HMS Mutiny [Game Over]

[Gimli]

Well, that'd be between mala and BBT. That'd mean BBT wolf here a lot actually

[Killing Joke]

Elements used KJ claim D1 to fake role, if KJ vanilla, then used Enchant result on Dan to justify that fake, then 'cleared' Flea with BBT claim then 'cleared' Gimli by 'checking' Mal. It's all pretty obvious KJ.

Can you quote all of these posts for me please?

[Aisa]

4.04

Votecount 4.04

Gimli (1):

BlueBloodedToffee.

Flea The Magician (1):

Gimli.

Bellaphant (1):

Elements.

Elements (1):

Eiralox.

Not Voting (5):

Bellaphant, Radical Rat, Flea The Magician, Malakittens, Killing Joke.

With 9 players alive, it takes 5 to eliminate someone.

Day 4 ends in (expired on 2023-02-12 15:30:00).

Co-Mod Notes

• Combined Mod ISO

[Radical Rat]

So, to be 100% clear, all it says is that "you are a miller" with no elaboration on what that means?

[Eiralox]

KJ was obvious Loyal Sailor to me start Day2 after what Joker did. Same thing made me think they're loyal sailor made me think poss. traitor.

So Elements trusting KJ is vanilla isn't that hard to see, cos it vas kinda obvious from my pov.

The rest is just too convenient to be real. Only reveal check on BBT after claim.

[Eiralox]

Elements used KJ claim D1 to fake role, if KJ vanilla, then used Enchant result on Dan to justify that fake, then 'cleared' Flea with BBT claim then 'cleared' Gimli by 'checking' Mal. It's all pretty obvious KJ.

Can you quote all of these posts for me please?

no

[Malakittens]

So, to be 100% clear, all it says is that "you are a miller" with no elaboration on what that means?

Yes

[Killing Joke]

This is probably the worst Town game I've played as far as reads go.

After I saw the flips I spazzed out and once I calmed down I realized the only logical explanation is that Gimli is playing a very lively scum game which had me completely snowed. Sorry I didn't listen to you earlier Mala.

Elements is...still scum unless I'm missing something. I'm fine voting out Gimli and Elements in any order.

~Joker

PEdit

I see Mala thinks Elements is Town for some reason I don't understand so VOTE: Gimli

[Eiralox]

Also I’m not really liking all of the killing roles. I was hesitant when Bella claimed, but if it’s redirect. I can kinda see scum either having a redirect or a bulletproof.

I believe elements is most likely town after the enchant flip tho.

Agreed

I think there's definitely scum between BBT and Bella rn. Game doesn't make sense if scum has no kill power and town has two one shots. It's too unbalanced

It's not. A dead Passenger and a dead Dan tells me it's very, very balanced. In fact, crew was really struggling here. BBT might have killed me if had more shots.

[Killing Joke]

Kj I don’t see a world with elements is scum unless elements really did fake after elements was seen with Titus watcher.

The only real way to clear elements would be to flip her but THAT Isn’t just possible or even well planned because if element is town then we just lost that really badly lost our vanilla cop

Yeah, I think the fact that they have results that do fit with the claims + Enchant’s role.

What do you think about Flea? And who if anyone do you think I’m reading wrong?

[Gimli]

KJ
BBT
RR?

That's my final solve. Goodbye now go town sorry for all the screaming

VOTE: gimli

[Eiralox]

This is probably the worst Town game I've played as far as reads go.

After I saw the flips I spazzed out and once I calmed down I realized the only logical explanation is that Gimli is playing a very lively scum game which had me completely snowed. Sorry I didn't listen to you earlier Mala.

Elements is...still scum unless I'm missing something. I'm fine voting out Gimli and Elements in any order.

~Joker

PEdit

I see Mala thinks Elements is Town for some reason I don't understand so VOTE: Gimli

why won't you vote elements here? they're the obvious scum pr!

[Malakittens]

IDK
WHY
ELEMENTS COULD BE SCUM

I MEAN I SEE WHY BUT WE RISK LOSING THE COP THANG IF ELE IS TOWN
BUT ON THE FLIP SIDE WE KILL A SCUM PR IF ELE IS SCUM

BUT IDK IF THIS IS FHE RIGHT OLAH

[Eiralox]

KJ
BBT
RR?

That's my final solve. Goodbye now go town sorry for all the screaming

VOTE: gimli

Shoulda voted Elements, if yer crew.

[Radical Rat]

So, to be 100% clear, all it says is that "you are a miller" with no elaboration on what that means?

Yes

That's very strange. Even if it were a regular alignment Miller, the role PM should explain what that means, rather than just expect you to know automatically.

I'd advise you to ask the mod for clarification

[Eiralox]

IDK
WHY
ELEMENTS COULD BE SCUM

I MEAN I SEE WHY BUT WE RISK LOSING THE COP THANG IF ELE IS TOWN
BUT ON THE FLIP SIDE WE KILL A SCUM PR IF ELE IS SCUM

BUT IDK IF THIS IS FHE RIGHT OLAH

Too late. I said take it slow but whatever. Probably Gimli is saving Elements here but if they're crew, like, 2% chance in mind? 7% after their excellent maybe theater? we're screwed.

[Killing Joke]

KJ
BBT
RR?

That's my final solve. Goodbye now go town sorry for all the screaming

VOTE: gimli

If you’re town here, congrats we’re going to lose. I was going to vote Flea but hopefully it is you. *prays*

[Elements]

Once again, Gimli hasn't been hammered yet?

[Eiralox]

they have?

[Killing Joke]

Once again, Gimli hasn't been hammered yet?

UNVOTE:

[Gimli]

KJ
BBT
RR?

That's my final solve. Goodbye now go town sorry for all the screaming

VOTE: gimli

If you’re town here, congrats we’re going to lose. I was going to vote Flea but hopefully it is you. *prays*

LOL you just voted me in this page

I'm done with this, I'm tired of every townie scumreading me and I need to flip so the remaining townies can solve with the extra info

goodbye

[Killing Joke]

KJ
BBT
RR?

That's my final solve. Goodbye now go town sorry for all the screaming

VOTE: gimli

If you’re town here, congrats we’re going to lose. I was going to vote Flea but hopefully it is you. *prays*

LOL you just voted me in this page

I'm done with this, I'm tired of every townie scumreading me and I need to flip so the remaining townies can solve with the extra info

goodbye

Not me, Joker voted you and then you immediately voted.

VOTE: Flea

[Gimli]

also I have like 10 posts left. what else can I say? IDK where the scum is, really. it can be any of you potatoes.

[Eiralox]

Shit what world am I on. AH well.

I think the best POE is Elements>Gimli>Flea the Magician then if we're still somehow here, Killing Joke.

[Radical Rat]

What do you mean you have 10 posts left? There's no way you've posted 140 times already