i read penetration fml im slow today. yeah i mean it's still kinda rvs so don't expect much more from me.In post 65, Gamma Emerald wrote:or at least, his presentation of it
In post 92, Haschel Cedricson wrote:Fascinating. Does this make sense to anybody else?In post 60, Seanzie wrote:I was kind of hoping someone would, yeah. Gotta get the game going somehow, and I read people better when they push me. Since I know no one here, it would have been helpful to see how people reacted to me.In post 57, schadd_ wrote:was somebody supposed to tell you it was scummy? what was your plan in that case
I think I remember a similar opening in kitty's last gameIn post 21, Gamma Emerald wrote:Does FP always open like this?In post 13, FancyPants wrote:VOTE: Eiralox
Can everyone let me know how experienced they are?
I've been playing mafia on and off for years but have about 10 games on site.
In post 77, Crescent wrote:Seems awfully quick to say someone could be playing "frozen".
3 players haven't even posted yet.
hmmm....In post 101, Eiralox wrote:In post 92, Haschel Cedricson wrote:Fascinating. Does this make sense to anybody else?In post 60, Seanzie wrote:I was kind of hoping someone would, yeah. Gotta get the game going somehow, and I read people better when they push me. Since I know no one here, it would have been helpful to see how people reacted to me.In post 57, schadd_ wrote:was somebody supposed to tell you it was scummy? what was your plan in that case
i mean it is fascinating, an interesting study, but can be a town ploy to draw sus. or can be scum ploy to seem like town ploy to draw sus. idk, either way i sure hope Seanzie isn't going to whirlwind into me whenever i hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
This is TvT, I had similar misunderstandings as town and got dogpiled by other townies.In post 55, Seanzie wrote:I've seen wolves "hmm..." posts to make it look like they're thinking hard about something while not actually giving any takes, and they can later use that post to fit pretty much any narrative (i.e. if I was a wolf and later today I push Galron, I could be like "see, I suspected them all the way back here!" vs if I decide to townread them, I could be like "yeah, I thought a lot about them as early as this and decided they look townie!".In post 52, Crescent wrote:What about it is supposed to be suspicious?In post 46, Seanzie wrote:Kinda surprised no one called out my "hmmm..." post as suspicious.
Anyways, VOTE: Galron. This is a non-RVS vote.
This looks like TMI.In post 109, KittyTacky wrote:This is TvT, I had similar misunderstandings as town and got dogpiled by other townies.In post 55, Seanzie wrote:I've seen wolves "hmm..." posts to make it look like they're thinking hard about something while not actually giving any takes, and they can later use that post to fit pretty much any narrative (i.e. if I was a wolf and later today I push Galron, I could be like "see, I suspected them all the way back here!" vs if I decide to townread them, I could be like "yeah, I thought a lot about them as early as this and decided they look townie!".In post 52, Crescent wrote:What about it is supposed to be suspicious?In post 46, Seanzie wrote:Kinda surprised no one called out my "hmmm..." post as suspicious.
Anyways, VOTE: Galron. This is a non-RVS vote.
everything but the reading people better when they push me bit. I can understand most of seanzie's explained thought process from a town pov, but the way he asks questions and explains his bait feels kind of fake, like scum that is too self aware and absorbed in their own playIn post 97, Haschel Cedricson wrote:By the by, while I'm interested in everyone's thoughts re: my last question, I'm particularly interested in a response from redcardinal and hope that it is in her next post.
I disagree that D1 does not have concrete info. Reads don't need flips or mech, granted those things can help.In post 112, redcardinal wrote:honestly though d1 my thought process kind of goes in circles due to lack of concrete info, I'm happy just voting after whoever posts the least which at this point is fancypants, what do you think seanzie?
Why doesn't the "reading people better when they push me" part not make sense?In post 111, redcardinal wrote:everything but the reading people better when they push me bit. I can understand most of seanzie's explained thought process from a town pov, but the way he asks questions and explains his bait feels kind of fake, like scum that is too self aware and absorbed in their own playIn post 97, Haschel Cedricson wrote:By the by, while I'm interested in everyone's thoughts re: my last question, I'm particularly interested in a response from redcardinal and hope that it is in her next post.
