HMS Mutiny [Game Over]

[Eiralox]

...

This is definitely a bit tinfoily but...

What if Mala's the traitor?

Miller is a pretty solid claim for a traitor to make, and if she's a traitor who doesn't know the main scumteam, Enchant could have just been an accident.

It helps with the PR balance issue, and explains Elements' result... The informed bit could be the existence of a traitor... It all lines up.

Idk, someone tell me I'm crazy here

makes perfect sense to me

*sigh*


See? A slog. Troll scum at this point. Bye ya'll.

[Radical Rat]

I am a Miller, but I also have one shot role.
I have one shot delayed vig.

I’m the asshole who shot enchant.

I was in between him or gimli, but in the end I picked enchant because I had something bugging me in the way he was engaging with me.

The less amount of information that scum has the better. Can we just move on?

Unless you are telling me that I’m scum and enchant bussed me by fishing for my role.

Does Town call themselves an asshole for correctly shooting scum?

Does Town get weird and cagey about information contained in part of their role.... When that information doesn't actually exist at all?

[Radical Rat]

Idk the more I think about this the more sense it all makes

[Gimli]

her miller claim isn't making much sense with us having nothing but vanilla cops. I know I was arguing for the other thing, but especifically the fact that she is a one-shot doesn't make sense with her also being miller in a game of vanilla cops, cause all the results will be the same (non-vanilla), than if she was just a one-shot delayed vigilante.

[Eiralox]

I am a Miller, but I also have one shot role.
I have one shot delayed vig.

I’m the asshole who shot enchant.

I was in between him or gimli, but in the end I picked enchant because I had something bugging me in the way he was engaging with me.

The less amount of information that scum has the better. Can we just move on?

Unless you are telling me that I’m scum and enchant bussed me by fishing for my role.

Does Town call themselves an asshole for correctly shooting scum?

Does Town get weird and cagey about information contained in part of their role.... When that information doesn't actually exist at all?

absolutely.


Please don't tell me we aren't 5/4 here and you're a traitor rat? Elements is pretty obvious scum and the progression of their fake role is very apparent. Meh.

Then again my mind goes to Killing Joke.

This is why I should stop talking about this. No use at this point.

Crew ill still have majority and there's no way in any hell we're limming Mala over Elements.

[Killing Joke]

...

This is definitely a bit tinfoily but...

What if Mala's the traitor?

Miller is a pretty solid claim for a traitor to make, and if she's a traitor who doesn't know the main scumteam, Enchant could have just been an accident.

It helps with the PR balance issue, and explains Elements' result... The informed bit could be the existence of a traitor... It all lines up.

Idk, someone tell me I'm crazy here

Why on earth would hypothetical Mala traitor shoot Enchant like ever? Mala’s locktown, no wonder this game’s such a mess.

[Radical Rat]

Fuck it.

VOTE: Malakittens

I'm going to be very angry with myself if it's just Gimli and I talked myself out of being right again, but. I can't let this go if I'm right.

[Killing Joke]

Fuck it.

VOTE: Malakittens

I'm going to be very angry with myself if it's just Gimli and I talked myself out of being right again, but. I can't let this go if I'm right.

She shot Enchant, she’s the towniest slot in the game.

[Radical Rat]

...

This is definitely a bit tinfoily but...

What if Mala's the traitor?

Miller is a pretty solid claim for a traitor to make, and if she's a traitor who doesn't know the main scumteam, Enchant could have just been an accident.

It helps with the PR balance issue, and explains Elements' result... The informed bit could be the existence of a traitor... It all lines up.

Idk, someone tell me I'm crazy here

Why on earth would hypothetical Mala traitor shoot Enchant like ever? Mala’s locktown, no wonder this game’s such a mess.

Because she wouldn't have known Enchant was scum. Maybe she thought Gimli was scum and so thought the kill was safe, and saw that a mislim wasn't happening.

[Killing Joke]

...

This is definitely a bit tinfoily but...

What if Mala's the traitor?

Miller is a pretty solid claim for a traitor to make, and if she's a traitor who doesn't know the main scumteam, Enchant could have just been an accident.

It helps with the PR balance issue, and explains Elements' result... The informed bit could be the existence of a traitor... It all lines up.

Idk, someone tell me I'm crazy here

Why on earth would hypothetical Mala traitor shoot Enchant like ever? Mala’s locktown, no wonder this game’s such a mess.

Because she wouldn't have known Enchant was scum. Maybe she thought Gimli was scum and so thought the kill was safe, and saw that a mislim wasn't happening.

If she was scum. then shooting us would be brilliant but I’m extremely confident on Mala!town> anyone else in this game and I’m not allowing my #1 tr to get run up.

[Radical Rat]

I mean. You've been very loud and very keen on pushing Townies. If I were scum, I wouldn't kill you.

