HMS Mutiny [Game Over]

[Malakittens]

I'm also more worried about eira than I was. I think eira needs to spend today straight talking

Why are you worried about Eira? Why does scum!Eira tell town!HPE to get into the thread because of “sharks”? Idk, I’m hard townreading him after last day. I was wrong on Gamma but he adamantly tried to save her. I don’t see why scum!Eira does that?

White knight

[Killing Joke]

Do you think you've played well this game?

I would say it's pretty likely to be facing 4 scum in a 16 player game.

Obviously no. It’s a tossup atp bewtween this game and LOST but I generally suck at most larges. Idk but I just think Gimli trying to run me up is hella scummy but I’m trying to make up for earlier but town!Gimli 100% would realize I’m town by now because this just isn’t how I play scum plus the

double soft inno

.

Basically having too many trs is NEVER a reason to sr me in any game ever.

[Killing Joke]

I think we need to mass claim today to try and narrow the pool if we can.

I'm really intrigued with what happened to Enchant as well.

I’m fine with that. We’re still 100% vt.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

It is when you're not accounting for how many scum are left and claiming all of your TRs are correct, Nancy.

It's extremely unlikely that this is 13/3 with town having a Looker/Watcher, Vanilla Cop, Vig, redirector (which I still think could be scum because I think it has more utility as a scum PR) as well as some other potentially unknown PR which killed Enchant.

Make what you're saying make sense, Nancy.

[Killing Joke]

I'm also more worried about eira than I was. I think eira needs to spend today straight talking

Why are you worried about Eira? Why does scum!Eira tell town!HPE to get into the thread because of “sharks”? Idk, I’m hard townreading him after last day. I was wrong on Gamma but he adamantly tried to save her. I don’t see why scum!Eira does that?

White knight

You really think he could be doing that as scum? Joker told me that Eira plays differently as scum, is more calculated and lurks, which seems to be pretty much 180 degrees the antithesis of what we’ve seen so far here.

~H

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I said I wanted to speak to Frog Yesterday, where is he?

I completely disagree with his meta read on Eira. All 3 of us played in a game recently as the scum team and I think Eira is playing this game similarly.

He kept promising to make cases and give thought out reads etc without actually doing it. I need Frog to come into this game.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

He also white knighted pretty hard.

If I used meta, which I don't, I would say Eira is almost definitely replicating his meta from that game.

[Gimli]

He also white knighted pretty hard.

If I used meta, which I don't, I would say Eira is almost definitely replicating his meta from that game.

how is it possible that this is someone's scum game? can you link me that game, BBT?

[Elements]

As well as that, there are too many as wells in the sentence above as well.

Best quote of the game

[Killing Joke]

It is when you're not accounting for how many scum are left and claiming all of your TRs are correct, Nancy.

It's extremely unlikely that this is 13/3 with town having a Looker/Watcher, Vanilla Cop, Vig, redirector (which I still think could be scum because I think it has more utility as a scum PR) as well as some other potentially unknown PR which killed Enchant.

Make what you're saying make sense, Nancy.

How about I possibly shoot Elements and we elim Gamma?

fine with these and also fine with enchant flipping cause it's still mafia

I thought you vigged him but then whomever did is a town hero.

[Gimli]

enchant flipped at end of day, how could it be BBT?

[Gimli]

she is faking dumbtells

[Killing Joke]

I said I wanted to speak to Frog Yesterday, where is he?

I completely disagree with his meta read on Eira. All 3 of us played in a game recently as the scum team and I think Eira is playing this game similarly.

He kept promising to make cases and give thought out reads etc without actually doing it. I need Frog to come into this game.

Well it looks now that Elements is probably town because he gave new results and scum wouldn’t have two very similar roles I don’t think.

I will tell him again but he’s generally hard to track down on weekends, so he’ll probably post something tomorrow.

[Killing Joke]

she is faking dumbtells

I never fake dumbtell and that’s yet another thing you know about me, my vote stays.

[Killing Joke]

Flavour

Tensions were mounting on the third day since downsizing had been announced. Paranoia filled the sea air, and every pirate took issue with their loyalty being questioned. With no sign of Mutineers, and the strongly felt absences of 4 honest Crew, the ship was fraught with a dangerous mixture of anger, despair and apathy. On this day, the largest crowd of pirates was surrounding Gamma Emerald. "Fine", she yelled, at one point seeming to go willingly towards the plank of the ship. But then she tried to turn back, only to find her route blocked. The jostling group of pirates ensured that she stumbled onto the wobbly plank and soon splashed into the briny deep. As everyone was about to shuffle back to their cabins, ActionDan suddenly keeled over. Then, just as everyone turned to stare, Enchant collapsed on the deck. "Nothing to see here", said Aisa, the ship's Scribe, as she swept up one in each hand and unceremoniously dumped them over the side.

Flips and Nightstart

Gamma Emerald was a

Spoiler:

Loyal Sailor.

Spoiler: Role PM

Welcome to HMS Mutiny,

Wayward Son

Gamma Emerald! You are a

Loyal Sailor

and are aligned with the

Crew

.

Abilities:

You have no special abilities.

Win condition:

You win if all threats to the Crew are eliminated and at least one member of the Crew is alive.

Confirm by replying with your role and alignment in a PM to me.

ActionDan was a

Spoiler:

Loyal Sailor.

Spoiler: Role PM

Welcome to HMS Mutiny, ActionDan! You are a

Loyal Sailor

and are aligned with the

Crew

.

