Open 855: Not Mafia's Republic | Game Over

[Not_Mafia]

Aftersun is flailing

[Not_Mafia]

lol AbbyandRani is definitely scum based on page 78

[catboi]

VOTE: arete

I think this is more likely scum than spf, still

[PenguinPower]

VOTE: arete

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

VOTE: arete

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

arete if you're somehow mafia you should claim b4 u go to e-1 and everyone's favorite cow shows up

[catboi]

idk why you're just following me lol

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

i think they're both scum so i don't actually care which one we yeet

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

like fmpov there has to be at least one wolf in TownBlok[Arete, SPF, Catboi, SabiHydra]

Three of you swear it's absolutely impossible for Brad to be scum here so I'm fine throwing SabiHydra in the townbin section cuz even if they were a wolf it'd be impossible to yeet them, I'll just take the L there.

I don't think it's you cuz I don't think you get that tilted over being correctly pushed.

SPF/Arete has either one or two wolves and I'm leaning towards two rather than one cuz they both want to yeet in ShadyKrew when they should want to yeet each other.

If it's S/T then I dunno there r some good points for each, I have no idea how much SPF saying she is "SuPeR PoLArIZed and WaY OuT of WoOF RaNge" is true but I assume you know more about her than I do.

Also it'd be funny if we lose together.

[catboi]

If it's S/T then I dunno there r some good points for each, I have no idea how much SPF saying she is "SuPeR PoLArIZed and WaY OuT of WoOF RaNge" is true but I assume you know more about her than I do.

I don't think that's remotely true lol I just have a gut feeling on some of the stuff she's posted

I could be wrong of course

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

like even if Arete is town and SPF + ShadyKrew Person are the wolves, that means the wolves know who the mafia are and will shoot them overnight cuz 2-2-2 is basically unwinnable for wolves?

2-2-2 yeet a wolf, 1-2-2, shoot a townie -> 1-2-1 mafia victory or shoot a mafia -> 1-1-2, yeet wolf yeet mafia?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

so let's say we wake up tomm in 2-1-3, we yeet SPF then, go to 1-1-3, if wolves shoot town we're in 1-1-2, we basically can try to guess which one is the wolf OR we can no yeet and make the wolf shoot the mafia?

i dunno this setup is weird

[catboi]

like even if Arete is town and SPF + ShadyKrew Person are the wolves, that means the wolves know who the mafia are and will shoot them overnight cuz 2-2-2 is basically unwinnable for wolves?

2-2-2 yeet a wolf, 1-2-2, shoot a townie -> 1-2-1 mafia victory or shoot a mafia -> 1-1-2, yeet wolf yeet mafia?

IMHO at 1-1-2 it's better to let the wolf shoot mafia (because if they shoot town they lose) but yes this makes sense

[PenguinPower]

i dunno this setup is weird

yup

[staypositivefriend]

ok

VOTE: arete

[staypositivefriend]

Aftersun is flailing

ur partner is probably about to die, sorry xo

[Arete Lastname]

jesus fucking Christ okay I didn't want to do this but unlike some people I'm not a thrower so

I'm mafia

the THEORY yesterday was that I needed to be able to bring us home, so I'd spend all day tunnelling Ydrasse (thereby accruing towncred), which would also let me dodge the nightkill since wolves would be like 'oh they're tunnelling a rando nonwolf so they're not a threat,' and then if it actually worked (which I wasn't expecting it to but lolme I guess) they would claim mafia and call out [a wolf, we disagreed in mafia chat who the most likely wolf was] as being a wolf and everyone would switch over

and then instead of claiming she did not do that. I think my salt about that decision has been ... pretty obvious, lol. there are things I could point to in my posts that are like 'here is how I was trying to nudge the game as mafia' but I think this is actually the most obvious thing, is that I was furious with her, and trying to channel that fury into looking townie and mostly not even succeeding.

my reads have mostly been real but occasionally with adjusted confidence to look less suspicious, and obviously the reads on my partners have been fake (well the Ydrasse one was sorta real? it was real in the sense I believed it but fake in the sense I had TMI)

I do genuinely think Penguin is a wolf, I legitimately cannot fathom his posts being that bad as town

and I wasn't sure on SPF, obviously the PoE argument was completely fabricated but I do legitimately think her posts when people started trying to get us to dome make the most sense from the lens of 'wolf who legitimately believed I was town, didn't want to look outed from a townrete flip, but kinda needed me to stay PoE' -- this is also consistent with her making my scumgame sound way better than it was, it kind of sucks, like this game was multiball a.k.a. scum easy mode and I spent half of day 1 as top wagon, I think she was trying to make things up to make me sound more sus because she knew no one here could verify

not going to comment on anyone else for obvious reasons, those two are my top suspects and I think they work together

[Arete Lastname]

YES I REALIZE MY DAY 2 PLAY WAS BAD but please don't call me a thrower I wasn't throwing I just fucked up

[PenguinPower]

I do genuinely think Penguin is a wolf, I legitimately cannot fathom his posts being that bad as town

you should fathom

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

UNVOTE:

[PenguinPower]

VOTE: spf

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

if you're mafia and you're not teamed with Arete you should counter claim them.

if you don't that straight up game throwing imo

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

i still can't believe the mafia actually bussed in 5-3-2 thats so ridiculous holy shit

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

is it that much to ask that people just play optimally for their own alignment what the fuck my god

[Arete Lastname]

I do genuinely think Penguin is a wolf, I legitimately cannot fathom his posts being that bad as town

you should fathom

if she had just fucking claimed like we had fucking planned it would've been FINE