There have been two eliminations so far, and we can make a few assumptions about what the scumteam wanted:
1) In general, the Galron elimination was not what they wanted;
2) In general, the Eiralox elimination was what they wanted.
Obviously bussing/"deepwolving" exists so this isn't foolproof, but I wouldn't be surprised if the remaining scum had at least one person taking these stances. So I've dived back and looked at how everybody felt about those players as their wagons were happening. Before you ask, the one from Schadd is more detailed and has quotes because that's the one I did first.
redcardinal
GALRON: Third on Galronwagon (although unvotes later and then rejoins later), is suspicious of me and Galron together, is convinced Galron is scum and focuses on finding partners.
EIRALOX: Doesn't start push on Eira but likes it, debates between KT and Eira, continues to actively look for partners.
schadd:
GALRON:Floats the idea that Galron is "town punishing everybody for voting for a low content slot" but doesn't press. Says he thinks Galron is scum, does not vote for him.
EIRALOX: Votes on D2, lots of shade with minor reasoning given at first - "i think there's a lot missing from your reads, especially those on me, which seems like it could be motivated by a desire to leave yourself options based on what i do / favor statements that are argumentatively convenient. i also can't help but notice you simply start to play the game once you're a top wagon and the competing one claimed pr"
Schadd wrote:there's two things about casing eiralox for me here. the first is that i'm just a person trying to make deductions here and i have an unavoidably huge chance of being wrong regardless of how convinced i am (which i kind of am). this means that i have to confront this chance that i somehow convince people to go with eiralox today, it turns out that they've been doing all this stuff while town, and then i have to play maybe the most grueling d3 of my life, in which everything i write here becomes fuel for not only the obvious eager wolves but also townies that wanna let the outcome of the game be someone else's fault. that day almost surely ends in me getting executed but i still have a responsibility to play it out, which i will hate doing so much its unreal
Foreshadowing on purpose? Later starts to tie Eiralox to Galron.
Seanzie
GALRON: Starts things off with RVS vote, later puts Galron at L-1, believes claim, characterizes Galron's play as more null than town, puts Galron at L-1 again.
EIRALOX: Doesn't mention much on D2 until Klick replaces in. Starts pressuring Eira in response to Eira's statements about him, supports Schaddwagon but thinks one of KT/Eiralox needs to go, pushes to end day because the town is going in circles.
Enchant
GALRON: No mention at all.
EIRALOX: Sees as town, tries to shift wagon to me albeit half-heartedly. Finally hammers after peer pressure from other players.
Malakittens
GALRON: Early vote, no reasoning. Galron makes single post saying Mala and Kitty aren't being objective.
EIRALOX: Hardly any mentions at all.
KittyTacky
GALRON: Sheeps Mala, suggests RC is chainsaw defending Galron, never lets up.
EIRALOX: Does not mention on Day 1. Votes/Unvotes due to trolly reads list from Eira. Suddenly starts casting suspicion of Eira, no details.
Kirigiri/Klick
GALRON: Actively tries to derail Galronwagon.
EIRALOX: "Doesn't have a problem with" Eiralox wagon but wants to wait to commit. Lists Eira at the very top of his Null rankings. Says RC is scum but doesn't lay out a case until the next day.
T3
GALRON: Early suspicion, ties Galron to KT as possible S/S pair, has opportunity to slow down Galron wagon and does not take it. Hammers after meta dive.
EIRALOX: Early TR, applies vote/pressure to Eira after the latter refuses to answer questions, turns around into thinking Eira is town after Eiralox starts posting longer posts. Reverses with second vote after Eira seems to be expressing fake emotion re: schadd
It's harder to draw conclusions based on the Eira elimination because by definition a lot of townies also wanted the same thing as the Mafia, but in general I would summarize things as follows:
Did not want the Galron elimination, or tried to remove pressure from it:
Kirigiri/Klick
Enchant
Seanzie
Schadd (sort of)
Actively wanted the Eiralox elimination:
Schadd
KittyTacky
redcardinal
T3
Passively wanted the Eiralox elimination:
Seanzie
Klick
Based on this Schadd/Seanzie/Klick don't come off as great in regards to their positions on both eliminations.
I can definitely get behind a Klick elimination here. However, there is also one possibility that I didn't notice until I went back and reread all of this: What about a KT/Schadd pairing? This would require KT bussing Galron but otherwise fits. Nobody ever bothered to ask this for some reason and it's kind of too late now, but
why did KT roleblock Schadd
? Redcardinal was KT's big pick for Galron's partner; he accused her of chainsaw defending Galron. Why not block her? In a KT/Schadd pair KittyTacky can easily claim that he blocked Schadd knowing that Schadd won't contradict him. The two of them don't have a lot of direct interactions in either direction on Day 1; Schadd seems like a weird choice of target for a town roleblock.
