Mystery Mafia 2- Game Over! But who won!?

[Lawrencelot]

Good game. And thanks Iceman for helping me survive so long. For the record, me and farside were mafia with Landlord, but we also thought he was BM.

Mod: did Landlord join the mafia because I targeted him with alcohol?

[Battle Mage]

DAMN YOU K-7.
No one even looked at me as scum. I was sad when I was killed like I was. I had bet that Lawerlot would be lynched that day two which would have give the scum two kills that night.
Oh well good game.

I was actually really amused by the fact that IcemanE gave the two scumbags at the time maximum coins, and then joined their team. Kinda cruel that, by trying to help them, he actually didnt do them much good atall, and tied himself to them.

And K7 impressed me alot here. I felt for a fair-while that he was going to lurk his way to victory. Please note that his role also challenged a mafia gameplay assumption - Long days = good for town. Maybe this isnt quite the case with a time-restricted SK.
This role definitely worked well, and i'd love to use it again. Also, seriously:

NEVER LET K7 LURK HIS WAY THROUGH THE GAME.

I see this happen all over the site. He's probably got the best survival record of anyone on MS this year!

BM

[Battle Mage]

Good game. And thanks Iceman for helping me survive so long. For the record, me and farside were mafia with Landlord, but we also thought he was BM.

Mod: did Landlord join the mafia because I targeted him with alcohol?

Nope, that was again coincidence. After the Pub-Phase, Landlord was given the choice of joining your Mafia group or the Town.

Speaking of which, i should probably colour co-ordinate the OP to show different scumgroups.

BM

[Korts]

I see this happen all over the site. He's probably got the best survival record of anyone on MS this year!

BM

Well, he doesn't say anything to incriminate himself, that's sure.

[Battle Mage]

From: bionicchop2
To: Battle Mage
Posted: Thu Nov 06, 2008 10:59 am
Subject: MM2 - night 7
kill: no one
distort: Korts

OMG, THAT REMINDS ME.

DUDE, WTF??

Why did you never kill anyone!? I thought i was wierd, but you completely baffled me. xD

BM

[Korts]

Good game. And thanks Iceman for helping me survive so long. For the record, me and farside were mafia with Landlord, but we also thought he was BM.

Mod: did Landlord join the mafia because I targeted him with alcohol?

Nope, that was again coincidence. After the Pub-Phase, Landlord was given the choice of joining your Mafia group or the Town.

Speaking of which, i should probably colour co-ordinate the OP to show different scumgroups.

BM

So Landlord knew he was giving the most money to the two scum

and

he could choose to be town? Isn't that a bit broken?

[Battle Mage]

Good game. And thanks Iceman for helping me survive so long. For the record, me and farside were mafia with Landlord, but we also thought he was BM.

Mod: did Landlord join the mafia because I targeted him with alcohol?

Nope, that was again coincidence. After the Pub-Phase, Landlord was given the choice of joining your Mafia group or the Town.

Speaking of which, i should probably colour co-ordinate the OP to show different scumgroups.

BM

So Landlord knew he was giving the most money to the two scum

and

he could choose to be town? Isn't that a bit broken?

He didnt know they were scum at the time. He didnt know anyone's role when he gave out the money, and he was neutral for that duration. The Pub Phase was his time to get settled and choose his allegiance.

BM

[bionicchop2]

How, though? Did I drop any obvious cop-tells or something?

I can't remember my exact thinking. I figured no cops were in the group we were scum hunting in and something about your play had a hint of power role.

[Surye]

Best part for me:

The shortest path to winning == Korlash NOT listening to me, and continuing to push a Landlord lynch.

Korlash will never trust me again

[Korts]

no-one even considered that "Insane Day Cop" was just a rolename for pop and he wasn't, in fact, insane.

I would imagine there are certain standards which a moderator is not going to tinker with. Insane Cop as a standard role name for an actual Insane Cop really can't be messed with or it would throw the whole game off.

This quote makes me lol

[elvis_knits]

OMG I will totally take this win even though it was through no play of my own! Sorry Korts. And how funny was it that you guys didn't think a dalek was scum? I mean, I wasn't... but if I weren't me, I wouldn't have believed it. I wouldn't have even claimed it if I even knew what it was. Town-sided miller killer robot FTW!

There were so many things in this game that were crazy and mysterious and there was no way to figure out that you just had to sort of go with the flow and try to rely on your gut. Which was really awesome! I had a great time, thanks BM.

Also, mislynching Patrick was good times. It... just... feels... so... good.

Good game. And thanks Iceman for helping me survive so long. For the record, me and farside were mafia with Landlord, but we also thought he was BM.

ROFL...

BM... you evil, evil man!

[bionicchop2]

From: bionicchop2
To: Battle Mage
Posted: Thu Nov 06, 2008 10:59 am
Subject: MM2 - night 7
kill: no one
distort: Korts

OMG, THAT REMINDS ME.

DUDE, WTF??

Why did you never kill anyone!? I thought i was wierd, but you completely baffled me. xD

BM

Well, joining on my own and seeing how the previous groups were lynched until all people in the group were basically gone. My scum group had gone 2 days without any living players and no shotgun kills. I needed town to focus on the stabbings from the earlier group and not see a new shotgun kill pop up. I also did not know who else would join (I could then start with new killings if a bigger group joined). I figured my best shot was to genuinely scum hunt. Maybe I should have lurked more so farside wouldn't tell her goons to off me
OMG, THAT REMINDS ME.

