Newbie 2107 | Random Music | Postgame

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Brickwall, does 88 not show that I/CCGeek cannot be scum together? Surely he just posts that in the scum PT???

As Red has said, scum dying Day One is a massive blow to their chances of winning. I do understand however that it looks like I tried to produce a counter-wagon to CCGeek and for that I don't really have a counter argument. All I can say is that I had absolutely no need to put CCGeek to E-1 when I did.

[Brickwalll]

Yeah, makes sense Post 393. I must be honest it is a bit strange but his double vote for Chazary also confuses me a little about BBT. I do currently the CCG vote as cover play knowing the wagon was already forming and the likelihood of a hammer dropping before a claim was slim (giving him ample opportunity to get off the wagon but look townie).

I don't necessarily agree with E-1 right now. What is the benefit for town. Even if we are right and Chazary is scum, why the need to rush? If we take D2 the full 7 real life days we as townie are giving ourself a better opportunity to win. We are in such a good position, why rush. Even noob town can drop hammers. Not just scum.

[Brickwalll]

Brickwall, does 88 not show that I/CCGeek cannot be scum together? Surely he just posts that in the scum PT???

As Red has said, scum dying Day One is a massive blow to their chances of winning. I do understand however that it looks like I tried to produce a counter-wagon to CCGeek and for that I don't really have a counter argument. All I can say is that I had absolutely no need to put CCGeek to E-1 when I did.

Not quite sure what part of Post 88 you are referring to. It is a long post, think you need to be a little more specific to what you mean there.

To be honest, I didn't know scum had a private chat? Can they use it during the day?

[biancospino]

@brick
UNVOTE: Chez
I don't think any townie will hammer so fast, but if you're nervous about it I'll keep them E-2

[Brickwalll]

D2 is unchartered territory for me. I may be wrong in my logic and if so I apologise in advance. I just think we better off using the time we need than rush it.

[biancospino]

Anyway, wrt post 88, the mafia has indeed daytalk. But frankly I'm also puzzled as of where that proof is in that post

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Scum have a private thread that is open at all times

[BlueBloodedToffee]

There is no 'proof' in that post.

What I am saying is that if I were scum with CCGeek, he simply could have posted in the scum thread about Elmo being V/LA and what it meant etc. There would be no need to post it in the game thread.

[Redados]

Scum has a private chat and they can use it during the day and night. CCGeek can’t post in it anymore though after dying.

[Redados]

There is no 'proof' in that post.

What I am saying is that if I were scum with CCGeek, he simply could have posted in the scum thread about Elmo being V/LA and what it meant etc. There would be no need to post it in the game thread.

Could he have been looking for newb cred?

I thought it was sketch that Cactus asked what an SE was in the same post that he used the IIoA acronym

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I don't see how he gets noob cred for asking it?

[Brickwalll]

There is no 'proof' in that post.

What I am saying is that if I were scum with CCGeek, he simply could have posted in the scum thread about Elmo being V/LA and what it meant etc. There would be no need to post it in the game thread.

Conversation starter. Easy way to look active without risking attention on you.

[Brickwalll]

Quite frankly I don't think post 88 gives you any credence. If anything, you vaguely pointing me in the direction of post 88 as your defence is somewhat concerning.

[biancospino]

@BBT Did you mean post #13 instead of #88?

[Redados]

There is no 'proof' in that post.

What I am saying is that if I were scum with CCGeek, he simply could have posted in the scum thread about Elmo being V/LA and what it meant etc. There would be no need to post it in the game thread.

Conversation starter. Easy way to look active without risking attention on you.

Yeah this makes more sense than that I said

[biancospino]

I don't see how he gets noob cred for asking it?

You are saying you should be TR'd for that very reason. If your logic is sound, then if you're scum, that could have been placed as a form of easy garancy in case CCG were to be limmed and flip

[BlueBloodedToffee]

No, I'm saying that interaction makes no sense as a s/s interaction.

I should be town read because my play has been quite obviously pro town.

[Redados]

I should be town read because my play has been quite obviously pro town.

Well I hate that logic

[Redados]

Scum can very easily do something pro-town and town can very easily do something anti-town.

I agree that your play has been Pro-town.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

You're right.

Part of the reason I thought you could be scum was because it felt like you were intentionally playing scummy to fall under the 'too scummy to be scum' bracket.

But I feel like I have been so very obviously town that it really shouldn't even be a question.

[Redados]

Yeah I was not doing anything intentionally. I was really struggling with my day one reads, but I hoped it would be scarier to scum if I was being more mysterious as opposed to that I really didn’t know what I was doing.

I find it much easier to form reads after people have flipped. I need to work on being a better day one player.

[Redados]

put your vote somewhere where it does something

Why chazary though? I'd imagine the idea was to gather a reaction, but now that one was given I'm not so sure keeping the pressure on would really do any good. Are you actually reading him anti-town?

Biancospino when I was reading the game, I saw that I never responded to this post. I apologize as I must have missed it.

[Redados]

You're right.

Part of the reason I thought you could be scum was because it felt like you were intentionally playing scummy to fall under the 'too scummy to be scum' bracket.

But I feel like I have been so very obviously town that it really shouldn't even be a question.

How do you read me right now Mr Toffee?

[Redados]

I think I solved the game but I need to think about it.

[Redados]

I misread a post never mind