Newbie 2075: Icecream Cake (Game Over)

[Looker]

Especially so close to deadline

[T3]

I've learned to take T3's judgement with a grain of salt. Also, I have my own brain.

you are sadly right

[Dorsey]

I think the plan is to stall until deadline so we can have a 'panic' (mis)elim again. I'm okay with getting rid of WhemeStar or Cook.

[Quiet Owl]

Spoiler: So I take it you support Cook's role-fishing

Cook:

Town, based on off-site meta. Though I think this strategy would be better off being tested in a normal game where the whole point is to try and break newD3, not in a newbie game. That being said, I'm not the tracker.

Owl - I thought the initial reads list was kind of early. I don't know what to think of that yet.

Why focus on this and not how I've been defending Cook, who you've got written down as scum? Personally I'd find the latter far more alarming.

Likely vanillas:

Cook

- I don't think she's mafia, for reasons that I have already explained, and if she had a power role, she would be participating in her strategy.

Support? No. I don't think it belongs in a newbie game with genuine newbies- it's a very non-standard and setup specific approach to the game. Think that it indicates that she's scum? No.

[Dorsey]

The first post is you saying you're not a tracker - isn't that helping her find power roles, as in (supporting) rolefishing? And the third post is you looking for power roles by way of exclusion.

[Quiet Owl]

The first post is you saying you're not a tracker - isn't that helping her find power roles, as in (supporting) rolefishing? And the third post is you looking for power roles by way of exclusion.

I am curious as to if the strategy works.
Third post: That was when I gave up on trying to find scum normally. I'm aware that I was inevitably going to come under fire for that, but if I was mafia, I would have posted that in the daytalk topic, not here, and stuck rigidly to a "safer" method of playing.

[Dorsey]

That's the same defense you gave for Cook - "too bold to be scum". Obviously I don't play that much; do you feel that's a good mantra to go by in most games? I'm still trying to navigate the concept of Wine In Front Of Me.

[WhemeStar]

VOTE: Cook

I think I like this

[WhemeStar]

Eh idk actually

[WhemeStar]

I really don’t know if this is t3’s town meta

[Quiet Owl]

That's the same defense you gave for Cook - "too bold to be scum". Obviously I don't play that much; do you feel that's a good mantra to go by in most games? I'm still trying to navigate the concept of Wine In Front Of Me.

Why ask me, of all people? This is my first game here. But since you ask, I used to play an Among Us clone regularly, in which a frequent scenario was someone doing something incredibly suspicious, getting ejected, and then turning out to be a regular old crewmate. I assume this is applicable to mafia.

[Looker]

I really don’t know if this is t3’s town meta

So you think it's T3 and who? Who's their partner?

[Looker]

What's the likelihood of it being Quiet Owl and Whemestar? Daystart bus for towncred? Or T3 and Whemestar? One active, one lurk?

[T3]

I really don’t know if this is t3’s town meta

It's actually not, ftr. This thought was real.

[WhemeStar]

I really don’t know if this is t3’s town meta

So you think it's T3 and who? Who's their partner?

I don’t know I don’t partner hunt

[Looker]

I really don’t know if this is t3’s town meta

It's actually not, ftr. This thought was real.

How long until you consolidate onto one of the bigger wagons for an elim

[Dorsey]

Do you see what I mean?

[Dorsey]

5 hours left.

[Dorsey]

Looker - MegaZoom
WhemeStar - me, Quiet Owl
Cook - Looker, WhemeStar
MegaZoom - T3

Cook - not voting

[Cook]

VOTE: MegAzu

slot won't come back before deadline

[Dorsey]

VOTE: Cook

[Quiet Owl]

No chance of getting Wheme to slip in the five hours left, VOTE: MegAzumarill

[Dorsey]

We can't do Meg cuz Meg is friendly neighbor

[Dorsey]

But I feel we should do someone on Meg's wagon since it's opportunistic

[Looker]

This is why lurkers are worthless