DUDE, WTF??

Why did you never kill anyone!? I thought i was wierd, but you completely baffled me. xD

BM

[bionicchop2]

errrrrrrr....

OMG, THAT REMINDS ME.

DUDE, WTF??

Why did you never kill anyone!? I thought i was wierd, but you completely baffled me. xD

BM

Well, joining on my own and seeing how the previous groups were lynched until all people in the group were basically gone. My scum group had gone 2 days without any living players and no shotgun kills. I needed town to focus on the stabbings from the earlier group and not see a new shotgun kill pop up. I also did not know who else would join (I could then start with new killings if a bigger group joined). I figured my best shot was to genuinely scum hunt. Maybe I should have lurked more so farside wouldn't tell her goons to off me

[forbiddanlight]

Well, that was fun, if a bit crazy. Being masonized was awesome in the day before I died, but dying pissed me off. So, why did K7 target me and farside? That was annoying.

Anyway, I really didn't do much this game except nearly get lynched for a badly chosen vig. I'm vaguely disappointed .

[forbiddanlight]

Also, mislynching Patrick was good times. It... just... feels... so... good.

Wasn't that me vigging? Totally not a mislynch .

[Korlash]

The shortest path to winning == Korlash NOT listening to me, and continuing to push a Landlord lynch.

Korlash will never trust me again

Yup... I will never take my Fifth Element doubts for granted again...

Anyway, I really didn't do much this game except nearly get lynched for a badly chosen vig. I'm vaguely disappointed

You helped me and Surye with our claim... that's something!

Anyways, you may all now cheer for me! Miraculously recruiting the only two vanilla town on my first attempts! *bows* I thank you! /flex

[forbiddanlight]

You helped me and Surye with our claim... that's something!

Anyways, you may all now cheer for me! Miraculously recruiting the only two vanilla town on my first attempts! *bows* I thank you! /flex

There were only TWO VANILLA TOWN THIS GAME!? You mean I had such a LOW chance of getting such a lame role...and I got it!? Geez!

[elvis_knits]

Also, mislynching Patrick was good times. It... just... feels... so... good.

Wasn't that me vigging? Totally not a mislynch .

UR RIGHT!

Good job!

[Patrick]

Also, mislynching Patrick was good times. It... just... feels... so... good.

I resent this. I'm just glad I got lord_hur lynched first before dying; I had to pretend I thought he was a werewolf, but towards the end of the day he was looking far more like mafia.

Wasn't that me vigging? Totally not a mislynch

Until the part where I found ashmite's breadcrumb, I wouldn't have believed my own story either X_X.

[farside22]

Also, mislynching Patrick was good times. It... just... feels... so... good.

I resent this. I'm just glad I got lord_hur lynched first before dying; I had to pretend I thought he was a werewolf, but towards the end of the day he was looking far more like mafia.

Wasn't that me vigging? Totally not a mislynch

Until the part where I found ashmite's breadcrumb, I wouldn't have believed my own story either X_X.

Sorry Pat. I bet you would be lynched. Didn't expect the vig from forbidden to happen.
Also I really didn't by the whole ashmite case. Guess I was wrong.

[elvis_knits]

Also, mislynching Patrick was good times. It... just... feels... so... good.

I resent this.

I'm sorry. I don't know why it feels good but it does.

[Patrick]

Oh yep, I speculated on that after you turned up mafia bookie What would you get for betting right?

[forbiddanlight]

Sorry Pat. I bet you would be lynched. Didn't expect the vig from forbidden to happen.
Also I really didn't by the whole ashmite case. Guess I was wrong. Very Happy

I didn't buy it either, but ah well. And hey, expect the unexpectable when playing with me. If there is a vig power that can be obtained by anyone I WILL FIND IT!

What would you get for betting right?

Yeah, I wanna know too!

[farside22]

Oh yep, I speculated on that after you turned up mafia bookie What would you get for betting right?

If I was right we would gain a second kill for the night but I couldn't bet that night.
Basically I bet. If right about the lynch I get to do a kill and the other mafia in my group does a kill.
You know the night Fonz and Literal died? That was me and lawerlot.

[Kison]

Awww, I finally technically lose a Battle Mage game after my long streak.

The Dismembering was Kison if i recall, given that he also decided to send a kill in for his group. Admittedly a little bastardish, but that'll teach you guys to take kill methods seriously!

Nope, I didn't submit the Dasquian kill. Must've been Lord Hur as we were the only two alive by the time I came into the game.

My first game as scum and I get to join with all my partners already dead + I get killed by other scum group.

Well at least your role PM didn't say 'you have 4 days to live.'

I had fun with my . I spent a good day or two thinking about how I could trick the most people into saying the keyword. The way it worked was that I had to get as many people to say 'Hiroshima' as I could before my time expired. Each individual who said it was more likely to die in the explosion, including my teammates. I'm guessing the other guy(Vel-Rahn Koon?) who was trying to get people to say 'Nagasaki' was suppose to be my offset and protect people who said his keyword, but I did not know what to think prior to his card flip, so I avoided saying the word altogether. In any event I was happy with this role because I really was not up to playing another game all the way through as I was trying to get

out

of playing Mafia at the time, so thanks for the unintentional consideration, Battle Mage.

This game was far more insane than the first Mystery Mafia. Just the sheer number of points where new players entered the game as opposed to last time made it far more confusing.