Abilities:

You have no special abilities.

Win condition:

You win if all threats to the Crew are eliminated and at least one member of the Crew is alive.

Confirm by replying with your role and alignment in a PM to me.

Enchant was a

Spoiler:

Cabin Servant.

Spoiler: Role PM

Welcome to HMS Mutiny, Enchant! You are a

Cabin Servant

and are aligned with the

Mutineers

.

Flavour: "Make those floorboards shine, ye scurvy dog! I want to see my beard reflected in every surface." Ever since you were captured by this pirate ship, your life has been one of servitude. [REDACTED] But, things could be about to change around here...and who would suspect you, the lowly Cabin Servant, of mutiny? You could even put your access to the Crew's cabins to use for nefarious means...

You may speak to [REDACTED] in the Mutineer PT at any time.

Abilities:

• Informed [passive]: [REDACTED].
  
• The Black Spot [factional]: Each Night, you and your partners may target a player. Assuming no interference with your action, they will die at the end of the following Day. In the morning, they will be informed they will die.
  
• Officer Cop: Each Night, target a player. Assuming no interference with your action, I will tell you whether or not they are an Officer.

You may use any number of abilities in the same Night.

Win condition:

You win if at least one Mutineer is alive and all other players are dead (or if nothing can prevent the same).

Confirm by replying with your role and alignment, either in a PM or in your PT.

Night 3 begins now and ends in (expired on 2023-02-05 10:20:00). Send any night actions to Aisa.

Enchant flipped during the night, why wouldn’t I think BBT shot him?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Because Enchant would have been dead at day start, not end of day.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

@Gimli, scum Eira;

viewtopic.php?sid=&f=53&t=89984&user_select%5B%5D=28136

[Killing Joke]

Flavour

Tensions were mounting on the third day since downsizing had been announced. Paranoia filled the sea air, and every pirate took issue with their loyalty being questioned. With no sign of Mutineers, and the strongly felt absences of 4 honest Crew, the ship was fraught with a dangerous mixture of anger, despair and apathy. On this day, the largest crowd of pirates was surrounding Gamma Emerald. "Fine", she yelled, at one point seeming to go willingly towards the plank of the ship. But then she tried to turn back, only to find her route blocked. The jostling group of pirates ensured that she stumbled onto the wobbly plank and soon splashed into the briny deep. As everyone was about to shuffle back to their cabins, ActionDan suddenly keeled over. Then, just as everyone turned to stare, Enchant collapsed on the deck. "Nothing to see here", said Aisa, the ship's Scribe, as she swept up one in each hand and unceremoniously dumped them over the side.

Flips and Nightstart

Gamma Emerald was a

Spoiler:

Loyal Sailor.

Spoiler: Role PM

Welcome to HMS Mutiny,

Wayward Son

Gamma Emerald! You are a

Loyal Sailor

and are aligned with the

Crew

.

Abilities:

You have no special abilities.

Win condition:

You win if all threats to the Crew are eliminated and at least one member of the Crew is alive.

Confirm by replying with your role and alignment in a PM to me.

ActionDan was a

Spoiler:

Loyal Sailor.

Spoiler: Role PM

Welcome to HMS Mutiny, ActionDan! You are a

Loyal Sailor

and are aligned with the

Crew

.

Abilities:

You have no special abilities.

Win condition:

You win if all threats to the Crew are eliminated and at least one member of the Crew is alive.

Confirm by replying with your role and alignment in a PM to me.

Enchant was a

Spoiler:

Cabin Servant.

Spoiler: Role PM

Welcome to HMS Mutiny, Enchant! You are a

Cabin Servant

and are aligned with the

Mutineers

.

Flavour: "Make those floorboards shine, ye scurvy dog! I want to see my beard reflected in every surface." Ever since you were captured by this pirate ship, your life has been one of servitude. [REDACTED] But, things could be about to change around here...and who would suspect you, the lowly Cabin Servant, of mutiny? You could even put your access to the Crew's cabins to use for nefarious means...

You may speak to [REDACTED] in the Mutineer PT at any time.

Abilities:

• Informed [passive]: [REDACTED].
  
• The Black Spot [factional]: Each Night, you and your partners may target a player. Assuming no interference with your action, they will die at the end of the following Day. In the morning, they will be informed they will die.
  
• Officer Cop: Each Night, target a player. Assuming no interference with your action, I will tell you whether or not they are an Officer.

You may use any number of abilities in the same Night.

Win condition:

You win if at least one Mutineer is alive and all other players are dead (or if nothing can prevent the same).

Confirm by replying with your role and alignment, either in a PM or in your PT.

Night 3 begins now and ends in (expired on 2023-02-05 10:20:00). Send any night actions to Aisa.

Enchant flipped during the night, why wouldn’t I think BBT shot him?

Oh there was a daykill? How did Enchant die then?

[Killing Joke]

Because Enchant would have been dead at day start, not end of day.

But how did he die then, since he couldn’t have black spot right?

[BlueBloodedToffee]

There is no way town didn't notice that 3 people died.

That almost confirms KJ as scum to me. Town would have noticed an extra flip immediately.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I think we need to mass claim today to try and narrow the pool if we can.

I'm really intrigued with what happened to Enchant as well.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

It's like you're not even reading, Nancy.

[Elements]

VOTE: KJ

[Elements]

UNVOTE:

[Elements]

VOTE: KJ