Why do you think?In post 113, Seanzie wrote:I disagree that D1 does not have concrete info. Reads don't need flips or mech, granted those things can help.In post 112, redcardinal wrote:honestly though d1 my thought process kind of goes in circles due to lack of concrete info, I'm happy just voting after whoever posts the least which at this point is fancypants, what do you think seanzie?
I am not at this time interested in going after Fancypants. Why is this targeted at me specifically?
I don't understand why you would read people better when they push you as opposed to when they push someone elseIn post 114, Seanzie wrote:Why doesn't the "reading people better when they push me" part not make sense?In post 111, redcardinal wrote:everything but the reading people better when they push me bit. I can understand most of seanzie's explained thought process from a town pov, but the way he asks questions and explains his bait feels kind of fake, like scum that is too self aware and absorbed in their own playIn post 97, Haschel Cedricson wrote:By the by, while I'm interested in everyone's thoughts re: my last question, I'm particularly interested in a response from redcardinal and hope that it is in her next post.
I'd like to hear it from you.In post 115, redcardinal wrote:Why do you think?In post 113, Seanzie wrote:I disagree that D1 does not have concrete info. Reads don't need flips or mech, granted those things can help.In post 112, redcardinal wrote:honestly though d1 my thought process kind of goes in circles due to lack of concrete info, I'm happy just voting after whoever posts the least which at this point is fancypants, what do you think seanzie?
I am not at this time interested in going after Fancypants. Why is this targeted at me specifically?
Well, I didn't really say the "as opposed" part. It is more like "as opposed to if they townlock me". I've been bamboozled more by buddying than I have been pushed for a misyeet (well... successfully pushed for a misyeet). Having someone push me makes me feel things, and those feelings tend to lead to good reads. To be honest, I usually OMGUS at first, but then after I see how the person adjusts their push, I tend to get a reasonable read on them.In post 116, redcardinal wrote:I don't understand why you would read people better when they push you as opposed to when they push someone elseIn post 114, Seanzie wrote:Why doesn't the "reading people better when they push me" part not make sense?In post 111, redcardinal wrote:everything but the reading people better when they push me bit. I can understand most of seanzie's explained thought process from a town pov, but the way he asks questions and explains his bait feels kind of fake, like scum that is too self aware and absorbed in their own playIn post 97, Haschel Cedricson wrote:By the by, while I'm interested in everyone's thoughts re: my last question, I'm particularly interested in a response from redcardinal and hope that it is in her next post.
what do you think of Galron?In post 112, redcardinal wrote:honestly though d1 my thought process kind of goes in circles due to lack of concrete info, I'm happy just voting after whoever posts the least which at this point is fancypants, what do you think seanzie?
first pick right now for scum. worse to actually post and say nothing than even to not post, was wondering if seanzie would pick up on that. might just read some of his games and see if he's always this deep in his own head or if he does this as scum to obfuscateIn post 119, Gamma Emerald wrote:what do you think of Galron?In post 112, redcardinal wrote:honestly though d1 my thought process kind of goes in circles due to lack of concrete info, I'm happy just voting after whoever posts the least which at this point is fancypants, what do you think seanzie?
Eh, this is not a good way to read someone IMO. It is barely 24 hours into the game and there are tons of NAI reasons someone could have only posted once by now. Smells more like feeling out LHF tbh.In post 120, redcardinal wrote:first pick right now for scum. worse to actually post and say nothing than even to not post, was wondering if seanzie would pick up on that. might just read some of his games and see if he's always this deep in his own head or if he does this as scum to obfuscateIn post 119, Gamma Emerald wrote:what do you think of Galron?In post 112, redcardinal wrote:honestly though d1 my thought process kind of goes in circles due to lack of concrete info, I'm happy just voting after whoever posts the least which at this point is fancypants, what do you think seanzie?
