Open 856: Deputy cultists (Game over)

[Bellaphant]

I want to ask why to both of the above posts. Although tbf I am town reading cat for bad reasons.

[Enchant]

Plainly, game won instantly after Cult Leader is dead, so it's always in benefit to simple massclaim D1.

On D2 and afterwards, assuming someone is converted, there will be always doubt that PR is converted and traded claims with Cult Leader to let him not look suspicious.

So... Yep. From my POV i have 1/10 chance to hit CL, if every PR claims without challenge, it turns in 1/7.

Why not?

[Bellaphant]

It's not a why not question, I'm just really bad at mech/set up. I'm pretty sure this is my first cult game, although I might've done a marathon ones years ago.

[Nathann]

Inclined to agree with Jacket that Enchant seems slightly Townie from their posting so far. Probably going to extend that feeling onto Jacket for the time being too.

Beat might be Town for 23. I disagree with the idea, but I think most Scum would be hesitant to recommend that strategy in their first post.

Let's try to VOTE: RH9.

I want to ask why to both of the above posts. Although tbf I am town reading cat for bad reasons.

Can I know what those reasons are?

[Jacket]

Plainly, game won instantly after Cult Leader is dead, so it's always in benefit to simple massclaim D1.

On D2 and afterwards, assuming someone is converted, there will be always doubt that PR is converted and traded claims with Cult Leader to let him not look suspicious.

So... Yep. From my POV i have 1/10 chance to hit CL, if every PR claims without challenge, it turns in 1/7.

Why not?

Can't the PRs prove themselves on later days, though? I don't see why they need to out now.

[Enchant]

Plainly, game won instantly after Cult Leader is dead, so it's always in benefit to simple massclaim D1.

On D2 and afterwards, assuming someone is converted, there will be always doubt that PR is converted and traded claims with Cult Leader to let him not look suspicious.

So... Yep. From my POV i have 1/10 chance to hit CL, if every PR claims without challenge, it turns in 1/7.

Why not?

Can't the PRs prove themselves on later days, though? I don't see why they need to out now.

Vengeful proves self by being elimmed and ability to shot. You probably don't want to elim them to prove power, as they are not Cult Leaders.
Governor overrules day 4 and chooses elim. Well, we will know that obviously, but see next letters.

Both remain in power after conversation. Therefore having converted vengeful is not cool, as they turn in mine. It's easier to confirm them now and then don't touch them for game end. Converted Governor plainly gurantee that CL doesh't get killed, more over someone cult desire will elimmed instead.

[Cat.Jpeg]

Plainly, game won instantly after Cult Leader is dead, so it's always in benefit to simple massclaim D1.

On D2 and afterwards, assuming someone is converted, there will be always doubt that PR is converted and traded claims with Cult Leader to let him not look suspicious.

So... Yep. From my POV i have 1/10 chance to hit CL, if every PR claims without challenge, it turns in 1/7.

Why not?

If both PRs claim then Cult Leader would want to convert them for the ability. But then we would be wary of the PRs and would want to elim them, which if they are town they will get to use their power so maybe it's not that bad. If they aren't town that sucks. Seeing as to progress we need to elim a Cultist though it might be a medium idea. I think D4 governor should reveal, not sure about the others.

Question: It says vengeful townies only have their ability when elimminated. What if one vengeful townie is eliminated and chooses to kill the other vengeful townie? will the second one get a kill as well?

[Enchant]

Vengeful triggered when they are elimmed via vote.

Dying to vengeful doesh't trigger vengeful.

[Enchant]

... Who even converts Vengeful which claim d1? They claim and basically never elimmed, as they are again... Not Cult Leader with quarantee.
Governor probably can be converted for power, but if we don't manage to hit CL for 3 days, we kinda deserved to suck up.

[Enchant]

Overall setup sucks. All PRs are basically Innocent Atheists.

[Titus]

I am in this game.

Will read later and likely sheep the largest wagon.

[Nancy Drew 39]

ego

[Nathann]

... Who even converts Vengeful which claim d1? They claim and basically never elimmed, as they are again... Not Cult Leader with quarantee.
Governor probably can be converted for power, but if we don't manage to hit CL for 3 days, we kinda deserved to suck up.

I can see the idea behind the Vengeful Townies claiming now, actually, but the Governor should definitely stay silent. They can always claim later if they get run up.

Also, Enchant is Town.

[Bellaphant]

@nathaan, they made me laugh with their opening to enchant. I tend to find town are more relaxed and making me laugh has tended town before - cat was in a game recently where one of my reasons for scum reading someone was they made me laugh when we were both town but not that game.

[furtiveglance]

Hello everyone. I see that people are townreading Enchant and voting Jacket. I was actually the first to townread Enchant. I know I just got here but I thought "Enchant is town". In the Open Queue. When I saw them sign up. As for voting Jacket, they're probably not Cult Leader, and we win by voting CL. So I encourage everyone to do what is literally the best strategy and sheep me on someone random, that no one else has voted for yet.

[furtiveglance]

VOTE: Korina

GG.

[Titus]

VOTE: Korina

[Jacket]

As for voting Jacket, they're probably not Cult Leader, and we win by voting CL.

Correct, but why would you say that?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

VOTE: Korina

[furtiveglance]

You got put at E-2 on page 1.

[Bellaphant]

? Didn't/ don't they have the same votes on them as korina does?

I don't understand anything so far.

[Enchant]

You got put at E-2 on page 1.

E-3*

[Enchant]

I probably will make outrageous claim, but i won't hammer before vengefuls claim.

There's literally no reason for them to NOT. Otherwise i challenge you to internet boxing fight right now.

[Enchant]

Actually let's do it funny way.

Play game like normal, and on 3 days before deadline force Vengefuls to claim. Therefore we will know who could tried push them and vice versa.

[Enchant]

Problem is i suck at playing mafia but that's different question tbh.