Newbie 2100 | Town wins

[KittyTacky]

I forgor about this game, will catch up and respond tomorrow morning.

I forgot to mention about Kitty, and it was another reason to vote him, that this first post on D2 in which he says he "forgot" about the game, looks to me like an excuse in advance so he can prove that he didn't do anything in the game during the night phase. But if he really forgot it, why bothering mentioning this instead of just catching up (supposing he was not fully caught up at that moment, which I don't see why, because it's not like a lot happened since his last post)?

1. This feels like you're trying to push me for being LHF and then retroactively making up a reason.
2. Why wouldn't I mention it?

Scummy as balls. VOTE: NJAC

You admit to being LHF, so what, in your mind makes you think his push is scummy? You do make a lot of excuses. I can see what he's saying. Is NJAC your only scum read?

The tone feels opportunistic is what I dislike about it. And yes.

[KittyTacky]

2) I'm not convinced that Kitty's only suspect during the whole D1 was Calum/T3 slot, and he didn't even considered that Calum was just a newbie who wasn't sure how to play and handle the suspicions on him. Also Kitty didn't seem interested in solving the game.

@

Kitty

you commented about my 412, but can you please also comment about my 404, specifically what I quoted above?

I missed it.
1. I don't like splitting my attention.
2. It felt more like scum than a newbie town.
3. I am interested in solving, I push people who I think are scumbags.

[Greeting]

Also, my townread on Greeting eroded pretty heavily upon a closer look.

Why?

[Greeting]

Greeting is manipulative from first post in game, i don't really see how Greeting can be town.

Please elaborate

I just feel Greeting!Town doesh't post "Hello newbies if you are green we are in same team".

So you think that 8 is definitive LAMIST that points to scum me? We really are having another rendition of "I found scum in just one post". It's a shame that you really didn't. The truth is that I am just being nice, because this is a Newbie game, and I care about player retention on MafiaScum.

And what about your contributions to the game? I mean, this case is literally the only thing you've been doing so far. What about your reads of other players?

KittyTacky

?

Salsabil Faria

?

Wayward Son

?

[Greeting]

@ Greeting Happy Cake Day!

Good night.

Thank you! Both the 28th and the 29th are cake day for me. First one is anniversary of joining the site (first anniversary!), second one is my actual birthday.

[Greeting]

Thanks for the welcome.

And, fair enough, I think I understand your reasons. Just a couple of questions more about this:

1) Did you consider that T3 was a good replacement and beneficial to the game, given that he was being active and seemed to be putting some work to solve the game? Did you consider that he was also still a newbie?

2) Why did you say you were tired of D1 and kind of wanted to end it soon, when there were replacements taking place, and considering that the deadline was frozen it could be beneficial to have more input from the replaced in players, before taking a final decision?

Day 1 felt like it lasted two weeks because of the constant replacements, which is four days longer than it should. At that very moment I felt like we had enough information to end the day with a

T3

elimination. It is a real shame that he got tunnelled on me over one post (23) and it probably clouded his judgement of this game very strongly.

[Greeting]

Current thoughts: Most likely one of my townreads is terribly wrong.

Both

Salsabil Faria

and

KittyTacky

deserve more scrutiny. Statistically speaking, usually, one of the mafia slots is an SE player and one is a Newbie. I guess I would definitely redirect my effort to analysing these two very closely today.

Salsabil

will go first as they have jumped off the

T3

wagon when it gained traction. I've found it suspicious at the time and I'm finding it suspicious now, because there was enough justification for a Calum/

T3

elimination and yet they left at the very last minute. Almost as if they wanted to try to avoid looking bad for miseliminating someone they knew was town.

[NJAC]

Greeting
Wayward
Salsa
Moonshot
Kitty/Enchant

But still evaluating my reads...

[lendunistus]

Newbie 2100 Votecount - 2.2

- Cory (on mafiauniverse.com)

Votecount

Greeting (1):

Salsabil Faria

KittyTacky (1):

NJAC

NJAC (1):

KittyTacky

Not Voting (4):

Moonshot, Wayward Son, Enchant, Greeting

4 votes are required for majority.

Deadline:

(expired on 2022-09-02 15:00:00)

Vote History

Post #381: Salsabil Faria votes Greeting
Post #385: NJAC votes KittyTacky
Post #416: KittyTacky votes NJAC

[NJAC]

We should start forming a serious wagon, right? Those not voting should vote.

[KittyTacky]

Also, my townread on Greeting eroded pretty heavily upon a closer look.

Why?

I don't like the way you turned on T3 in spite of townreading Calum.

[Wayward Son]

@ Kitty I urge you to do an ISO of Greeting and T3 together. Please point out any posts where you feel Greeting is turning on T3 in a scummy way. If you're Town, then maybe you're seeing something I don't.

[Wayward Son]

We should start forming a serious wagon, right? Those not voting should vote.

Soon, I haven't decided yet. I still want to hear Enchant's reads. Moonshot's slot is a pretty firm Town read of mine too, and I am really curious on what the slot (whomever it ends up being) thinks.

[Enchant]

What reads?

Greeting+NJAC are mafia team.

GG eazy.
That's it.
All.

Go persuade me otherwise.

[NJAC]

@

Wayward

: your town read on Moonshot is based mainly on 26, or you have seen something else?

[NJAC]

Greeting+NJAC are mafia team.

Please explain your theory, as detailed as you can.

[lendunistus]

Moonshot has been prodded.

[Enchant]

Greeting is maf, you whiteknighting, therefore maf.

[NJAC]

Yeah, very convincing. And why aren't you voting?

[Enchant]

I don't need to vote to talk shit on you.

[NJAC]

But, if you are sure Greeting is scum, shouldn't you vote him?

[Enchant]

We are speeding somewhere?

[NJAC]

We only have less than 4 days left to make a decision. We need to form a wagon, make our biggest suspect claim, and if necessary form a new wagon. Many players are posting once a day or less, so I'm worried we end up short on time and deciding bad.

[Enchant]

VOTE: Greeting

Whatever

[Salsabil Faria]

Statistically speaking, usually,

one of the mafia slots is an SE player and one is a Newbie.

Then why you didn’t eliminate

Kitty

(or going after me) when he contributed nothing important??

Salsabil

will go first as they have jumped off the

T3

wagon when it gained traction. I've found it suspicious at the time and I'm finding it suspicious now, because there was enough justification for a Calum/

T3

elimination and yet they left at the very last minute. Almost as if they wanted to try to avoid looking bad for miseliminating someone they knew was town.

So, from your

SE theory

, I'm scum because...

1.

One of the SE has to be a scum.

2.

Scum!me didn’t want to look bad that's why jumped off from

T3

after making a scum case on him which YOU AGREED with me. (I literally gave

T3

on a platter to you... smh )

3.

And of course, town!me shouldn’t give pause/re-evaluate on any read, specially when we had time and a replacement happening.

Hmm.... almost flattering that you're up for my a** since RVS, trying to find ANYTHING to make me look bad Though I'm impressed by your pocketing attempt [FYI, one of them should be the scum partner].

Btw, I believe we can win by this: {

Greeting > Wayward/NJAC

}