White flag #824 game over

[northsidegal]

I think if you were town it wouldn't be difficult for you to convince us

like, you realize this is a ridiculous thing to say, right?

You did say you were able to obvtown ?

did i misremember or something

you are being wildly bad faith right now.

[northsidegal]

like, you've completely sidestepped my questions regarding your read on me, then implied it was just sheeping, and this idea that "if you were town it wouldn't be hard to show us" is just flat out an absurd thing to say. i can't reason you out of a position you don't seem to have any reasons to have, and again - i really just don't have all that much time, in case you're expecting some giant wall posts.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

i mean you disappearing for a long period of time feels like what scum!you does and sheeping is just part of it,

[northsidegal]

time for some 100% motivated reasoning.

VOTE: pooky

i'm listening to what murdercat said. he was right last time this happened, maybe he's right again. your play day one and in fact this entire game has been flat out lazy, uncaring, your vote on yourself day two was performative, and i don't believe that you actually believe any of the things you're saying to be.

honestly this vote is more of just a statement of spite than anything, but whatever. if i'm still alive next tomorrow then i'll review more.

[northsidegal]

i mean you disappearing for a long period of time feels like what scum!you does and sheeping is just part of it,

again:

and do you think there's significant evidence of that this game? and if your response to that is to point to my non-appearance recently, 1) what explains my play on day 1 and 2) how does your belief compare to the alternative hypothesis of me just actually getting busy recently?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

if all you're going to do is omgus its very hard for me to believe you're town

[northsidegal]

there's actually nothing about my play this game that matches my scum play and it's not even close. and i don't just randomly expect people to know that especially given how infrequently i play now, but for someone claiming some familiarity with me it's completely different.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

r you going to do some kind of self meta thing to show you're town?

all i know of your scum play is that someone told me you're not really interested in solving and you have trouble sustaining effort when you're scum and I see you're not around so I think probly scum.

[northsidegal]

if all you're going to do is omgus its very hard for me to believe you're town

is there some reason you can't answer my questions? it just feels dishonest for you not to answer really basic questions like: "if nsg doesn't post much as scum, why is this only happening now instead of day one?" and "what evidence is there to believe the idea that this is an expression of scum meta instead of real life business?"

[implosion]

that's great to hear, really makes the game enjoyable

The word of the day is,

[northsidegal]

r you going to do some kind of self meta thing to show you're town?

all i know of your scum play is that someone told me you're not really interested in solving and you have trouble sustaining effort when you're scum and I see you're not around so I think probly scum.

aren't you supposed to be a better player than this? like, even if you're scum pretending to be town. that's sort of my hangup here.

and this isn't even about you being wrong-because obviously i was wrong, probably am, and will be again and again in every game, there's nothing bad about that-it's about the thought process.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

"if nsg doesn't post much as scum, why is this only happening now instead of day one?"


there's a difference between sustained effort over an entire game and effort at the beginning.


"what evidence is there to believe the idea that this is an expression of scum meta instead of real life business?"

I don't know what your RL is like because I'm neither a stalker nor a psychic.

[implosion]

I think I'm going to Formally Swap nsg and pooky in my reads list and declare that the scumteam is, without a shred of doubt, Not_Mafia and PookyTheMagicalBear.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

aren't you supposed to be a better player than this? like, even if you're scum pretending to be town. that's sort of my hangup here.

and this isn't even about you being wrong-because obviously i was wrong, probably am, and will be again and again in every game, there's nothing bad about that-it's about the thought process.

if I was scum I would never have defended bugspray d1 I just let them die lol

[northsidegal]

"if nsg doesn't post much as scum, why is this only happening now instead of day one?"


there's a difference between sustained effort over an entire game and effort at the beginning.

and you have evidence or reason to believe that one is specifically scum indicative for me over the other? or are you just fitting a narrative?

"what evidence is there to believe the idea that this is an expression of scum meta instead of real life business?"

I don't know what your RL is like because I'm neither a stalker nor a psychic.

so what you're saying is that you have no evidence whatsoever, no reason to believe what you're saying over the null hypothesis.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

"if nsg doesn't post much as scum, why is this only happening now instead of day one?"


there's a difference between sustained effort over an entire game and effort at the beginning.

and you have evidence or reason to believe that one is specifically scum indicative for me over the other? or are you just fitting a narrative?

"what evidence is there to believe the idea that this is an expression of scum meta instead of real life business?"

I don't know what your RL is like because I'm neither a stalker nor a psychic.

so what you're saying is that you have no evidence whatsoever, no reason to believe what you're saying over the null hypothesis.

I just see you not around and think "that's scummy she's not here"


yes I am very simpleminded.

I have no evidence about your RL because it would be creepy af if I did.

[northsidegal]

you say you want some bombshell post or self meta that clears me? fine, here's a truth bomb for you - i have to go to sleep and wake up in less than five hours. there's no scum game on the planet that i'd still be here talking for.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

you say you want some bombshell post or self meta that clears me? fine, here's a truth bomb for you - i have to go to sleep and wake up in less than five hours. there's no scum game on the planet that i'd still be here talking for.

mmm ok

unvote

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

good night

[northsidegal]

I just see you not around and think "that's scummy she's not here"


yes I am very simpleminded.

I have no evidence about your RL because it would be creepy af if I did.

it's not about you having evidence of me in real life. it's about you not having a reason to believe the hypothesis that my not being here is scum indicative compared to the null hypothesis of me just being busy, which consistently happens in town and scum games. if you don't have this reason, why still accept the alternative hypothesis?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I don't know if you are scum ghosting the thread or town who is too busy irl to post.

just like I don't know anyone's alignment in this game for sure except my own.

I make guesses.

That's just how the game works?

[northsidegal]

No. The game works on

inferences

based on reasons to believe one hypothesis over another. If you don't have such a reason, then yes, you would he just making guesses.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

ok I usually just make wild ass guesses I'm not smart enough to make

inferences

[Not_Mafia]

I think I'm going to Formally Swap nsg and pooky in my reads list and declare that the scumteam is, without a shred of doubt, Not_Mafia and PookyTheMagicalBear.

[Not_Mafia]

I wish I'd hammered now, that was a very underwhelming series of posts