Gnosia Game over!

[shiki]

for roden it is like,

want to check if you were in radio buzz when i talked to galron about like my views on people facilitating communication at some length

but even if so probably unfair of me to not view as +town as i usually do even if you were aware

(you were but eh)

think the thoughts on autere's complaining / enchant's helpfulness felt somewhat towny

[shiki]

can't really even try to connect throughline of jessica rabbit's other than 'claims bad' which comes back around later so could very well be a held belief

haven't really noted anything else one way or the other

looking at now could be like, overly focused on small things and mech stuff rather than like, finding mafia

kinda feel like i am doing exactly that when looking at iso too

[shiki]

i dunno if like

the feeling that elmo is timetraveling is greatly lessened by elmo being aware and apologizing for jumping around the thread,

still don't really follow elmo's fakegod read,

[shiki]

kinda inclined to believe that klick's seemingly not knowing there wasn't daytalk is plus town as well,

don't really follow most of the reads but we approach game very differently

[shiki]

already posted most of my thoughts with regards to ranger

if you squint and really try to connect each readslist to the one before it as well as to the posts you think ranger is looking at between them it feels like

consistent as far as i can tell and applicable

at the very least ranger is going through the process of carefully reviewing them and that would be A Lot for mafia to be doing

seems more likely to me to come from town or traitor or bug who doesn't know the solution

giving a wait and see to 'voice and a vote' now - don't really have enough information to attempt to reach any sort of conclusion with regards to ranger's further explanation of this

[shiki]

freedom's questions with regards to abilities still seem odd to me but recent posts have felt okay even if possibly prompted by scoliosis's 'real thoughts' post

want to note scoliosis's dismissiveness towards freedom when compared to other interactions

[shiki]

guess i would also like fakegod's answer to the question i asked enchant, though slightly modified,

would you use ability again right now if you had another shot?

most of fakegod's thoughts are with regards to mech so i guess i can see how fakegod would reach conclusion that disagreeing about how to procede would be mafia indicative

maybe

if one of them dies during the night we know they're both town cuz scum doesn't want to get rid of that kind of wifom.

What is this logic??

lol forgot this happened

'claim and counterclaim are both town if one of them dies during the night' is a pretty funny take

[shiki]

junkochan has felt very town to me and thus my inclination to ask her thoughts on things i was having trouble weighing,

dunno if i can put a lot of words to this but i am often looking for like

a pillar or whatever and junkochan was my most confident town

[shiki]

'claim and counterclaim are both town if one of them dies during the night' is a pretty funny take

though i also thought there was a decent chance both were town and maybe even more so now

[shiki]

enchant obviously excited by the format here and thus the preplanned counterclaim and such,

post following reveal of not the engineer about preventing counterclaims seemed good and logical

though rescinding of claim coming shortly after fakegod use of ability and me asking about a second shot makes me a little uneasy

as if traitor and fakegod truthful enchant could still get found out potentially

but also traitor still a miss and i don't currently think traitor more likely than town anyway

and rescinding could very simply have been because didn't want the guardian angel to not know who to save based on later enchant comments, which would be some of the benefit of a mafia counterclaim anyway which enchant worked to prevent, so!

since not known 15 had already claimed et cetera

[shiki]

for marashu most of my thoughts are above other than like,

recent interactions could be angled towards me

but i have posted a lot and it's a very small sample size, so

oh the lie detector thing! was reminded of this when looking at autere's iso

still think this was oddly preemptive of marashu and the wording maybe questionable, (think enchant also used town wording when replying to not known 15's state your human)

((also also probably should have been compiling notes for myself to not potentially forget things such as this but eh feel like this has often led to me losing myself in a rabbithole))

[shiki]

still have that tingly feeling with regards to autere talking about tracking fos votes and then someone using an ability that made day 1 an actual vote

I'm not asking you all to be brain surgeons but I really am fucking perplexed that the front of discussion has been what it is. The start of this game was NK15 claiming engineer in the most hackneyed way by intentionally misspelling his apparent ability, which he then (unprompted) claims Engineer of all fucking things. This causes Enchant to CC, and my initial thought is that 'ok, so Enchant is likely real because he didn't want to out like a sensible person' but ho ho ho I thought it was supposed to be December but you could've fooled me that it was April with how much fucking jokes have been played. Excuse me for being skeptical about FakeGod's ability when we've already seen what's happened prior. So what else is going on? Meandering discussion that amounts to nothing but setup analysis and flavor wank that is

tonally daft and boring

it's like I'm being educated about Gnosia and if I wanted to do that I would've played the fucking game. Please for the love of god can we get some nuance in here. The thread is bone-dry with surface level takes it makes me want to participate with a coma than this shitshow.