[Gimli]

think I'm clearing rat, after all of this.

don't like nancy's defense of mala here either. scum team will know that one is a traitor, right?

traitor also makes sense with enchant's role, cause it'll return VTs and the traitor as non-officers. that way they won't mistakenly kill their traitor.

if we have all this killing power AND a tracker AND a parity cop, then surely mala can be the traitor.

but then we still have other three scums outside of mala.

[Eiralox]

...

This is definitely a bit tinfoily but...

What if Mala's the traitor?

Miller is a pretty solid claim for a traitor to make, and if she's a traitor who doesn't know the main scumteam, Enchant could have just been an accident.

It helps with the PR balance issue, and explains Elements' result... The informed bit could be the existence of a traitor... It all lines up.

Idk, someone tell me I'm crazy here

Why on earth would hypothetical Mala traitor shoot Enchant like ever? Mala’s locktown, no wonder this game’s such a mess.

Because she wouldn't have known Enchant was scum. Maybe she thought Gimli was scum and so thought the kill was safe, and saw that a mislim wasn't happening.

Enchant was funny to Mala. Mala killed them. People can have good reads, and actually kill scum.

[Eiralox]

think I'm clearing rat, after all of this.

don't like nancy's defense of mala here either. scum team will know that one is a traitor, right?

traitor also makes sense with enchant's role, cause it'll return VTs and the traitor as non-officers. that way they won't mistakenly kill their traitor.

if we have all this killing power AND a tracker AND a parity cop, then surely mala can be the traitor.

but then we still have other three scums outside of mala.

Ok so Rat is your traitor? Or you're just loving your new clown suit?

Sleepy time.

[Gimli]

eira I'm almost done with posting for the gameday but I'll save this one post just to tell you this is extremely annoying to deal with your tunneling every single one of my posts. I don't wanna engage with you, you're not talking through anything with me just calling me scum and if you're town you're the biggest potato in the game. go talk to other people and leave me alone now.

[Eiralox]

You had your chance to vote Elements. Stop trying to eke out a victory for a lost cause and I'll leave you alone.

On an unrelated not, I'm leaving you alone.

@Everyone who isn't a mutineer or a possible traitor: I'm ready for either an Elements flip or a Gimli flip.

My earlier caution is, so to say, gone.

[Killing Joke]

think I'm clearing rat, after all of this.

don't like nancy's defense of mala here either. scum team will know that one is a traitor, right?

traitor also makes sense with enchant's role, cause it'll return VTs and the traitor as non-officers. that way they won't mistakenly kill their traitor.

if we have all this killing power AND a tracker AND a parity cop, then surely mala can be the traitor.

but then we still have other three scums outside of mala.

Yeah you don’t like pretty much anything I’ve said but I protect my strong trs so feel free to wrongly sr me for that. You’re wrongly sr me for tons of terrible reasons, no reason to stop now.

[Gimli]

if RR is right, this is literally elim-or-lose.

[Killing Joke]

eira I'm almost done with posting for the gameday but I'll save this one post just to tell you this is extremely annoying to deal with your tunneling every single one of my posts. I don't wanna engage with you, you're not talking through anything with me just calling me scum and if you're town you're the biggest potato in the game. go talk to other people and leave me alone now.

Um hello, pot meet kettle?

[Gimli]

ATTENTION EVERYONE

ISO malakittens. ctrl+f enchant. there isn't a single moment in which malakittens scumreads enchant. this is her last post in which she talks about enchant before she kills him:

Idk but Eira feels like scum failing which is weird bc they aren’t under pressure when they stated acting like that,

I feel like Kj is p clear to be town to me right now between Meta and Titus. So not touching there with a 29008493 foot pole.

Elements im kinda ont be fence about. I can see elements being a scum pr.

Enchant is p town imo

Gamma can go either way

Action Dan can go eight way

Radialrwt might be town but idk how they play but I’m townreading they slot

Flea I think is fae town.

Gimli is gonna be sorted out but obv scum js

Bbt might be town but idk

[Gimli]

if malakittens was a townie with a gun she would've shot me and not someone she was townreading

[Eiralox]

People lie, to survive.

[Radical Rat]

Having two Town vigs is also really weird, isn't it?

[Malakittens]

Eh, tbh, enchant is a good kill. Enchant is a very hard player to read
)&: his scum and Town Meta are similar
My enchant shot was already placed on n2 so he was deadman walking d3 I said I was townreading him bc I didn’t want anyone trying to lim him d3 bc he was dead coming into n3 I didn’t want to have to claim fully yo save hum

[Malakittens]

I was planning on yeeting gimli d3 but I got busy and couldn’t case

I’m still busy today I ran 20 calls in 12 hrs