Newbie 2111 - Know Your Skittles! (Game Over)

[Elements]

I like Arko for town
VOTE: Weuler

[Weuler]

@Aureal, what are your thoughts on Human? Do you think it was a slip or not?

Aww, you don't think I was being serious with my solve?

I didn't and I'm still not sure if you are!

[Black]

Black, what's your previous mafia experience?

I played on the WotC forums over 15 years ago. This my 2nd game out of retirement

[Elements]

What made you want to retire from retirement?

[Black]

I like Arko for town
VOTE: Weuler

Same. His reads post felt like a town post to me

I don't have many reads yet. I've always had a hard time gauging alignments in the RVS

I still don't like Human's "slip" but that by itself is not vote worthy in my eyes

Arko, Elements seem pretty townie

Weuler feels kinda performative but mostly townie

I'm getting null vibes on Aureal

I don't like python's eagerness to discuss roles. Slightly scummy

Taly and Human Sequencer are M.I.A... I think I would like to vote for one of these to get them going in the game and I think Taly is on vacation so

VOTE: Human Sequencer

[Black]

What made you want to retire from retirement?

Honestly, I work from home and have lots of free time, so I figured I would jump back in

[Elements]

I'm finding Weuler to be a bit wooden

[Elements]

Talyyyyyyyy!
Come and bleed town all over the place

[usesPython]

Weuler read:
In Newbie 2109 as VT they make the first post of the game with

VOTE: CCGeek, obvious lurkscum. Haven't made a single post

Whereas in 52 this game they post

Weuler, can I persuade you to VOTE: Taly?

I prefer to vote for people who have made a post

Now obviously the first post is a joke, but I'm not sure it's a joke someone who prefers voting for people who've made a post would make. Might be hesitant to vote for Taly specifically?

Post 73:

Also VT read on Human Sequencer, it'd be odd to ignore a game if there's something interesting happening and since there's no indication of them going V/LA
(And thus clearly everyone that has posted so far must have an interesting role, QED you're all scum)

Let's not PR hunt

Post 74 they vote me and explain in post 78

UNVOTE: Arko and VOTE: Python

Did that comment actually seem scummy to you?

No it seems like a comment from a newbie. Consider my vote an effort to discourage further PR-hunting.

But if it's a scum!Weuler game they start PR hunting themselves in 119 by pushing this line of questioning

My point was there were at most two PR's

A question to clarify: Did you know that not all possibilities contains 2 PR when you wrote the original post?

UNVOTE: Elements
VOTE: Weuler

[Black]

Weuler, what say you? Are you in fact made of wood?

[Black]

I like this post by python. But I'm not sure I can get on board with the case. Inconsistencies in RVS between two games probably isn't alignment indicative. Weuler's #119 strikes me as him trying to pursue his suspicions on Human based on Human's "slip" rather than PR hunt

[Human]

Well was gonna mention you hadn’t posted in a while and this pops up

[Human]

Also you did say that it was the FIRST post of 2109 so no one else had posted thus the RVS was a joke

[usesPython]

Aureal:
Null read, pretty much all her posts are fluff. Consistent with Newbie 2108 as VT, inconsistent with Micro 1068 where she's actually scumhunting by her 3rd post as VT

[usesPython]

Also you did say that it was the FIRST post of 2109 so no one else had posted thus the RVS was a joke

Sure but my point isn't whether or not it was a joke (it clearly was), rather is it a joke that someone who prefers voting for posters would make

[Human]

Oh wait that is what you said I’m an idiot

[usesPython]

I like this post by python. But I'm not sure I can get on board with the case. Inconsistencies in RVS between two games probably isn't alignment indicative. Weuler's #119 strikes me as him trying to pursue his suspicions on Human based on Human's "slip" rather than PR hunt

Even if the slip is real it'd still have to be NAI for town!Weuler, so why would town!Weuler continue the line of questioning?

[usesPython]

Arko:
Null read, based off Newbie 2109 it looks like they do better when they have actual information to work off (They replaced at the start of d2 as VT) so I'll revise my read on them once they have more posts

[usesPython]

Human:
Gives me newtown vibes, he tried to get posts early that he could presumably work with. Don't agree with his reads but I can see how he got there

[Black]

Actually you're right Python and I didn't even think of it that way. This whole time I was looking through the lens of scum!Human being the only way he could know there are 2 PRs. I wasn't even considering the fact that certain PRs will also know this information too depending on what PR they have

[Black]

Human was null but now that I understand the situation better I think he leans town. His thought progression feels natural and I like that he's making reads already

Weuler loses town points for me here

[usesPython]

Elements:
22 posts worth of fluff at the start only to follow it up with one sentence posts is somehow consistent with with their Newbie 2108 game as VT, same with them always being on E-3/E-2 wagons (also please start wallposting instead it makes my job easier)

Null read leaning slightly townie

[usesPython]

Black:
Null read leaning townie based on my gut instinct, no analysis because I've been reading posts for the past hour and my brain has turned to mush

[Elements]

Ew wallposting, no thank you

[Elements]

Python, how much do you think people can emulate their town game as scum?