Community Redux | Postgame

[PenguinPower]

[PenguinPower]

Though I think I might've said Penguin was 3p in hood? Both of them kind of make sense as that to me

you said me

[Meuh]

Yeah thought so

[Frogsterking]

A hood with concrete powers and no scum in it is a pretty crazy idea to me

Yes and I think Penguin is Town on play unless I'm hella pocketed.

[Frogsterking]

Meuh did you already get a chance to talk about your read on Penguin?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

pedit: if Furtive is a third party governemtt eliminator condemner cop bla bla bla i will eat my sock

actually maybe tweetie is scum and my initial suspicions were correct because why would she offer to eat her sock unless she was sure I was wrong (:3)

[RH]

Day 3 Count II

Meuh (4) - furtiveglance, PenguinPower, Morning Tweet, PookyTheMagicalBear

No Elimination

(1) - Enchant

Not Voting

- Frogsterking, Meuh, DeasVail, Titus, ActionDan

Notes

• The combined mod ISO is here.
  
• With 10 remaining, it takes 6 to form a majority.
  
• All votes on anybody outside of Meuh and furtive as well as all votes before 779 will be considered invalid from now onwards.

The

Day

concludes in (expired on 2023-01-14 11:25:30).

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

VOTE: furtiveglance

[Frogsterking]

Meuh why did you self vote once you went back down to e-2?

[Frogsterking]

VOTE: meuh

E-1

Gn Furtive!

Says gn

UNVOTE: Meuh

I'm going to think about this first

I show reluctance, putting Meuh at e-2

Furtive's recent posting isn't even scumpinging me so I don't mind dying all that much

Meuh starts fast talking

Furtive's recent posting isn't even scumpinging me so I don't mind dying all that much

Virtue signaling?

VOTE: Meuh
No signaling, just virtue

Self vote, now e-1 instead of hammer

UNVOTE: Meuh
I'll SV if it comes to it but Furtive dying is still better cause they could just be scum

Pedit: One step ahead of you

Quickly takes self back off e-1

[Frogsterking]

1134 I don't like

VOTE: Meuh

[Frogsterking]

Frogs case on andres seems like mostly that he's absent

VOTE: Bell

Frogs case on andres seems like mostly that he's absent

VOTE: Bell

Frogs case on andres seems like mostly that he's absent

VOTE: Bell

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

VOTE: meuh

i have a bad feeling about this tbh but i also have no patience

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

e-1

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

like nothing about how furtiveglance has played this or reacted to me makes sense from the perspective of "im a town gladiator and i scumread meuh"

[Frogsterking]

Okay fine I'll think about it then UNVOTE: Meuh

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

UNVOTE: yeeeeeee

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

alright thought dump time:

i've been turning this shit over in my head a few times here's what I got:

(1) we r winning p hard - scum team should be p demotivated - would be a shame to lose to some random out of nowhere 3P nonsense.

(2) meuh's reaction to getting run up makes almost no sense from a town perspective to me, like who the hell self-votes in a gladiate? her entire play today is just kind of lolcatty - feels very much like caught scum.

(3) but i dont trust things that look too good to be true because im a paranoid conspiracy theorist. I know you'll say im overthinking this shit and you'd be right like 99 out of 100 times that Pooky is way too paranoid for this game but it doesnt feel right to me. Nothing about this feels right.

Like maybe i'm the clown who rep'd into a townstomp and is setting the town back an elim by not trusting GladiatorGlance over there but like nothing of his reaction to me feels right to me - he's getting mad about all the wrong things to get mad about if he's town.

I think there's a real chance we're about to get punk'd.

Maybe i'm wrong but I don't see why we shouldn't err on the side of safety.

Also I'm probably wrong cuz my theory is some wild shit but like I can't stop from thinking it.

Anyways thanks for coming to my TED Talk.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

maybe im just wrong lets just flip meuh

VOTE: meuh

worst case scenario we lose and I get to see Tweetie eat a sock

[ActionDan]

We're I town in meuhs shoes I might do the same thing. Maybe. Getting gladiated? Big suck. Getting a bunch of votes? Pain. Knowing towns probably OK without you? Lol good luck eat dirt go next.

Maybe, but I'd probably also harass the fuck out of furtive first.

[ActionDan]

A hood with concrete powers and no scum in it is a pretty crazy idea to me

Yes and I think Penguin is Town on play unless I'm hella pocketed.

Is there something in the hood that makes you think so? Or in this thread

[Frogsterking]

A hood with concrete powers and no scum in it is a pretty crazy idea to me

Yes and I think Penguin is Town on play unless I'm hella pocketed.

Is there something in the hood that makes you think so? Or in this thread

Nothing specific I can recall off the top of my head, I just remember thinking he seemed active in both and I never really got scum pinged.

[Frogsterking]

okay cool

I will now go into the reasons why I think Meuh is government.

I am the other Operator (technically it's possible that there's more but I very much doubt that is the case) and so I feel I have some insight into what a reaction to Maria's claim would be from someone who knew about the existence of operators.
Not only that, but the government would have even more knowledge that Maria's claim was made up because of what Maria said about 3p in 505.

See, when Maria claimed, I was preeeetty sure that they were a scum operator making stuff up, but there was an outside chance that the other operator was somebody else and this was Maria just making something else up.

BUT the government role knows about the operator thing, and they would have known if there was also some lost mason thing that they could listen in on. So, because there is no lost mason thing and what Maria was posting sounded very similar to the operator role, the government player would have 99% known that this was Maria just making stuff up.

This is where Meuh comes in. 521 reads to me as Meuh knowing based on her role that Maria is scum, but the actual reasoning provided does not really stack up. It reads to me more as the government player knowing that Maria is scum, but not being able to be completely honest about the reasons why.

If anyone is interested in any other operator details I'm happy to divulge, but Maria had reason to believe that I might be the other operator (I semi- revealed myself in my night 1 radio message) and the claim was probably to try and claim masons with me on the off-chance I was another traitor, OR banking on me potentially being an unclaimed member of the hotel.

Meuh has also weirdly not expressed suspicion of me despite me being mostly a non-presence.

But yeah, I think it makes more sense to eliminate Meuh than furtive here.

[Frogsterking]

How much do we all trust Dease as a Community? I don't trust him that much to be honest because his ISO doesn't look that great.

[Frogsterking]

What if the scum team is something like furtiveglance and Dease, and Meuh is the target of the 3rd Party Player who is like MT or something?