozen.

[T3]

Yeah but he has good intent.

[Cook]

let's see about the psyche RI

i townlean psyche
i null mega, and that's scary this late
i scumlean dorsey
i townlean owl
i townread t3 now (again please stop being so hard to read it's like >:( )
and wheme is both scum and town. i want to vote wheme but at the same time feel like it would be a mislim.

[Dorsey]

What changed from Cook's post 314 where I was townie to now, other than my post 472 where I questioned her wagon and dynamic with T3?

[Dorsey]

Also, both T3 and Cook are saying that WhemeStar is town, but not giving any reasoning. It could be mafia trying to posture themselves to look good after a miselim. I also don't get what "please stop being so hard to read" is supposed to do as either a post or a sentiment. It seems like progressionless filler that also acts as a disclaimer.

[GuyInFreezer]

Looker replaces Psyche.

New deadline: (expired on 2021-08-27 22:32:10)

[Cook]

Welcome, Looker!

1. who do you want off the island?
2. who do you want saved at all costs and why is it me?
3. what do you think of my excellent strategy?
4. opinions on psyche?
5. opinions on t3?
6. what will you do differently that will help town win?

[Quiet Owl]

you're scum doing the bare minimum to stay in the game.

Is this how you think scum would play this game?

Yes, I have read through games where scum did this exact thing. Why wouldn't you? There's little activity here and so the active lurking forces us to play a game of eeny meeny miny mo.

[Looker]

Why haven't you guys voted off the person who's strategy was literally "role fish"?
VOTE: Cook

[Looker]

Sorry.

IS

role-fish. She did it twice.

Spoiler:

hello everyone! i have been working on a strategy so that we can narrow down the initial setup incredibly quickly, and while we're at it, clear a bunch of players and generally make it much harder for scum to beat us.

to execute this strategy, i'm going to ask:

If there is a Tracker, claim now.

once that tracker claims, protective,

be on that Tracker.

Tracker, post results.

if there's no tracker then we have a fairly normal day one.

Spoiler:

alright, cop/mason faking cop, you have (expired on 2021-08-21 13:43:47) to claim.

get a friendly neighbor message? you have (expired on 2021-08-21 13:43:47) to claim it.

[Quiet Owl]

Why haven't you guys voted off the person who's strategy was literally "role fish"?
VOTE: Cook

There are 2 universes.
Town navigator is lrgit suspicious of Cook.
Scum navigator thinks "oh shit, cook broke the game. PANIKKKKKKKKK"

Or universe 3: demanding people reveal power roles as your first post is a really bad move from either alignment and I want to avoid losing two games in a row lol

legit i joined a newbie game because i wanted to try to break newd3 and came up with this strategy and wanted to see if it'd work.

[T3]

Look at that!

[WhemeStar]

Welcome to the game looker

[Looker]

Why haven't you guys voted off the person who's strategy was literally "role fish"?
VOTE: Cook

There are 2 universes.
Town navigator is lrgit suspicious of Cook.
Scum navigator thinks "oh shit, cook broke the game. PANIKKKKKKKKK"

Or universe 3: demanding people reveal power roles as your first post is a really bad move from either alignment and I want to avoid losing two games in a row lol

legit i joined a newbie game because i wanted to try to break newd3 and came up with this strategy and wanted to see if it'd work.

Spoiler: So I take it you support Cook's role-fishing

Cook:

Town, based on off-site meta. Though I think this strategy would be better off being tested in a normal game where the whole point is to try and break newD3, not in a newbie game. That being said, I'm not the tracker.

Owl - I thought the initial reads list was kind of early. I don't know what to think of that yet.

Why focus on this and not how I've been defending Cook, who you've got written down as scum? Personally I'd find the latter far more alarming.

Likely vanillas:

Cook

- I don't think she's mafia, for reasons that I have already explained, and if she had a power role, she would be participating in her strategy.

[WhemeStar]

T3 called it townie. What do you think of that

[Looker]

I've learned to take T3's judgement with a grain of salt. Also, I have my own brain.

[Looker]

What do

you

think of it, non-voter?

[Looker]

Both of your opening posts to the day seemed weird. Personally Id rather look at the last 2 counterwagons to the

mislynch

becasue odds are scum are there and both of you seemed to not want to do that.

Do you want Quiet Owl or do you want Dorsey? To whom were you referring with this?

[WhemeStar]

Both of your opening posts to the day seemed weird. Personally Id rather look at the last 2 counterwagons to the

mislynch

becasue odds are scum are there and both of you seemed to not want to do that.

Do you want Quiet Owl or do you want Dorsey? To whom were you referring with this?

I was referring to cook and T3

[Looker]

So you're willing to vote Cook with me?