HMS Mutiny [Game Over]

[Killing Joke]

Dragons reuses his scum material so much you can track where he is on his agenda beat-for-beat:

(in response to Red)

Yes, and if I were an intruder, I would have lied and come up with suspicions, it wouldn't have been hard to parrot or invent some.

(in response to Elements)

Why do you think scum would blatantly target an activite slot like that

[Killing Joke]

I’m like the killing joker posts for town. Mainly because I know frogs meta and this is definitely the town game.

As for STD I was back and forth tryingest to figure out his alignment in my brain. His early game felt more scummy, but as this day is progressing I’m going back to a soft town read. I don’t std scum would make a vote like this right now.

@STD, you’re claiming a reaction test on our slot? Yes? In what universe did you not think, that I would not find that suspicious? Now that that game has ended, town!STD did exactly the same thing in the Temple game, so because he had never actually done it before - despite it being beyond silly and lame - still bought it as authentic but there’s pretty much no way in hell, STD expects me to seriously fall for it two games, back to back.

VOTE: STD

~Harley

[Titus]

Explain how you went from softing mason to dueling each other please. I'm too exhausted to parse readwalls and I'm fixin to be too drunk to.

[Killing Joke]

Explain how you went from softing mason to dueling each other please. I'm too exhausted to parse readwalls and I'm fixin to be too drunk to.

Nah you can read 4 posts yourself and you should slow down with the drinks because I don't think "dueling" and "one-sided lambasting of Dragon's scummy play" are the same construct.

[Wayward Son]

Wayward I've read some newbie games of and I think I will just find them hard to gel with.

Is it the fluff? I try to spoiler it, and it did happen.

I'm always serious on who I want overboard. umm When I figure out who that is.

Catching up.

[Wayward Son]

I`d like to ken this from Wayward as well.

I think all the post wasting posts are NAI. Of all of them HPE's most makes me want it to stay alive. Who'd kill a doll?

I'd really like to see a Tarot reading happen for someone suffering the Black Spot. Call me a scientist. Or not.

@ Passenger Hello?

[Radical Rat]

town!STD did exactly the same thing in the Temple game, so because he had never actually done it before - despite it being beyond silly and lame - still bought it as authentic but there’s pretty much no way in hell, STD expects me to seriously fall for it two games, back to back.

Are ye sayin' Fenrir's scum because he be actin' like he did on another crew? Seems to me like ye should be readin' 'im as loyal fer that, nay?

[Wayward Son]

If they are why did you not put a vote down earlier

Too many choices. But seriously, too many choices.

I'm about 50/50 in participating in RVS. This time I Didn't. shrug

[Killing Joke]

town!STD did exactly the same thing in the Temple game, so because he had never actually done it before - despite it being beyond silly and lame - still bought it as authentic but there’s pretty much no way in hell, STD expects me to seriously fall for it two games, back to back.

Are ye sayin' Fenrir's scum because he be actin' like he did on another crew? Seems to me like ye should be readin' 'im as loyal fer that, nay?

He actually claimed to have a reason for his vote in that and while objectively bad, at least he didn’t do it-

because why would scum like naked vote a townie player. Omg, STD absolutely has to be town for that.

and what world ever would any person think it makes an iota of sense to perform a very similar reaction test on the very same player you just did it too?

It looks to me like he’s wants to be tr for naked voting us, like why couldn’t scum also do that?

[Killing Joke]

@andres

@BBT

@Mala

@Enchant

@ActionDan

@Passenger

If they are why did you not put a vote down earlier

Too many choices. But seriously, too many choices.

I'm about 50/50 in participating in RVS. This time I Didn't. shrug

Can you pick a few slots (like maybe ~4) you think or feel are more suspicious than the rest, Wayward? I think that would be helpful for the quiet slots to do as well. I believe there are exactly one or two scummers hiding in the slots above and I'd like to help flush them out.

town!STD did exactly the same thing in the Temple game, so because he had never actually done it before - despite it being beyond silly and lame - still bought it as authentic but there’s pretty much no way in hell, STD expects me to seriously fall for it two games, back to back.

Are ye sayin' Fenrir's scum because he be actin' like he did on another crew? Seems to me like ye should be readin' 'im as loyal fer that, nay?