and i don't really like

understand why this post exists? / feels like,

like isn't the solution simply to interact with posts that aren't 'educating you about gnosia' and to interact with those who are about other things,

i guess i feel like,

like,

like there was not a dearth of posts outside of this umbrella autere could have easily posted about instead

same as with the vote counting thing like instead of doing so stated that it should be done, instead of doing so with regards to content not about source material stated that others should provide it,

and i don't know if being so seemingly upset with that tracks

Call me nostradamus but I predict NK15 will retract as well. I'm not very happy about this but I'm biting my tongue for the sanctity of the thread

though i thought this numerous times

and i don't really have any basis from which to judge if being so upset about something like this instead of doing something about it is actually alignment indicative

so guess i would like others' thoughts on this

[shiki]

going to function as if not known 15 is the engineer

like even if i wouldn't put my belief in this at 100% seems like only reasonable worldview to work from right now

[shiki]

going to function as if not known 15 is the engineer

like even if i wouldn't put my belief in this at 100% seems like only reasonable worldview to work from right now

though i think the cynicism from autere / narrow parking pretty fair based on past experience yeah

[shiki]

if i were engineer i wouldn't claim here. i doubt we'll reach end of phase without one of them walking back their claim. if one of them dies during the night w/o that happening we know they're both town cuz scum doesn't want to get rid of that kind of wifom.

ill wait for the dramatic reveal to decide if i want one of them froze

how did you decide

that you want enchant froze?

[narrow parking]

i feel like i articulated my point pretty clearly

[shiki]

if i were engineer i wouldn't claim here. i doubt we'll reach end of phase without one of them walking back their claim. if one of them dies during the night w/o that happening we know they're both town cuz scum doesn't want to get rid of that kind of wifom.

ill wait for the dramatic reveal to decide if i want one of them froze

how did you decide

that you want enchant froze?

mmmmmmmmm

yeah this mostly right you say someone is going to walk it back both are quite possibly town et cetera

but then when enchant walks it back you vote and are now saying you're unlikely to vote elsewhere

so how did you get from a to b i guess i am asking

like was it a ploy to get a mafia to rescind their claim

and if so why do you think a mafia would do so at the time that enchant did?

and if not, i guess what is the reasoning otherwise,

[shiki]

i feel like i articulated my point pretty clearly

could you rearticulate it for me please,

[shiki]

i feel like i articulated my point pretty clearly

could you rearticulate it for me please,

like it's quite possible i am misunderstanding

but it feels to me like you were saying,

someone is going to walk back their claim, and at that point you will decide if you want one of them froze

so i guess i am wondering how you made that decision with such certainly at the point that enchant walked it back

like what about it makes you certain that it doesn't come from town

[shiki]

idk blurry eyed me feeling like this could be distancing if i squint and tilt my head

but it's almost certainly super unfair of me to be like, well sure narrow parking might be right about this could see mafia!enchant carrying through with this plan even though it was very very well executed if so, but if narrow parking is right then narrow parking might be mafia also!

like yeah super super unfair so i guess more just wondering the answers to my previous posts yeah

[FakeGod]

VOTE: Marashu

[Freedom]

VOTE: Marashu

Can you explain this?
From my understanding, you disagreed with them on wanting to out the Coroner.
But Roden seemed to support that notion too.

[FakeGod]

I would like to hear what he has to say.

[Freedom]

I see.
I could actually see Town coming up with that strategy if they had feared that scum would fakeclaim it later.
Though, it is possible that scum wants more targets to choose from.

[Jessica Rabbit]

still have that tingly feeling with regards to autere talking about tracking fos votes and then someone using an ability that made day 1 an actual vote

I'm not asking you all to be brain surgeons but I really am fucking perplexed that the front of discussion has been what it is. The start of this game was NK15 claiming engineer in the most hackneyed way by intentionally misspelling his apparent ability, which he then (unprompted) claims Engineer of all fucking things. This causes Enchant to CC, and my initial thought is that 'ok, so Enchant is likely real because he didn't want to out like a sensible person' but ho ho ho I thought it was supposed to be December but you could've fooled me that it was April with how much fucking jokes have been played. Excuse me for being skeptical about FakeGod's ability when we've already seen what's happened prior. So what else is going on? Meandering discussion that amounts to nothing but setup analysis and flavor wank that is

tonally daft and boring

it's like I'm being educated about Gnosia and if I wanted to do that I would've played the fucking game. Please for the love of god can we get some nuance in here. The thread is bone-dry with surface level takes it makes me want to participate with a coma than this shitshow.

and i don't really like

understand why this post exists? / feels like,

like isn't the solution simply to interact with posts that aren't 'educating you about gnosia' and to interact with those who are about other things,

i guess i feel like,

like,

like there was not a dearth of posts outside of this umbrella autere could have easily posted about instead

same as with the vote counting thing like instead of doing so stated that it should be done, instead of doing so with regards to content not about source material stated that others should provide it,

and i don't know if being so seemingly upset with that tracks

Call me nostradamus but I predict NK15 will retract as well. I'm not very happy about this but I'm biting my tongue for the sanctity of the thread

though i thought this numerous times

and i don't really have any basis from which to judge if being so upset about something like this instead of doing something about it is actually alignment indicative

so guess i would like others' thoughts on this

Ranger, could you explain why you have Autere so high in your reads?