Newbie 2093 | New Wave | Postgame

[catboi]

Vote Count 1.02

ItalianoVD (2):

Asphodelus, BigTerp

Asphodelus (1):

Val89

CornPuffBuddha (1):

abdbla

TTTT (1):

Takemikazuchi02

BigTerp (1):

CornPuffBuddha

Takemikazuchi02 (1):

TTTT

Not Voting (2):

furtiveglance, ItalianoVD

With 9 alive, it's 5 to eliminate.

Deadline for Day 1 is April 24 at 6:00 PM EST.

Deadline Timer:

(expired on 2022-04-24 18:00:00)

Notes:

Asphodelus is V/LA from 4/16-4/18

[CornPuffBuddha]

I do not understand TTTT's interpretation of T02's 60.

Italiano seeming somewhat null to me right now. @Italiano, could you give your thoughts on the game so far as soon as you're able? You asked for someone to fill you in but didn't really do anything more than that once TTTT did so. This could be called a reach, but it seems a little strange to ask for help catching up considering how little actual content the game has so far, feels to me like wanting to look participatory but not actually doing anything to forward the gamestate.

[Takemikazuchi02]

TTTT is probably just spewing any bullshit he can think of to get reactions. I don't like his attitude but its NAI.

[Val89]

I do not understand TTTT's interpretation of T02's 60.

To be fair, my initial reaction to seeing 60 was to wonder if that was a townread. Thinking about it a bit more, there isn't anything to support that, but I think it's important to note that was the gut reaction I had to that post as well.

With respect to votes on T02 and CPB, I saw TTTT made reference to this 'tell' in a recent game, although I can't remember off the top of my head if it was the one we were scum together, and the application of that would tally with 16 and 23. I'm sure there was a point to this, but I forget what it is now. I shall give this gave some more attention once my visitors have taken their leave tomorrow evening.

[abdbla]

As for why I chose you over T02, I think your posting is reminiscent of your posting in the previous game.

can you elaborate on this some more?

CPB in the previous game of making posts where a lot of what was said was empty air, observations obvious to anyone at a glance. See 55 and 49.

abdbla said he didn't want to put Asph at E-2 even though he scumread Asph

this is misrepresentative of why I wanted to vote Asphodel.

[abdbla]

EBWOP: "CPB in the previous game of making posts" -> "CPB in the previous game

had a habit

of making posts"

[furtiveglance]

abdbla's push on Corn is weird. The reason given is that Corn's posts have been airy, but that's the same for everyone so far.

As for Take 'assuming' TTTT was town, I think that wording can come from town.

VOTE: abdbla

[abdbla]

abdbla's push on Corn is weird. The reason given is that Corn's posts have been airy, but that's the same for everyone so far.

What? It's the reason I'm choosing CPB over T02. The reason I want to push T02, CPB or Asphodel is because from a personal standpoint I'll gain more from pushing those three. If you're implying that T02 has airy posts, I guess I just disagree.

I said this in 57, but sure, a lot of people have airy posts. I haven't played with most of those people, however.

[furtiveglance]

Oh ok. I didn't realise you limited your initial voting pool to people you previously played with. Still seems like a weird move and I didn't like the explanation for the vote, it seemed a bit mechanical. so I'll keep mine where it is.

[ItalianoVD]

How does that assume you're town? You could be just maf pretending to be doing pro-town things.

I do not understand TTTT's interpretation of T02's 60.

Italiano seeming somewhat null to me right now. @Italiano, could you give your thoughts on the game so far as soon as you're able? You asked for someone to fill you in but didn't really do anything more than that once TTTT did so. This could be called a reach, but it seems a little strange to ask for help catching up considering how little actual content the game has so far, feels to me like wanting to look participatory but not actually doing anything to forward the gamestate.

You both decide to say this in the scum chat?

[furtiveglance]

Explain this very bold and early gamesolve please.

[ItalianoVD]

If you want me to forward the gamestate I can, but scum won’t like that because this game will be short. I’d rather take a laid back approach and follow someone I feel is towny.

[ItalianoVD]

Are you town Furtive?

[furtiveglance]

I am town. Then again scum would probably say that too.

[furtiveglance]

Italiano do you actually suspect either Take or Corn?

[Takemikazuchi02]

You guys should take a look at game 2091 since half the players here played there and you may get an idea on our playstyles.

@Italiano

We decided in scum chat that TTTT's bullshit argument was bullshit? You're gonna need to try harder than that.

[furtiveglance]

I read 2091, it was over pretty quickly

[CornPuffBuddha]

As for abdbla thinking my posts seem airy, I actually think they're significantly more substantive here than they were in 2091, and even there I think my posting was generally pretty average in terms of content. I suppose that's not a surprising position from me, and I don't see any point to debating it, but I wanted to say that. I can see how 49 could be perceived as extraneous but just disagree when it comes to 55.

Not to be holding hands with Take but I pretty much just second their 90. Italiano's play here is so brazenly unreasonable that I am actually wondering if it's some kind of advanced flailing that no scum would be bold enough to attempt.

That being said, I see no reason to keep my vote on Terp.

UNVOTE: BigTerp

VOTE: ItalianoVD

I believe this puts Italiano at E-2.

[ItalianoVD]

You guys should take a look at game 2091 since half the players here played there and you may get an idea on our playstyles.

@Italiano

We decided in scum chat that TTTT's bullshit argument was bullshit? You're gonna need to try harder than that.

Oh sorry I guess I didn’t make it clear. Apologies.

[ItalianoVD]

How does that assume you're town? You could be just maf pretending to be doing pro-town things.

…feels to me like wanting to look participatory but not actually doing anything to forward the gamestate.

This is what I meant.

[ItalianoVD]

Italiano do you actually suspect either Take or Corn?

I couldn’t tell you, haven’t read much of the game, but I assume I won’t find anything substantive anyway. It’s only 4 pages. Things don’t really get good until around pg 10.

[ItalianoVD]

Italiano's play here is so brazenly unreasonable that I am actually wondering if it's some kind of advanced flailing that no scum would be bold enough to attempt.

And yet you still vote me.

[ItalianoVD]

I am town. Then again scum would probably say that too.

They would, but I’m gonna assume you’re telling the truth for now. Tell me about abdbla.

[Takemikazuchi02]

You're making no sense italiano. Explain your thought process about me and corn clearly.

[CornPuffBuddha]

How does that assume you're town? You could be just maf pretending to be doing pro-town things.

…feels to me like wanting to look participatory but not actually doing anything to forward the gamestate.

This is what I meant.

The basic thrust of what you said remains the same. For what it's worth I don't think I had even noticed 72 when I wrote 76. I find the idea Take and I are sitting in scumchat making sure we're agreeing with and parroting eachother in the main thread to be rather comical, having similar observations on page 4 in these circumstances is simply not a scumtell.

95 - So are you walking back 84? I don't understand.

96 -

"And yet you still vote me."

Indeed.

Furtive's vote on abdbla seems fairly unremarkable to me.