Mini Normal 2288: Reposting Same Picture As Flavor Are Lame

[Enchant]

Official Vote Count 2.01

With 11 votes in play, it takes 6 to eliminate.

Lazy Shirou

(3): Kowahbunga, Herta, geraintm

geraintm

(2): redFF, Klick

Andante

(1): GamerGryff

Herta

(1): Lazy Shirou

PenguinPower

(1) Firebringer

Klick

(0):

Not Voting

(3): Andante, Taly, PenguinPower

Deadline:

(expired on 2023-02-12 06:48:00).

Mod notes:

This is hard one

[Herta]

Mod thinks he's at Carnegie Hall.

[Enchant]

no

[geraintm]

UNVOTE:

this is disappointing

[geraintm]

@klick

yep, i'd done nothing that looks towny. that doesn't make me scum though. and yet you had on your vague scum feeling stuck me in your 4 person scum pile and "has good scum equity" and i was just confused how you could take that from what i had done in game.

It's not much but it's enough for me to feel like it might be accurate!

i am going to object to someone going with "its not much" to placing me in a scum pile. some people in game might have reasons for putting me lean scum that i can understand, but not you.

you are then using my response to your reasoning as a reason to go after me, because i didnt respond to you properly. but all you have given me is "you vaguely feel like scum because you don't feel like the geraintm i've played with before" - and how am i meant to respond to that concretely? i literally backed off day one even harder than normal because i knew i was going to antogonise people, and day 2 i had the one or two posts - all i can do is explain why you might be getting such a vague feeling off me (i hadnt done anything of substance in game) and i can't win with you.


"It's almost like this was the point you wanted to make about my read on you all along, but you decided to beat around the bush a bit to make it look more natural. It didn't really matter to you what response I gave."

i am not sure what the above means? all i have done is say your read on me is a bad one and you need to let it go and wait for actual day 2 to roll on before making proper reads on me, not just on your day 1 vague feeling.

so from what im getting herta playstyle is naturally scummy ?

herta is not scummy.

penguin - why the quick vote entering day 2 and then backing off? very mixed signals

[Klick]

You want to position my suspicion of you as stronger than it is so that you can argue that I shouldn't suspect you strongly

A good way of putting my current read on you is 'everyone else in the game is townier than you'

Of course I don't have solid reasoning for suspecting you, you've not done anything substantial
But there are three scum to find, and other people are giving me reasons to think it's not them, and you're not
You're thinking too much about trying to 'win with me' or otherwise argue against the fact that you have wound up at the bottom of my PoE through virtue of kinda doing nothing

I don't have to have specific things to point at that you've done that are scummy to think that you could very easily be one of the three players in this game with a red Role PM

[Klick]

'Null' becomes 'likely scum' pretty quickly when most of the townies in the game are becoming 'likely town'

[PenguinPower]

penguin - why the quick vote entering day 2 and then backing off? very mixed signals

hi. I'm penguin.

[PenguinPower]

VOTE: geraintm

[geraintm]

You want to position my suspicion of you as stronger than it is so that you can argue that I shouldn't suspect you strongly

A good way of putting my current read on you is 'everyone else in the game is townier than you'

Of course I don't have solid reasoning for suspecting you, you've not done anything substantial
But there are three scum to find, and other people are giving me reasons to think it's not them, and you're not
You're thinking too much about trying to 'win with me' or otherwise argue against the fact that you have wound up at the bottom of my PoE through virtue of kinda doing nothing

I don't have to have specific things to point at that you've done that are scummy to think that you could very easily be one of the three players in this game with a red Role PM

ho hum. i don't know how to argue against this then, as it is an absence of towniness that you are using to vote for me.
i'll leave it, interacting with you isn't helping at all. i have no reason to think you are scum (i just found your view on me odd and i was compelled to respond).
i am much more interested in Shirou....

[geraintm]

penguin - why the quick vote entering day 2 and then backing off? very mixed signals

hi. I'm penguin.

what would you have done if i had followed your vote? it to me looked like you had a guilty.

[PenguinPower]

oh, i'm still not taking questions.

[geraintm]

oh, i'm still not taking questions.

that isnt how this works

[PenguinPower]

it isn't? pretty sure it works how i want it to.

[Andante]

Hi sorry, I'll be around this weekend hopefully, I'm just super busy at the moment, I was like "please tell me I'm dead" nope, of course not lmao can't wait for final 3 (so... dead chat is probably gonna yell at me if wrong.. but I really think... **hammers town** followed by eternal sadness)
I'm town though, so just write me off as town and bam! easy game to solve!
- Got no info last night to share with yall

ok bye, I have exam I haven't studied for. rip. this only ends well.

[Firebringer]

wow im a liar i never got back to this and shirou question. Maybe i will get to it over the weekend. Or maybe i will procrastinate it to never answering.

Anyways i don't like wagons and i actually want to hear more from andante who is basically at null for me right now.

Andante stop studying and start solving

[GamerGryff]

oh, i'm still not taking questions.

This does literally nothing for town, if you're not willing to at least put in the effort to try and scumhunt and discuss, you're just dead weight

[PenguinPower]

thank you for your opinion on my play

[Firebringer]

i appreciate ur play regardless of ur alignment penguin friend

[Herta]

Stop touching me.

[PenguinPower]

i appreciate ur play regardless of ur alignment penguin friend

<3

[GamerGryff]

Honestly

VOTE: Penguin

For not participating

[redFF]

Honestly

VOTE: Penguin

For not participating

huh?

[Herta]

Maybe Gryff is scum after all?

[PenguinPower]

Honestly

VOTE: Penguin

For not participating

huh?

He thinks because I won't answer a specific line of questions I am not participating.