Newbie 2107 | Random Music | Postgame

[Redados]

I would be happy to explain it further - ask more questions, look at the setup options, and poke at it.

[Baron Kirkholm Uttgart]

But surely that’s word against word

[biancospino]

If someone counterclaims, the scum is between two slots (the claimer and the counterclaimer), and so town win. So any town slot that can cc would do so, and nobody did

[Brickwalll]

So, now that the ball is firmly rolling, some initial observations after a first read through.

Baron voting himself whether to test the voting function or not seems a bit off. Not saying anything conclusive from it but just a note. I also feel Baron's posts are lacking on content to some degree. Offered nothing of value and just fluff posting.

Bianco making a lot of alignment calls early in which is interesting. Don't necessarily agree with the alignments either, a bit too soon to make any calls.

Redados would appear to be pushing the game forward which gives me town vibes for now. Actively asking players to participate and get involved.

HyruleHitman is null for me presently. I like his post 45 where he references Redados and thread control. Don't necessarily agree with that particular argument in this case but feel like his intent is good for now. Can't say I loved the "break a few eggs to make an omelette" comment. Will comment on this one specifically.

Elmo following the thread but yet to post is interesting. Nothing much to comment on otherwise.

**Question: you all seem like experts quoting posts, what is the best way to use the quote function/multi-quote in a post, please?

Brickwall do you remember why you didn't give a read or comment on CCGeek here?

Yeah, I was quite late to pick up the game in the sense that I said hello, went to bed and woke up and we were already 62 posts deep. So I caught up those first 62 posts and summarised, which is this post. At this point CCG had posted a couple of times, but I remember thinking for the most part it was fluff. His two content posts were post 27 and post 31, which even then I thought were a bit light on content. That was halfway through my catchup so suspect it got clouded out by the 31 posts after that which I would have read.

[Brickwalll]

And then from post 178 I start building my case on CCGeek

[Baron Kirkholm Uttgart]

If someone counterclaims, the scum is between two slots (the claimer and the counterclaimer), and so town win. So any town slot that can cc would do so, and nobody did

Ok I get that- thanks!

[Brickwalll]

so what are your thoughts now Baron? Do you agree that Wayward and Red are town and scum must be amongst you, Baron, Bianco, Hellhound and myself?

If so, who are your top 3 scum picks out of the remaining 4 (obvs you aren't going to say yourself)

[Wayward Son]

I've been doing ISO's instead of keeping up with the Main thread. I know we're short on time, so I was hurrying.

I think BBT fits pretty well as scum, especially considering the Cop block.

Baron would be my next best slot, CCG put some initial pressure on Baron (it was pretty weak) 31 88. In 294 CCG gives Baron a Town lean (twice) for making a reads list.

Also @bianco I simply wanted Baron to get into the game faster. No other reason for me to not shift my vote. Also, the slim possibility that someone decides to start pushing Baron midday exists, which would lead to inciting discussion. So yes, that's all I have to say to defend not jumping on the HH wagon.

This is his last real reference to Baron, so I

could

see it as throwing a little early suspicion on a partner, then easing up on it the first chance they got.

I've ISOed everyone else and I'm leaning Town there.

I'm definitely Doctoring Red Tonight if we end up there.

[Wayward Son]

@ Baron I enjoyed your scum-o-meters.

[Baron Kirkholm Uttgart]

so what are your thoughts now Baron? Do you agree that Wayward and Red are town and scum must be amongst you, Baron, Bianco, Hellhound and myself?

If so, who are your top 3 scum picks out of the remaining 4 (obvs you aren't going to say yourself)

Thanks for asking- might as well do a pared back scum-o-meter now

Vote4scum-o-meter:

BBT
Baron
Red
Wayward
Hellhound
Bianco
Brickwall

Chat4scum-o-meter:

BBT
Baron
Hellhound
Bianco
Brickwall
Red (seemingly)
Wayward (seemingly)

Baron4scum-o-meter:

BBT- explained a bunch before
Bianco- worse impression for me than than Brickwall, let me find quotes though
Brickwall- ^v
Hellhound- I really haven’t seen anything scummy from them, probably interchangeable with above 2
Red and Way surely are towny bucket if that logic is sound, still convincing myself of it

[Baron Kirkholm Uttgart]

@ Baron I enjoyed your scum-o-meters.

What a coincidence, thanks!

[Baron Kirkholm Uttgart]

Just to be clear, we’re in A1 right?

[Redados]

Just to be clear, we’re in A1 right?

Yes.

I’m ready for someone to hammer BBT.

[Wayward Son]

There's been a lot of talk about Baron being scummy but I think he's just noob!town and that he wouldn't have roleblocked me.

Baron being the one to block you is where my main doubt comes in too.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Someone is playing a great game so far

[Redados]

Someone is playing a great game so far

If you’re town then yes absolutely. Fantastic day one distancing

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I'm town and I don't envy whoever is left on D3.

[Baron Kirkholm Uttgart]

Also just looked through bianco ISO specifically for content I could see to do with CCG- could see much that would indicate scum, but it was certainly not as if Bianco was avoiding CCG either. So feeling better about them now. That said I have noticed they have been trying to push attention away from themselves throughout, but especially early game, but I suspect that’s just a natural reaction.

I really will be shocked if BBT is not scum.

[Baron Kirkholm Uttgart]

I’ve changed my mind about my scumometre. Hellhound has made it to second scummiest

[Redados]

Biancospino is unique in that he’s really never pushed on me, which *I* like although maybe I’ve been pocketed

[BlueBloodedToffee]

If I don't push that counter wagon to CCG I don't believe anyone thinks I am scum.

That was really unfortunate.

[Redados]

If I don't push that counter wagon to CCG I don't believe anyone thinks I am scum.

That was really unfortunate.

You couldn’t control this but that CCG V/LA thing too…

I am once again asking someone to hammer BBT.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I really don't understand how that makes me scum

[Wayward Son]

@ BBT I think I'm ready to vote. If I'm wrong, then you can yell at me in the Dead thread. We'll both be there!

VOTE: BlueBloodedToffee fingers crossed.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

It's all good.

I am town