I know this is addressed to Harley and I'd like to respond as well. The argument that Dragons is reaction testing doesn't address the scumminess of posts like 137. Town!Dragons reaction testing Harley doesn't require faking agitation and a dubious interaction with Elements. Town!Dragons is also interfering with the effectiveness of their own reaction test (133.) While on a surface level "Dragons reaction tested Harley" is logical and does explain the naked vote, the way it was executed after that appears unlikely that sorting Harley was Dragon's actual intent at all.

[Wayward Son]

Something in the way the wind is blowing through the sails is telling me, "Trust KJ". I

need

something to get behind.

VOTE: Save The Dragons

Going back up on deck.

p-edit Well I was gonna follow your suspicions on STD for now. I still want something out of Passenger.

[Killing Joke]

Explain how you went from softing mason to dueling each other please. I'm too exhausted to parse readwalls and I'm fixin to be too drunk to.

Nah you can read 4 posts yourself and you should slow down with the drinks because I don't think "dueling" and "one-sided lambasting of Dragon's scummy play" are the same construct.

I had a really awful Townread on Dragons and I realized I was wrong because Dragons made an egregious scum play. In the read walls I explain what I saw, where I've seen it before and what the implications are. In this case, not only is Dragons a solid scum read but Elements is implicated just as strongly because it's an SvS tell. It's excellent news. I am not sure why I got so angry and I'm sorry that I did.

[Wayward Son]

Elements i think you're getting fussed over a playstyle difference but you're not sring me. You could be a partner of kj soft defending them but I think you're just town enraptured by their content

This post sets off shivers. It may be the way they said, "could be"?

I don't know how it makes me feel about elements though.

p-edit OK, I'll digest that.

[Killing Joke]

I'm sorry to you too, Mala, I was too harsh I think in 149. I really don't think your read in 146 is that bad, I was Townreading Dragons at the beginning of this game for a terrible reason. I think if you already suspected Dragons before his naked vote then now isn't the time to stop because I believe his vote and subsequent interaction is actually an element of his scum game which I've seen before.

[Wayward Son]

Elements is a member of this fine ship I wouldn't mind walking the plank. They're shirking their responsibilities, playing chess while our ship is in crises.

They walk around mumbling things I'm not sure of the meanings. Their last several posts were directed mainly toward STD and I can see it as Mutinous talk. They've said something along the lines of KJ being loyal crew, but is it misdirection?

Maybe the Cards will tell.

[Wayward Son]

I think RR is a true and fine Crew member. Not in my sights Today.

[Bellaphant]

^ this is all fine from ws. I'm not sure what specifically it was in the games I read, tbf a lot of the newbie games are awkward.

[ActionDan]

Read up.

VOTE: StD

First, this isn't a reaction test if he's willing to use associatives to divine a read on Elements 137. So let's make this simple: It's a bad vote against someone likely town. If there was "something to see" show us.

Town reads on RR who has essentially spent his time chastising someone in role play mode for voting a no Elim do not make sense to me.

Bella, what makes RR's posting a different caliber to eria's?

Flea's 111 sucked.

I think wayward has done alright extricating himself. I'll choose to believe his posts at face value.

Elements' posting leaves a lot to be desired but I'm not getting particularly strong scum feelings from them either.

[ActionDan]

Then again 164 is... not pleasant to read

[Wayward Son]

Then again 164 is... not pleasant to read

Is it because of this?

Elements' posting leaves a lot to be desired but I'm not getting particularly strong scum feelings from them either.

STD and Elements are the best tin foil I have atm. I'd like to hear from them.

Waves at Passenger, hi!

[Wayward Son]

I go through STD's ISO, I can see Elements being partnered.

When I go through Element's ISO, I can see them partnered with STD.

It's hard trying to convince myself it's just conf-bias.

[ActionDan]

No it's not the read itself it's that your post despite its short length is fluffed up, vague in places (what "mumbling things"?), and what's the point of the embellishment of the last line about KJ?

[Elements]

To clear up things people have been saying about my reads:
I do not town read KJ
I do not scum read StD
I did not like the vote on an empty wagon on an active and interaction creating slot.

[Wayward Son]

and what's the point of the embellishment of the last line about KJ?

I thought they might be a Mutinous member trying to slip in a Crew read to throw off suspicions. The rest was me describing what I felt about their ISO without making a Wall.

p-edit I'll sleep on it, my shift's over.

[Aisa]

-