Mini Normal 2267 | Music Hits of 2010-2014 | GAME OVER

[Andresvmb]

Oh and Galron.

They’ve basically argued {angela, I, Kitty (by claim), Scorpious} are Town. The only controversial take there is Scorpious, and basically they want anybody but Scorpious dead today.

@Andante, please clarify what you meant.

[Andante]

what i meant on what?

[Andresvmb]

what i meant on what?

Why do you like STD’s reads?

[Andresvmb]

They seem half-assed, and frankly just bad.

[Andante]

im not casing and reading 60 pages on my phone, and have a major thing to do after classes, so y’all aren’t getting full reads till likely tomorrow? not sure i understand the question

[Andante]

half just a joke? but also like the “that’s me!!” had me laughing so I like them

[Andante]

i haven’t read much so it’s not like i’m judging the content there

[Andresvmb]

I like dragons reads. Dragons seems towny!!!

ok gg. 1 read a day... read for today is done

You wrote this. If you haven’t read much, and don’t have much of a sense for what’s going on, why would you say you like STDs reads? That seems like a fair question yeah?

[Andante]

STD’s pool is {geraintm, Andante, Rathe, Nero Cain, Malcolm Tucker}. Tell me that’s not wide as all hell.

wide pool isn’t bad?? all I have to do is tey and I’m pretty sure I’m out of the pool

[Andresvmb]

Like when someone says they like someone else’s reads, it’s because they tend to agree with them. If you just like that they made a set of reads and aren’t judging the content… I think that’s just suspicious.

[Andante]

then it’s a pool of 4, and that’s not bad…

[Save The Dragons]

ger isn't in my pool and i didn't say he should have solved the game by d2 i said it was annoying they can't seem to play d1 and didn't bring up anything juicy so far now that they "can play" or whatever they couldn't do d1

my pool is wide but some of those are just leans. i don't think that that's unreasonable considering you have 1 neutral, 1 uncertain, and 3 scum reads yourself.

[Andante]

Like when someone says they like someone else’s reads, it’s because they tend to agree with them. If you just like that they made a set of reads and aren’t judging the content… I think that’s just suspicious.

suspicious? lmao ok… nice to meet you! I’m Andante, this is me… welcome to my gameplay

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: unvote

[Andresvmb]

ger isn't in my pool and i didn't say he should have solved the game by d2 i said it was annoying they can't seem to play d1 and didn't bring up anything juicy so far now that they "can play" or whatever they couldn't do d1

my pool is wide but some of those are just leans. i don't think that that's unreasonable considering you have 1 neutral, 1 uncertain, and 3 scum reads yourself.

Yeah geraintm is null, but I’m not actively SR’ing them right now. The Uncertain is for reasons I’ve explained. And I don’t think my SRs are unreasonable, even if they include you. You disagree on Scorpious which fine whatever I’m having a hard time nailing that down completely, but outside of Kitty due to their role, and angela, we really aren’t looking at the same game. So I was interested to figure out why Andante decided to praise you for posting a list of reads, but said nothing about mine (outside of hey I have my own Tier), when they haven’t read the game really. That just seems odd.

[Save The Dragons]

i wasn't saying you read are bad or anything i was pointing out you have a lot of {?} which i have a lot of {?} too

i tr kitty from play yesterday so just because i mentioned the doesn't mean that's the only thing i'm considering. we also agree nero is suspicious and potentially andante, and that ger is null, so i dunno why you're acting like my list is bad when we do have some common points

[Andresvmb]

And a wide pool is not Town positive.

I’m opening myself up for criticism if say Nero, STD, and Scorpious all flip Town. Like, clearly. And if Galron, Rathe, and angela have all fooled me, I will look like an idiot. STD gets to gloat meaningfully if Scorpious flips Town, but then gets to say regardless of what happens elsewhere for the most part, that they had them in the POE but are actively trying to sort. There’s a clear difference in potential blowback depending on how the game develops, and I’m not perceiving that as a positive.

[Andante]

VOTE: unvote

YOU’RE THINKING IM TOWN? AND… I haven’t made reads yet? LEGGOOOOO THIS IS A WIN!!!

[Save The Dragons]

i'm not sure about you yet i just don't know if i wanna vote you atm (@andante)

[Andante]

nice

[Rathe]

Any unique reasoning here or just hopping on the wagon?

new information i dont hop on wagons just to be on there

[Save The Dragons]

this is what i feel. it's not a wide pool, it's one more scumread than you. (@andres)

scum is in = {galron, nero, rathe, malcolmtucker}

null = {ger}

uncertain = {andante}

town = {rest}

[Andresvmb]

i wasn't saying you read are bad or anything i was pointing out you have a lot of {?} which i have a lot of {?} too

i tr kitty from play yesterday so just because i mentioned the doesn't mean that's the only thing i'm considering. we also agree nero is suspicious and potentially andante, and that ger is null, so i dunno why you're acting like my list is bad when we do have some common points

Kitty is almost surely mechanically cleared so I can’t read into that one.

I want more from Nero, and I don’t trust how you played the end of day yesterday. Yeah of course we have common points you can’t possibly disagree with everything I’m saying that would be absurd. But what I’m struggling the most isn’t the conclusions necessarily. Like why is Galron suspicious to you? Why are they not at all memorable? What do you make of their vote on angela that is still sitting out there?

I can be very wrong. Of course. I have played some really horrid games. But at the very least I want to understand your mindset and then make up my mind. Your reads list does seem half-assed to me and there’s not a whole lot to grab onto to criticize later if you turn out to be wrong and that’s what pinging me more than anything.

[Rathe]

i dont try to figure out the setup n in this current scenario u r not looking good if both kitty n angela r town

[Scorpious]

Any unique reasoning here or just hopping on the wagon?

new information i dont hop on wagons just to be on there

you answered me so thats fair..