Mini Normal 2288: Reposting Same Picture As Flavor Are Lame

[PenguinPower]

[Shirou]

you were told it was ELO and thought it was Mylo one or two pages ago

there's just no way i'm not voting herta here

he scumposts too much for me to let him live

[Shirou]

Shirou is skitter redux.

also, once again i ask, what did you mean by this

[Herta]

I got caught up in my rush to judgment ha.

[Shirou]

i think fire makes sense as scum by dayplay as well to be clear, but i also think that herta is scum and therefore one of freedom/fire is likely telling the truth/town, and roaming watcher makes more sense to me as the last town PR rather than loyal visitor, because every other town PR had a setback of sorts

Hider was lazy (stops working once there's only one scum left)

Follower was Novice (cannot target on night 1)

JOAT was both loud and announcing (which means that if he targets scum, scumteam knows who to NK, it's almost like being delayed weak or something)

we've also an activable innocent child so most of the time this setup has 2 or 3 potential clears/innos, we just got unlucky. I think rather than being a rather powerful ungated role, the last PR probably follows the trend of being nerfed a bit, and roaming is the perfect nerf for watcher given he can't soft-protect a universal town read/town PR for more than one night then

[Shirou]

Fire was also the unique person to be able to be sure that Klick was a Town JOAT by N2. Klick was rather suspected and I don't remember him softing at all, if he did it was rather subtle i think. it was a weird NK and the most plausible explanation also points me to Firebringer unhappily.

i really tried my best to just not call him scum in this game and sorry if i'm wrong again on you fire.

[PenguinPower]

that makes a lot of sense actually

[PenguinPower]

Fire was also the unique person to be able to be sure that Klick was a Town JOAT by N2.

Explain?

[Firebringer]

he is saying because i saw Klick visit me night 1

[Firebringer]

i think fire makes sense as scum by dayplay as well to be clear,

expand on this portion the most

[Shirou]

I also think firebringer suspecting me on day 1 here was a weird read from him, i think i was completely uncaring about how i'm seen by others in this game and i do think he would normally assume that to be +town for me

suspecting Andante is also puzzling and he was unable to tell me one single game where he saw andante playing like this as scum. his reads on both me/andante didn't feel real to me initially but then i was really trying my best to not tunnel him because i've been wrong on him before twice and i like playing with him, but by this point i just cannot justify not scum reading him and once again i'm sorry if i'm wrong firepup

[Firebringer]

u were hell of sus day 1

[Shirou]

i think fire makes sense as scum by dayplay as well to be clear,

expand on this portion the most

what i said in my most recent post and also you had two interactions with herta (which i assume is scum right now) that caught my eye:

the most interesting thing about herta to me is his attitude this game is way less passive than last game i just played with him.
Outside of that change in tone i don't see anything scummy there.

herta, ur attitude and play are a lot different than mini 2285.
is there a reason for this

it feels like the kind of stuff you say to a scumbuddy to poke him but not really bus him

if you thought that herta was acting differently than the other game you played with him, i would think you would be a bit more suspicious of him and through the days you just seemed rather uninterested on pursuing/voting him

[Shirou]

u were hell of sus day 1

why was i sus

[Firebringer]

i have to get back to work, will talk later today/tomorrow morning

[Shirou]

same gotta do some other stuff

idk i think i'm throwing this game by this point but i don't know what to do other than throw

my scum read on herta at least isn't something that will vanish from any amount of talking i'm confident

[Shirou]

calling me scum without voting me until he had a "case" of sorts upon my explanation of why i thought geraintm was likely to be scum

understanding how ninja works but still asking the mod for it

initially being aware of it being Mylo/ELO, but thinking it can be 6 people alive, when he also always guessed 3 player scum teams so he should know that with 6 people alive and 3 mafia, the game would be over. But then also "forgetting" it's ELO in the next page when he was also told that by PP a short bit ago.

idk what to do here other than vote herta

i'm sorry if i'm wrong yet again

[Firebringer]

lets let everyone else talk and take a break. I have some analysis to do on this game later.
theres zero reason to rush anything

[Shirou]

UNVOTE:

[Herta]

calling me scum without voting me until he had a "case" of sorts upon my explanation of why i thought geraintm was likely to be scum

understanding how ninja works but still asking the mod for it

initially being aware of it being Mylo/ELO, but thinking it can be 6 people alive, when he also always guessed 3 player scum teams so he should know that with 6 people alive and 3 mafia, the game would be over. But then also "forgetting" it's ELO in the next page when he was also told that by PP a short bit ago.

idk what to do here other than vote herta

i'm sorry if i'm wrong yet again

You were calling me scum before any of that?

Why?

[Kowahbunga]

I just realized that I have no idea if Fire is actually even telling the truth about his role. So I can no longer just assume he was actually loyal. I only know whatever he is is loud.

Freedom, did Fire visit me?

[Herta]

I view this game as either gryff being scum and herta likely being one buddy or Kowah being scum for the max troll. If all of those people are town, and Andante is town, and I assume redFF, PP and maybe Klick are more likely town than scum for some good posts there and here, geraint becomes scum by PoE, so if my main suspects are wrong and most of my town leans are right, there's decent chances of geraint being scum due to...math. he also hasn't done anything remotely townie as far as I know.

I do kinda dislike klick defending players more than attacking scum reads but /shrug, he doesn't feel that scummy to me, maybe just wrong (or maybe right??)

Explain your thinking with this post.

[Shirou]

calling me scum without voting me until he had a "case" of sorts upon my explanation of why i thought geraintm was likely to be scum

understanding how ninja works but still asking the mod for it

initially being aware of it being Mylo/ELO, but thinking it can be 6 people alive, when he also always guessed 3 player scum teams so he should know that with 6 people alive and 3 mafia, the game would be over. But then also "forgetting" it's ELO in the next page when he was also told that by PP a short bit ago.

idk what to do here other than vote herta

i'm sorry if i'm wrong yet again

You were calling me scum before any of that?

Why?

i'll reply this later

just wanted to come back to reply:

i like the new anime girl avi shirou

...it's a boy.

[Firebringer]

I just realized that I have no idea if Fire is actually even telling the truth about his role. So I can no longer just assume he was actually loyal. I only know whatever he is is loud.

Freedom, did Fire visit me?

Freedom visited me

[Kowahbunga]

I just realized that I have no idea if Fire is actually even telling the truth about his role. So I can no longer just assume he was actually loyal. I only know whatever he is is loud.

Freedom, did Fire visit me?

Freedom visited me

Okay I misread Watcher role, so he would be able to confirm that Herta targeted you, but not confirm you visited me.

Second question then, Freedom. Who all did you target each night of the game?