i designed this setup in 2019 [game over]

[xyzzy]

votecount 1.09

boxing day?

4 players voting for imaginality (furtiveglance, Ranger, Lycanfire, HighPrincessErinys)
4 players voting for Frogsterking (McMenno, Ythan, KittyTacky, imaginality)
3 players voting for Ranger (Titus, Gamma Emerald, Quiet Owl)
2 players voting for Elements (Save The Dragons, Cat Scratch Fever)
2 players voting for furtiveglance (tris, Elements)
1 player voting for Not_Mafia (Not_Mafia)
1 player voting for Titus (Frogsterking)

6 players not voting (Vaxkiller, tapiocaphobe, kitten around, Enchant, Morning Tweet, GeorgeBailey)

with 23 votes, it takes 12 to eliminate.

mod notes: Vaxkiller and Tapiocaphobe have 24 hours from this vote count to post or be replaced. prodding Morning Tweet and Enchant.

[Elements]

you have reached the bottom of page 27.

Best post of the game so far

[Ythan]

Really fake and unnatural sorting.

Keep crying

[Gamma Emerald]

Do you think there might be loved or hated going round with this many players?

Possibly. Frogsterking still didn't give the tonal read when he suspected I was town supposedly. Frogsterking is scum. Scum with Ranger. I have 75% odds on that.

Idk how much of the game you read when you joined but I think frog feels substantially different this game than he did in the normal you replaced in as scum with frog

Every single time Frog has been town, he has a certain level of frustration he gets with me everytime trying to sort me. He hasn't displayed an ounce of it. Instead, he's adapting his read to the environment on the board. He hasn't displayed it here.

Frog’s entire strategy this game seems to be slinging mud wherever it’s most suitable
He’s vacillated his reads on several slots, and keeps aiming to return to particular targets. If that’s not agenda driven, I don’t know what is.

That's the exact opposite conclusion to the one I've drawn. He's throwing out reads and theories all over the place which is drawing attention to himself. To me that reads as town running through scenarios trying to find if any fit.

I would believe this if he wasn’t continually circling back to the same few central ideas. When my thought process runs wild, it becomes completely erratic.

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: frogsterking
I’m fine to go back here.

[Frogsterking]

Hmm interesting, I'll consider that

Why would you consider that, of all things? How have I not shown frustration lmao?

[Enchant]

You probably don't believe me but i do have readlist!

[Frogsterking]

Do you think there might be loved or hated going round with this many players?

Possibly. Frogsterking still didn't give the tonal read when he suspected I was town supposedly. Frogsterking is scum. Scum with Ranger. I have 75% odds on that.

Idk how much of the game you read when you joined but I think frog feels substantially different this game than he did in the normal you replaced in as scum with frog

Every single time Frog has been town, he has a certain level of frustration he gets with me everytime trying to sort me. He hasn't displayed an ounce of it. Instead, he's adapting his read to the environment on the board. He hasn't displayed it here.

If you actually believe this then I don't think you are understanding the tone in my posting at all. Also, I think that's silly to claim that I'm assuming positions based on the path of least resistance, I don't think anyone except for Ranger agrees that Gamma is scum and in an actual frog!scum titus!mason world then I would avoid your wagon like the plague.

[Frogsterking]

Do you think there might be loved or hated going round with this many players?

Possibly. Frogsterking still didn't give the tonal read when he suspected I was town supposedly. Frogsterking is scum. Scum with Ranger. I have 75% odds on that.

Idk how much of the game you read when you joined but I think frog feels substantially different this game than he did in the normal you replaced in as scum with frog

Every single time Frog has been town, he has a certain level of frustration he gets with me everytime trying to sort me. He hasn't displayed an ounce of it. Instead, he's adapting his read to the environment on the board. He hasn't displayed it here.

If you actually believe this then I don't think you are understanding the tone in my posting at all. Also, I think that's silly to claim that I'm assuming positions based on the path of least resistance, I don't think anyone except for Ranger agrees that Gamma is scum and in an actual frog!scum titus!mason world then I would avoid your wagon like the plague.

[Frogsterking]

You probably don't believe me but i do have readlist!

It's not just you as town and everyone else null is it?

[Frogsterking]

Fuck I wish I remembered to spoiler that quote in my double post.

[Enchant]

You probably don't believe me but i do have readlist!

It's not just you as town and everyone else null is it?

No!

I also have NM as Town!
And everyone else null.

[Elements]

Hmm interesting, I'll consider that

Why would you consider that, of all things? How have I not shown frustration lmao?

Because I'm basing my read on you partly off meta that I know and now new meta has come to light that I was not aware of.
Why would I not consider it...

[Elements]

I guess it's not meta I'm basing it on but comparisons to a previous game

[Frogsterking]

Titus, you aren't really a mason are you?

I am 100% functionally a mason. Neighbor with mod confirmation that my neighbor is town. Yes. That's a mason. Imaginality has the same thing.

Now, after I post my reads list and object to your theory, you just immediately vote me. You

still

[/u] won't say why you townread Ranger despite me asking.

