Community Redux | Postgame

[DeasVail]

Dease and herta signaling each other maybe

Sadly not but there was some quite clear signaling last game!

This could be a signal actually

VOTE: DeasVail

It turns out I was wrong because I was convinced that you were the traitor

[Frogsterking]

Dease and herta signaling each other maybe

Sadly not but there was some quite clear signaling last game!

This could be a signal actually

VOTE: DeasVail

It turns out I was wrong because I was convinced that you were the traitor

Did you alter your scum playstyle consciously in the first iteration of Community?

Dease and herta signaling each other maybe

Sadly not but there was some quite clear signaling last game!

This could be a signal actually

VOTE: DeasVail

Good catch.

Frog if u don't see how "You think ur posts r nai but someone townread you why didn't u engage" is a weak implication at best

I'm getting "frustrated scum who was called out for reasons they know are dog shit" intuition pings from you.

Nah, "good vibes" doesn't cut it. Why meuh and mt specifically you pick out to townread? Give a more realistic sounding excuse please.

They seemed solvy. It was page 3, don't expect me, or anyone, to have particularly deep reads.

I think you sound way too defeated here already.

Thank you. Just need Flavia to clarify and then I'll make an announcement.

That's cool, I have 1 mediocre and 1 excellent scum read I'm sitting on.

Pedit: Haven't gotten scumpings yet, tbh. I tried taking another look through people's posts when Nancy asked for reads; the only thing that really stuck out to me as meh is Herta's lack of anything of relevance to the game in any of their posts. I guess that's something.

I'm starting to get concerned now because I was about to townlock you but I can't tell if you have a pro town agenda for not outing your scum reads. If I can't townread you then I'm pretty much back to square 0 as far as my reads go. If I can townread you so much to start a townblock with you, then I think the Nonexistent Hydra is most likely to be scum because I don't like how they came after you.

My problems are mainly just that I'm surprised you didn't say more about Tweet, they drew my attention the most with that long, static post they wrote. Also, KT's townread on you looked a bit muggy, like they're trying to pocket you. Is there any reason you don't have scum pings on KT and Tweet?

KT's mention of Tweet and I wasn't a traitor thing, sorry, I'm town
Also I don't really think NH's push against me was scum indicative. Why do you?

Also why did you expect me to have reacted to those posts from KT? My most recent post at the time predated KT's townread on me, was I meant to read the future?

At first when reading Tweet's 60 I felt like she could be town for it, but ultimately I feel like townreading someone for some (albeit good) mechspec is a bad call. Especially since Tweet could've just read the previous setup and parroted her thoughts on it from before the game started (which wouldn't be AI at all, then).

Hardclaim ninja blasphemer.

VOTE: deas

Also I know this is a joke but it's been bugging me because I don't know, what's a blasphemer?

Every time someone posts a swear I get a dayvig.

I figure the game will be over by Friday.

Fuck shit fuck

@Herta

shoot the people voting for me

What were you thinking here, Meuh?

I was trying to be funny,

N.Y. M replaces Nonexistent Hydra.

Welp. that was fun

UNVOTE:

~Still Nancy

Why the unvote here?

UNVOTE: meuh

Meuh I'm going to be real with you: I want to believe you're town but there are a few things you have to answer for before I can be comfortable with you.

Preliminary tweet town read.

Why did you post this Herta? Trying to communicate something to tweet?

Haven't gotten scumpings yet, tbh. I tried taking another look through people's posts when Nancy asked for reads; the only thing that really stuck out to me as meh is Herta's lack of anything of relevance to the game in any of their posts. I guess that's something.

Herta? I think you missed this? Are you not reading Meuh's posts?

Yes I'm communicating an early town read

No I did not miss that post and why would you think that?

Is it possible for you to solve without being confrontational or is this just scum you? I think it could go either way with you.

Hey can you do something besides whine about getting called out for your dog shit posts? Like, post anything that doesn't make me want to throw up in my mouth when I read it? What gave you the idea to "preliminary town read" MT based off a mech post?

[Frogsterking]

What gave you the idea to "preliminary town read" MT? Was it only based off their mech post?

EBWOP @ herta. I'm sorry I said your posts are dogshit, that was way too harsh and not accurate of what I actually think. I think your posts are consistently null or scummy and I'm struggling to come up with any reasons to rule you out as a suspect. I don't really believe your posts or play are of sub par quality and I'm sorry that I wrote what I did in #126.

