In post 1726, Meuh wrote:
What feels gross about it, and do you think these “gross” parts make me scum?
I listed the parts I felt bad about literally immediately after part you quoted - in the 2nd part of your response to 3), I didn't like the original "I did it as scum so he's probably also doing it as scum" jump on Lavar without considering your previous read on him, and I wouldn't be surprised if you did that as scum to have a solid reason to scumread a town player. (though tbf I do think it can plausibly come from town or scum)
And in 4) the parts I quoted
Meuh wrote:4. There was a vote on Gorilla, I like voting where there's votes.
5. I wanted to see where the wagon went to assess Enchant better, like I did with Lavar on day 1.
6. While making my readslist, I realized how unsubstantial my read on Gorilla was at that point. Questioning myself on it, it felt like an odd read to let exist in spite of this.
just don't feel like a genuine town thought process to me, it feels like an overjustification of something you didn't actually put as much thought into as you're saying you did now.
There's like a minor mitigating factor in that fire was specifically asking for more of your reasoning on the gorilla read so part of the "overjustification" I felt may have been you going into more detail than usual to answer his question, but I still don't believe you were thinking about the parts I quoted at the beginning of Day 2 when the gorilla/marci thing was originally happening.
Also as an unrelated thing:
In post 1736, Meuh wrote: In post 1734, Dunnstral wrote:@Luke
My invictus will be on gorilla tonight. I don't feel bad about claiming this because I really don't think I will be targeted by mafia or that they benefit from shooting into that. I'm telling you this so you have somewhere to use your power role if you can't coordinate anything before an elimination is reached. I think it would not be a bad idea for a few people to do the same, but that for most people this would be a bad idea.
Okay yeah let's maybe not lim Dunn today
Also I just remembered a good bit of what had me clear Dwlee earlier was the LLD kill. Meh I guess that's relevant, but not enough to avoid limming an otherwise scummy player imo. This also makes me curious: could the mafia have like a doctor? (Who would then block invictus kills) That could be a way to mitigate town's power and make mass-targeting one person bad, right?
I would bet the game on scum not having a full doctor, it defeats the entire point of the Invictus mechanic. (scum needing to play around their nightkills potentially Invictus shots). scum had a bodyguard in the last Invictus game, and either that or something like 1-shot of any of doc/jailkeeper/mayyybe bulletproof (though that's pushing it) could potentially exist though.