Really fake and unnatural sorting.

Keep crying

All right, that's probably fair. Hope you had a good Christmas!

615 it may be fair but it doesn't make sense as an excuse as they've "engaged" the game this way on all days, not just Christmas.

[Frogsterking]

Hmm interesting, I'll consider that

Why would you consider that, of all things? How have I not shown frustration lmao?

Because I'm basing my read on you partly off meta that I know and now new meta has come to light that I was not aware of.
Why would I not consider it...

Because her argument is that it's in my town meta to become frustrated with her, which is what I've done, but she is arguing that I am scum.

[Titus]

Hmm interesting, I'll consider that

Why would you consider that, of all things? How have I not shown frustration lmao?

Because I'm basing my read on you partly off meta that I know and now new meta has come to light that I was not aware of.
Why would I not consider it...

Because her argument is that it's in my town meta to become frustrated with her, which is what I've done, but she is arguing that I am scum.

Except you haven't consistently with those games. That's my point.

[Titus]

VOTE: Frogsterking

[Titus]

You have
1) put forth a game which isn't true (trying to call people toen blocks that aren't)
2) voted me immediately afterwards, despite arguing my mason claim was real before
3) have an unexplained ranger townread
4) whatever you did that got you wagoned prior to be coming in
5) inconsistent personality tell

[Titus]

*2) immediately after I called you out

[Enchant]

Cool, mason claim d1

[Elements]

Hmm interesting, I'll consider that

Why would you consider that, of all things? How have I not shown frustration lmao?

Because I'm basing my read on you partly off meta that I know and now new meta has come to light that I was not aware of.
Why would I not consider it...

Because her argument is that it's in my town meta to become frustrated with her, which is what I've done, but she is arguing that I am scum.

I don't think you've felt particularly frustrated about Titus

[Titus]

This seems like a really wild take and it is also something I might expect from town Titus maybe. I was wondering if it was a bad look for Chungus and Dragons to be refusing to vote each other in the way that they are.

This is a sample even though we found each other fast that game. Town!Frogster expects "off the wall" takes from my perspective. He still engages even when I FoS him. In fact my off the wall take was based off VCA, which I could have included in my case here.

[Frogsterking]

1) put forth a game which isn't true (trying to call people toen blocks that aren't)
2) voted me immediately afterwards, despite arguing my mason claim was real before

Things you and I both know I would be really unlikely do as scum.

693 just looks like a post I've already seen you write before as scum:

Spoiler:

VOTE: Masquerader Yellow

This is where my suspicions point me currently. I do not trust the way they took Purple's post out of context.

oh I thought this was just gonna be a regular game, huh

UNVOTE: Masquerader Yellow

Green doesn't want to appear aligned with yellow

, and yellow is an intruder; therefore I am deducing that the intruders are green and yellow. Olive was my red herring and teal was red's red herring.

Offer hand: Red

Offer hand: Olive

Offer hand: Blue

Offer hand: Teal

Offer hand: Magenta

Purple's first offer happens to be every player left alive in the game. That would be an odd coinicidence.

Their acceptance might be coordinated. Based on their own admissions

1) Purple did an about face on Olive.
2) Olive originally wanted to pair with red supposedly but changed his mind.
3) Purple wanted hard to identify people to pair with easy to identify people but currently rests on meta knowledge for Olive town.
4) Olive asks Purple to retract invites and Olive accepts 4 minutes later. The rationale is the thought process looked invitee.
5) The awkward you were right I was town.

VOTE: Purple/Olive

I think I want to see this through.

Scum!Titus is Red Masqué in the above quote and I am Purple Masqué who she is voting. Obviously.

[Frogsterking]

1) put forth a game which isn't true (trying to call people toen blocks that aren't)
2) voted me immediately afterwards, despite arguing my mason claim was real before

Things you and I both know I would be really unlikely do as scum.

693 just looks like a post I've already seen you write before as scum:

Spoiler:

VOTE: Masquerader Yellow

This is where my suspicions point me currently. I do not trust the way they took Purple's post out of context.

oh I thought this was just gonna be a regular game, huh

UNVOTE: Masquerader Yellow

Green doesn't want to appear aligned with yellow

, and yellow is an intruder; therefore I am deducing that the intruders are green and yellow. Olive was my red herring and teal was red's red herring.

Offer hand: Red

Offer hand: Olive

Offer hand: Blue

Offer hand: Teal

Offer hand: Magenta

Purple's first offer happens to be every player left alive in the game. That would be an odd coinicidence.

Their acceptance might be coordinated. Based on their own admissions

1) Purple did an about face on Olive.
2) Olive originally wanted to pair with red supposedly but changed his mind.
3) Purple wanted hard to identify people to pair with easy to identify people but currently rests on meta knowledge for Olive town.
4) Olive asks Purple to retract invites and Olive accepts 4 minutes later. The rationale is the thought process looked invitee.
5) The awkward you were right I was town.

VOTE: Purple/Olive

I think I want to see this through.

Scum!Titus is Red Masqué in the above quote and I am Purple Masqué who she is voting. Obviously.