[Titus]

Ok, since Flavia cleared up as best they're comfortable with, I'll make my announcement. The mod said there was a role that checked opposite of their alignment and that's it. So I'm assuming Flavia is a miller. If Flavia is not a miller, we have a godparent.

[Flavia]

Idk exactly how to describe why I like 49, it just feels right. May be one of those cases when someone makes a post that's NAI but I just find it funny/enjoyable so I TR them for it. If so I don't mind because either way a smile was brought to my face, heehee

They are funny but I think totally NAI. Was funny and relaxed last game...and was third party. But the penguin gifs were sort of cute.

Yeah, checked. 100% Miller.

[Meuh]

That's a nice bit of info to have! Yeah, I played with Penguin once before and I recall him being similar.
Do you have a read on anyone yet? Would be nice to hear.

Also

@Frog

if you have anything to ask in order to sort me better, feel free! Might not have much more to add without the game developing a bit more first, though.

[PenguinPower]

They are funny but I think totally NAI.

Correct!

[Bell]

I'm confused why they weren't comfortable with it in the first place.

[N.Y. M]

Ok, since Flavia cleared up as best they're comfortable with, I'll make my announcement. The mod said there was a role that checked opposite of their alignment and that's it. So I'm assuming Flavia is a miller. If Flavia is not a miller, we have a godparent.

Could they possibly be a hated miller?

I’m also upset that I’m not what I was last time

Players

Resident - N.Y. M

Resident - JohnnyFarrar

Pensioner - Bell

Pensioner - Andresvmb

Attendant - The Bombay (Lukewarm and marcistar)

Proponent - Star Power/Roden

Clerk - Frogsterking/Morning Tweet

Publican - furtiveglance

Speculator - Flavia/Scarfsmanship

Consul - DeasVail

Opponent - Kokabiel

Collaborator - Herta

Collaborator - Passenger

Chancellor - PenguinPower

Dease and herta signaling each other maybe

Sadly not but there was some quite clear signaling last game!

This could be a signal actually

VOTE: DeasVail

It turns out I was wrong because I was convinced that you were the traitor

@Meuh, I liked your later posts. Any reads @Deas?

~Nancy

[DeasVail]

@Meuh, I liked your later posts. Any reads @Deas?

Not at the moment.

I also haven't read the game properly.

V/LA for the next 36 hours

[Morning Tweet]

Frog if u don't see how "You think ur posts r nai but someone townread you why didn't u engage" is a weak implication at best

I'm getting "frustrated scum who was called out for reasons they know are dog shit" intuition pings from you.

Understandable, not far from the truth too

What gave you the idea to "preliminary town read" MT? Was it only based off their mech post?

EBWOP @ herta. I'm sorry I said your posts are dogshit, that was way too harsh and not accurate of what I actually think. I think your posts are consistently null or scummy and I'm struggling to come up with any reasons to rule you out as a suspect. I don't really believe your posts or play are of sub par quality and I'm sorry that I wrote what I did in #126.

Herta: Makes 1 TR without reasoning on page 3

Frog:

[Morning Tweet]

2 miller-likes claimed so far, both in their first posts. i cant rlly think of anyway to setup spec this, there weren't any negative town utilities last game from what i can tell

Ok, since Flavia cleared up as best they're comfortable with, I'll make my announcement. The mod said there was a role that checked opposite of their alignment and that's it. So I'm assuming Flavia is a miller. If Flavia is not a miller, we have a godparent.

Mhm okay

When you say you r page 1 wasn't fanatastic, what is it that you mean by that?

This is my first time playing as myself in opening pages in a while (played an anonymous game recently but that felt different). I am struggling, I'm just not scum for it. 13 was disingenous because I made it from a want to post more than having something to say, and that's a way that struggle showed. That's partially why Frog's read on me is something I felt satisfied with despite yknow, its wrongness.

i like meuh's reaction to being voted by nym and my questioning

VOTE: Bell

[furtiveglance]

2 miller-likes claimed so far, both in their first posts. i cant rlly think of anyway to setup spec this, there weren't any negative town utilities last game from what i can tell

Ok, since Flavia cleared up as best they're comfortable with, I'll make my announcement. The mod said there was a role that checked opposite of their alignment and that's it. So I'm assuming Flavia is a miller. If Flavia is not a miller, we have a godparent.

