ffery is Luke's slotIn post 2516, petapan wrote:uh what turned you around on fferyIn post 2508, Dunnstral wrote:Oh, don't worry... they areIn post 2505, unwnd wrote: I want ffery and peta to both be town but I'm not sure if they both are
I realized, and the whole sequence set off my plunge into the snarky fishes rabbithole.In post 2527, Bell wrote: Oh. I was being totally sarcastic in my reversal of my read on Marci. I was half-heartedly trying to play ball and try to convince the scum team to kill them if I was wrong.
But self control broke and I reverted to active open skepticism.
I mean I'm cheating because I know for a fact you're right. But if you want #2, I'd lean more STD.In post 2517, unwnd wrote: We're smart people.
There has to be scum between Dunn/StD/Marci.
Right? ..Right?
In post 2114, Bell wrote: Oh, Dunn is just saying I haven't exited my scum range.
Sure. Okay.
Did Marci say who they tracked yet.
I'm irrationally hesitating I will always regret the road not traveled when the road ended up being a green blood splatter but you always have to wonder if they're both going to be green blood splatters.
Did I mention I'm upset that KT fliped green, because I'm pretty sad about that.
I genuinely don't know how I was supposed to tell. I guess there were some hints in how they formulated their reads lists on people. But sigh. A minor inkling.
Like cop is easy for scum to fakeclaim. "I'm super cop. X is town. Y is town. Z is town. Look I know because they're not in the scum PT with me".In post 2531, Bell wrote: Hey, I did ask.
But I would like to selfishly continue to claim that I need a methodology and accept the criticism anyway.
If you actually think she's scum, then there's two possibilities:In post 2535, unwnd wrote: Marci is just there because I see people still want marci dead (Peta, et al). I don't know what marci is up to but I've seen her come in here saying that we don't care about her reads and then someone will say 'Yeah Marci, we actually do' then she leaves. I have to ask myself if I want that type of play to be anywhere near the top-half of a readlist.
As far as her claim goes? I believe someone said that outing her result gives scum a lead on other PRs because she claimed her target didn't visit anyone.
what i mean by that is "i push hard (very frequently)" not "i push hard (literally always)" butunderstand the linguistic ambiguityIn post 2395, fferyllt wrote:Sometimes you don't though.In post 2051, petapan wrote: when i push hard all the time as town too
(I recently insomnia-reread Not Quite Normal 1)
It was probably a passing fancy.
There's three whole targeting roles left alive that could have submitted a night action last night. (Doctor, Ascetic Cop, Draft Cop) If she's picking someone scummy who is middle/end of the pack (because none of the investigative roles are targeting the top 4, where scum are going to be shooting), what are scum going to potentially learn? Lukewarm/Fferlyt doesn't have one of those three roles? Gee. I bet they'd have never guessed.In post 2539, unwnd wrote: Pray tell how the first point is absolutely true? Let's say she's real. If her check is on
1) A member who didn't submit a kill
2) A vanilla townie who doesn't have an ability
Then that's basically nothing gained.
I see where you're coming from though in regards to if she's scum though. If I were to be blunt, I feel indifferent. She's not town on my list and she's a lim candidate so she's there with the other two
no she can literally be a tracker who is still scum? what are you on aboutIn post 2538, GreyICE wrote:If you actually think she's scum, then there's two possibilities:In post 2535, unwnd wrote: Marci is just there because I see people still want marci dead (Peta, et al). I don't know what marci is up to but I've seen her come in here saying that we don't care about her reads and then someone will say 'Yeah Marci, we actually do' then she leaves. I have to ask myself if I want that type of play to be anywhere near the top-half of a readlist.
As far as her claim goes? I believe someone said that outing her result gives scum a lead on other PRs because she claimed her target didn't visit anyone.
- She's actually the Tracker at which pointscum know the fucking results
- She has to fakeclaim, meaning she either fakeclaims a target on a scumbuddy, or risks fucking it up.
Or you could think she's town. Do you think she's town?
...In post 2544, petapan wrote:no she can literally be a tracker who is still scum? what are you on aboutIn post 2538, GreyICE wrote:If you actually think she's scum, then there's two possibilities:In post 2535, unwnd wrote: Marci is just there because I see people still want marci dead (Peta, et al). I don't know what marci is up to but I've seen her come in here saying that we don't care about her reads and then someone will say 'Yeah Marci, we actually do' then she leaves. I have to ask myself if I want that type of play to be anywhere near the top-half of a readlist.
As far as her claim goes? I believe someone said that outing her result gives scum a lead on other PRs because she claimed her target didn't visit anyone.
- She's actually the Tracker at which pointscum know the fucking results
- She has to fakeclaim, meaning she either fakeclaims a target on a scumbuddy, or risks fucking it up.
Or you could think she's town. Do you think she's town?
Bolded - She's not really being cooperative. You assume this methodology follows someone who is paying attention and it's likely they're not. No disrespect to her on a personal level we're friends but yeah. I also don't think she really cares about her awesome role because a lot of her bemoaning comes from 'I'm not being listened to' which I think maybe half or more of the plist has said 'ok Marci, the floor is yours!'In post 2542, GreyICE wrote:There's three whole targeting roles left alive that could have submitted a night action last night. (Doctor, Ascetic Cop, Draft Cop)In post 2539, unwnd wrote: Pray tell how the first point is absolutely true? Let's say she's real. If her check is on
1) A member who didn't submit a kill
2) A vanilla townie who doesn't have an ability
Then that's basically nothing gained.
I see where you're coming from though in regards to if she's scum though. If I were to be blunt, I feel indifferent. She's not town on my list and she's a lim candidate so she's there with the other twoIf she's picking someone scummy who is middle/end of the pack (because none of the investigative roles are targeting the top 4, where scum are going to be shooting), what are scum going to potentially learn? Lukewarm/Fferlyt doesn't have one of those three roles? Gee. I bet they'd have never guessed.
Chances are it's useless, but there's a reason there's a methodology to these things. If she does make a "likely guess" and it turns out to be wrong, she's caught scum. That makes your win percentage go up slightly.
Frankly I think Marci is salty we're not taking her awesome power role seriously. That stinks of town to me. But hey, I'll take the few percentage chance I'm wrong and she mucks up a fakeclaim.
As for Hypocops, we should have a long talk in the postgame about why they're very bad and you should have never fallen for Dunn's gambit.