1) stupid to not try when they're already down 1 member on 1In post 2874, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:Or if math and house are both town it is possible scum no killed because they expected that due to Math and House's abilities that it would be impossible to know who is innocent or guilty based on their results. For this scum has to assume House will try to roleblock though.
In post 2875, House wrote:1) stupid to not try when they're already down 1 member on n1*In post 2874, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:Or if math and house are both town it is possible scum no killed because they expected that due to Math and House's abilities that it would be impossible to know who is innocent or guilty based on their results. For this scum has to assume House will try to roleblock though.
2) Roleblock is an easy assumption to make considering I dropped trou.
Haven't read these linked posts yet to validate the legwork yet, just quoting with some added post tags for laterIn post 2535, Almost50 wrote:A) YthanIn post 2437, MathBlade wrote:For those of you who think DGB is scum, who with?
For those of you who think DGB is town, who is scum?
B) Ythan & someone else.
Seriously though, maybe we need to all calm down and analyze how D1 went down separately. Maybe everyone should give reasons to why they think X, Y & Z are cleared by now.
The reason I put House back in my PoE is his behaviour around the Wake yeet wagon. Coupled with Wake self-hammering it felt like "maybe" Wake realized House was defending him too hard at that point, taking away all previous anti-associatives. In my mind, it could be that House did approach Wake to help him get into the game, and was expressing genuine disappointment it didn't work out, while Wake was angry to be pushed by hi own partner. Also Wake flipping Rolecop after House had claimed a Rolecop shot is... a bit confusing to say the least?
Overnight I did a quick revision and this is what I put down in my notes:
Nero is Town (484)
Cat is Town (1456)
Kerset is Town (1784)
Math is Town (1820 & 1822)
Kyouko is Town (1977)
Andres is Town (hard pushed by Scum!Wake)
Titus is Town (stood her ground on the Wake wagon)
DotW is “probably” Town (gut read)
The remaining 2 scums are in DGB/House/Ythan
Note: With the exception of SRing Math; Nero's initial reads prove magical as always
Now unless House has suddenly turned into a RADIANTCOWBELL clone I don't think him & DGB are scum partners, so Ythan is now my prime suspect. Looking back at his entrance he was oddly focused on whether my lullaby rhymed. That was a strange thing to be pivoted on after replacing into the game.
In post 2554, Almost50 wrote:I can neither believe nor disbelieve him. I think it's much much more likely you protected me though,In post 2468, MathBlade wrote:What do you make of House saying he blocked DGB?
I said I was a "self-targeting FN", meaning I can only be confirmed to myself.. i.e. a VT. You said you'd JK me, and I accepted, even before I got your "Simple" modifier crumb.
The Kyouko somehow found imaginary crumbs for me that I was a Watcher, and I rolled with it. I couldn't have cared less if Scum thought I was a PR and worth their shot.
So, if you did target me you most likely did protect me.
Why would Kerset be excited about Wake being wagoned?In post 2879, House wrote:1784 is hardly clearing, but whatevs.
I mean... you don't already know?In post 2560, Almost50 wrote:I wasn't even. Kyouko brought it up, and I rolled with it. I didn't even ask what crumbs because it would have confirmed me as NOT being a Watcher.In post 2492, MathBlade wrote:I had a gut feeling you were faking watcher crumbs.
@Kyouko: Now is the time to show me my so-called Watcher crumbs. Thank you.
In post 1387, Almost50 wrote:Just because aIn post 1380, Dragon of the West wrote:This post pings me. Reads similarly to how A50 acted in 235 where the whole time he was super jovial and unhelpful. I don't know if that's A50's schtick but it seems scum indicative to me
is acting
doesn't make them a p
If this is the case Math is just a Simple Doctor because if House is town his block only works on PRs, if House blocked DGB and A50 is a scum watcher, then all 3 of the scumteam are PRs, meaning Math's role is just a doc. Weird to think the mod would make him a JK instead of a doc, if his only ability effectively is to doc. Maybe the idea is to bait Math into trying to stop the kill by targeting a potential goon, but seems like a weird train of thought to entertain, even if it's moonIn post 2570, House wrote:That would make for a hilarious dead thread, if dwlee outed night actions.In post 2568, MathBlade wrote:DGB And A50.In post 2566, House wrote:I love moon logic.In post 2562, MathBlade wrote:Ready for some moonlogic House?In post 2559, House wrote:You copied that claim from me, btw.In post 2554, Almost50 wrote:I said I was a "self-targeting FN"
I have a really weird theory.
A50 is scum watcher.
Claiming watcher dooms DGB to elim.
So he has to claim VT.
But I think I may be paranoid and A50 is probably VT but I hate my paranoia.
Didnt someone (DGB?) say he flipped rolecop? I've been away and assumed that was correct, will have to double checkIn post 2580, MathBlade wrote:Nah I think A50 scum watcher doesn’t make sense.
Because Wake is Voyeur.
Tbh I was hoping to be useless you claim watcher and DGB lock scum. I was hoping I was wrong and you were a Watcher.
yes, something weird is happening there I am pretty sure.In post 2598, MathBlade wrote:Because Ythan isn’t in you and DGB.In post 2597, Almost50 wrote:Is there a new rule against social talk in a game thread? You see a friend talk about something in their life and you respond to it. That's normal in my book.In post 2557, MathBlade wrote:Why the weird iguana talk with Titus?
Also, why haven't you asked Ythan the same question? He wanted to see them iguana's. Why is my talking about them any different?
Titus I think would have told me about iguanas.
So I think something weird is happening.
Looks to me like he was poking fun at the 2 players with Hugh Laurie avatars both being the top wagons, which is NAI.In post 2881, Almost50 wrote:Why would Kerset be excited about Wake being wagoned?In post 2879, House wrote:1784 is hardly clearing, but whatevs.
lmaoIn post 2619, Almost50 wrote:ROFLMGO!In post 2617, MathBlade wrote:All images of watches
Read the BRANDS!
DtoW said I was acting "Jovial" so I said "Just because a CITIZEN was acting JOVIAL doesn't mean they're SEIKO (Psycho)". That's yet another VT crumb. CITIZEN!
@A50: hence my...
In post 2512, Titus wrote:With the way he pushed the Wake wagon? I doubt it.In post 2505, House wrote:Yep.In post 2504, Ythan wrote:Okay so we have either an a50 clear or an a50 goon guilty or a dgb guilty is that right?
Leaning towards A50 guilty, myself.
Does that fencepost have a comfy cushion?In post 2521, Titus wrote:Wake was situationally weak with his nonpresence in the thread.In post 2519, House wrote:Typically a goon or weak player gets sacrificed on d1.In post 2516, Nero Cain wrote:I mean, it's not 100% impossible b/c scum know who each other are and scum bussing their buddies to look better is a thing.In post 2512, Titus wrote:With the way he pushed the Wake wagon? I doubt it.
Wake was neither.
House DGB, and DGB tried to kill A50, is the implication of A50's post.In post 2716, MathBlade wrote:House Kerset?In post 2715, Almost50 wrote:I call this a slip.In post 2708, House wrote:Ok Stephen Hawking, why does Math block DGB's shot?
VOTE: House
I have family in town for another dayIn post 2721, MathBlade wrote:Could also do Kyo Kerset Kyo has been hella quiet
Do you think Ythan targeted you on n1?In post 2895, Almost50 wrote:OK... so... if I buy House & Math are both Town I think my preferred lim would be Ythan
VOTE: Ythan
Sheep me at will