Mhm okay

When you say you r page 1 wasn't fanatastic, what is it that you mean by that?

This is my first time playing as myself in opening pages in a while (played an anonymous game recently but that felt different). I am struggling, I'm just not scum for it. 13 was disingenous because I made it from a want to post more than having something to say, and that's a way that struggle showed. That's partially why Frog's read on me is something I felt satisfied with despite yknow, its wrongness.

i like meuh's reaction to being voted by nym and my questioning

VOTE: Bell

I was a Miller last time, but I also had a roleblocking component to my role.

[furtiveglance]

Do we know if RH has changed the setup? Have we had any public information about that?

[Meuh]

@Furtive
viewtopic.php?p=13561728#p13561728

[Titus]

Could they possibly be a hated miller?

Yes. My role pm was vague. They could be a scum miller, a miller innocent child or anything else

[Titus]

2 miller-likes

Two?

[Bell]

Merry x-mas eve.

[DeasVail]

Did you alter your scum playstyle consciously in the first iteration of Community?

My scum playstyle will always be carried out consciously, in such a way that I think will look town to other players

[DeasVail]

My tentative townreads are NYM, Herta, Tweet, Flavia, Frogster, Titus, Meuh

Meuh is the read I've put the most thought into so far, because my initial impression that her posts were "trying too hard" in a scummy sort of way, but I've since changed my mind on that, and I think the more likely explanation is that Meuh is town.

NYM's progression on Meuh matched my own and the casual conversational pop-ins without seeming to be trying too hard to have READS has the sort of relaxed town vibe.

Herta's looseness feels different from last game, where they felt more stilted. 23 feels particularly carefree, where scum might worry that they may garner suspicion for looking like a tractor.

Tweet is not avoiding the game, which is generally positive.

Flavia is probably a miller, and the weirdness of the approach to the initial claim felt less thought through than I would expect from scum.

Frogster's focus on trying to find traitors signalling to each other seems like something that town-Frogster would focus on.

Titus feels like she is sinking her teeth into trying to work out what is going on in the game.

[DeasVail]

VOTE: Bell

[N.Y. M]

Wasn't Yume just banned.
Does time fly faster when I don't stare at it

This is kind of giving me Turing Test vibes.

VOTE: Bell

I liked that post from Deas but not sure I agree on Herta but Bell isn’t solving, so probably good vote.

~Nancy

[N.Y. M]

Wasn't Yume just banned.
Does time fly faster when I don't stare at it

This is kind of giving me Turing Test vibes.

VOTE: Bell

I liked that post from Deas but not sure I agree on Herta but Bell isn’t solving, so probably good vote.

~Nancy

viewtopic.php?f=3&t=90080&user_select%5B%5D=34613

Yep, sounds like Bell probably got a red role pm. I thought he was really obvious town in the og setup.

[Herta]

My tentative townreads are NYM, Herta, Tweet, Flavia, Frogster, Titus, Meuh

Meuh is the read I've put the most thought into so far, because my initial impression that her posts were "trying too hard" in a scummy sort of way, but I've since changed my mind on that, and I think the more likely explanation is that Meuh is town.

NYM's progression on Meuh matched my own and the casual conversational pop-ins without seeming to be trying too hard to have READS has the sort of relaxed town vibe.

Herta's looseness feels different from last game, where they felt more stilted. 23 feels particularly carefree, where scum might worry that they may garner suspicion for looking like a tractor.

Tweet is not avoiding the game, which is generally positive

Flavia is probably a miller, and the weirdness of the approach to the initial claim felt less thought through than I would expect from scum.

Frogster's focus on trying to find traitors signalling to each other seems like something that town-Frogster would focus on.

Titus feels like she is sinking her teeth into trying to work out what is going on in the game.

Not a fan of this poplist.

[Frogsterking]

Did you alter your scum playstyle consciously in the first iteration of Community?

My scum playstyle will always be carried out consciously, in such a way that I think will look town to other players

In hindsight after knowing your role I thought you might have adjusted your posts quite a bit to be more in line with how town was posting. It was subtle and I didn't notice at all in-game but I think it made a big difference in how you were percieved.