Final Fantasy XIV - A Realm Reborn Mafia (Game Over)

[Romance]

I /think/ I would take out Mystic Bears as well.

Hard disagree.

- House

How much experience do you have with them?

[Dwlee99]

(WhemeStar, RealCheeks, Qrow and Raven, Save the Dragons, ArcAngel9)
Is a kill list I'm behind

[Bell]

I will note that this increased level of activity is notable for most scum.
So probably they're getting left behind and overwhelmed. Or I'm being silly.
Either or.

[Mandelbrot]

I /think/ I would take out Mystic Bears as well.

Hard disagree.

- House

How much experience do you have with them?

I have experience with Elsa being satisfied having his name left out of the raid with MB's in his place.

I'm never trusting that slot.

- House

[Mystic Bears]

I cant do shit because a strongman and a roleblocker exists and i cant even be sure if the strongman is in the raid rn or not trying to get their strongman shot back.

Oh actually we should just not fill this raid at all. The risk of scum getting an extra RBer or strongman shot is not worth the plus 1 shot. I'm thinking about it like this
Since scum have RBer, town probably doesn't.
Our tracker is dead
even adding a cop 1 shot can't compare with scum RBer or Strongman 1 shot.
Adding a role cop, flavor cop, visitor, watcher, doc, vig, fn are all good but RBer and Strongman are still stronger shots
We probably don't have a vig
watcher is really cool but if we had one, i imagine we'd have a guilty by now? Like if town watcher exists and isn't targeting romance every night, they're absolutely insane and deserve to be voted out period.
Visitor is a dumb role
the other cops are weaker than regular cop

[Bell]

Aa9 is a blank slate and I don't really care whether they're vigged, investigated, or blind eliminated.

[RealCheeks]

tbf this raid might be better forcing it to fail.

It would be better to get all your townreads in minus mastina and use it as a check, the +1 may come in handy when you catch the RB
~C

[Sakura Hana]

I have experience with Elsa being satisfied having his name left out of the raid with MB's in his place.

I'm never trusting that slot.

Ah I see.
Do you think toog is town?

[Mandelbrot]

I'd rather flip RC.

- House

[Dwlee99]

Oh it's possible to not fill the raid? Can people still on it pass it or no?

[Romance]

Reading this still so y'all know I'm not silent. Not feeling super well but I'm keeping up.

Will try and sleep and then make a Readlist that's better but going purely off of the people on the failed raid atm... I'm not including myself, and I trust Sakura and Romance's claims. So here's my elim order preference from the other 5.

1: TC (still doubt the weird posts but can compromise)
2: Bell (least townie of the rest)
3: Tictac
4: Dwlee
5: Cheeks

Do we all think this list is 5/5 town?

[Sakura Hana]

I cant do shit because a strongman and a roleblocker exists and i cant even be sure if the strongman is in the raid rn or not trying to get their strongman shot back.

Oh actually we should just not fill this raid at all. The risk of scum getting an extra RBer or strongman shot is not worth the plus 1 shot. I'm thinking about it like this
Since scum have RBer, town probably doesn't.
Our tracker is dead
even adding a cop 1 shot can't compare with scum RBer or Strongman 1 shot.
Adding a role cop, flavor cop, visitor, watcher, doc, vig, fn are all good but RBer and Strongman are still stronger shots
We probably don't have a vig
watcher is really cool but if we had one, i imagine we'd have a guilty by now? Like if town watcher exists and isn't targeting romance every night, they're absolutely insane and deserve to be voted out period.
Visitor is a dumb role
the other cops are weaker than regular cop

Imagine if we could know all these things with a massclaim.
Oh well.

[RealCheeks]

As much as it would be nice for this to be easy mode, it would be wise to check your townblock.
~C

[Bell]

I think we should just put the same names in the raid and see if it fails or not.
I can be the control if someone in the raid died. I guess that would be Elsa.
So yeah, just replace me with Elsa and then we'll see if there's any scum in there.

[Sakura Hana]

Do we all think this list is 5/5 town?

nope

[Sakura Hana]

Oh it's possible to not fill the raid? Can people still on it pass it or no?

If raid doesnt fill it automatically fails.

[Bell]

Always suspect the middle option for middle of the road scum.

[Dwlee99]

Scum can also pass the raid bell

[RealCheeks]

It's not possible to skip raid, it will autofill.
~C

[Mandelbrot]

I have experience with Elsa being satisfied having his name left out of the raid with MB's in his place.

I'm never trusting that slot.

Ah I see.
Do you think toog is town?

I'm willing to give him town cred for his role in eliminating Elsa.

If he was scum with Elsa, no way did that flavor get 1) claimed in the first place, and 2) called out.

Elsa wagon probably dies yesterDay without him.

- House

[Bell]

But isn't Tictac confirmed town or something.
People kept saying that but I had no idea what they were talking about.

[Romance]

We need to hear from mastina.

[Dwlee99]

How does it autofill? I thought that was only when there are 8 or less people

[Mandelbrot]

Reading this still so y'all know I'm not silent. Not feeling super well but I'm keeping up.

Will try and sleep and then make a Readlist that's better but going purely off of the people on the failed raid atm... I'm not including myself, and I trust Sakura and Romance's claims. So here's my elim order preference from the other 5.

1: TC (still doubt the weird posts but can compromise)
2: Bell (least townie of the rest)
3: Tictac
4: Dwlee
5: Cheeks

Do we all think this list is 5/5 town?

Absolutely not.

- House

[Bell]

Scum can also pass the raid bell

I personally think town gains the advantage the more town that are in a raid.