HMS Mutiny [Game Over]

[Eiralox]

Also, the fact that neither of you have been hammered suggests to me that one of you is scum?

Absolutely!

Radical Rat wants to vote MalaKittens
Flea the Magician has expressed interest in voting for me.

So right now, crew is split.

I'mma be away for a while, but I guarantee this Bellaphant: Talk with Rat. Talk with Flea.

I'm very sure that if crew communicates we can pull through this.

[Radical Rat]

IF Malakittens is third party, then it becomes POSSIBLE for Elements and Eiralox to both be Town.

But then if THAT'S the case, the only scumteam that remains is KJ/Flea. Which seems.... well, not very likely given recent events.

So all roads inevitably lead to Eira/Elements, save for the very remote possibility that I'm wrong about Bella.

My insistence on Malakittens, though I thought it to be illuminating, is ultimately just kicking the can down the road.

So. It is with a split mind and a heavy heart that I must...

VOTE: Elements

If she flips roleblocker, KJ is innocent and Flea is the last scum. If they flip a beneficial scum role, KJ is guilty. Anything else... and Eiralox gets a firm handshake for swaying me from my correct solve.

[Elements]

RR unvote me or we will lose!

[Elements]

How has Eira persuaded you after getting Gimli limmed yesterday?

[Eiralox]

To be honest, if I were scum this game, with everything I've done, I'd just feel dirty.

Radical Rat, I'm willing to vote for either MalaKittens or Nancy Drew, I think I've become that certain.

I don't think Flea is at all interested in voting Mala though...

Well.

I really think I have to work now and tune these things out of my mind a bit.

[Elements]

Are you actually taking into account how Eira has played this game? The way him and Mala were all but taunting me despite scumming me? The activity anti town and detrimental gameplay of blind repeating and saying he'd case without ever doing it?

[Eiralox]

Elements, these last few pages, has that been a case?

Or just Eira repeating themselves?

Well..... as I said, I need to tune this out. My mind is way too over-invested here and right now Imma just fade.

[Elements]

Comf town -> scum on Mala because of a ROLE NAME
Do you not see how ridiculous that is?
Meanwhile Bella claims a role name you literally gave her on a platter when I claimed and that gets no suspicion at all.
Eira, Bella (RB), Mala
You just have to look at their positioning today

[Elements]

Elements, these last few pages, has that been a case?

Or just Eira repeating themselves?

Well..... as I said, I need to tune this out. My mind is way too over-invested here and right now Imma just fade.

No, but you've had 2 weeks to come up with it

[Elements]

And suddenly everyone is just like 'yea sure Eira must be right, it's not like Eira has been stalling making a case for 2 weeks this must have been what Eira was thinking since the start'

[Radical Rat]

Well, the thing is once he got over his grandstanding huffy silence... He makes sense. I saw a glimmer of it with regard to Gimli too. He was wrong about Gimli, and many other things, but I believe him when he says he sees these things, because if you go and you look, the progression makes sense.

I think Eiralox's earlier behavior was incredibly anti-Town. I think he's been disingenuous a lot of the time throughout the game.

I thought much of the same about Gimli before him. I came around on Gimli because I could see the genuine effort and desire to solve underneath the surface. Took me a while to get there, but I was right.

And right now, I'm getting that same feeling from Eira.

Is it possible he's just emulating this to appeal to me? Sure. But at the end of the day... he doesn't need to appeal to me. If he's scum, he just needs one Townie to bite, it doesn't have to be me.

And unfortunately if it isn't him... It does have to be you.

[Eiralox]

Meanwhile Bella claims a role name you literally gave her on a platter when I claimed and that gets no suspicion at all.

I'm actually still very suspicious of this, exactly for the reasons you stated! But, I trust Bellaphant, and that is enough.

I mean I even soft hinted that I am the BOSUN, so.... me trusting Bella has far more to do with their behavior, with my solve, than their role name. I decided to trust it cos I trust them I guess? If I were scum and Bella crew I'da cc'd that ultra-hard, maybe.

Bilous odours simmering under noses...

Well, that's all from me.

[Radical Rat]

Wait hold up.

UNVOTE:

[Radical Rat]

You're counterclaiming Bella? Now?

[Radical Rat]

Can you explain what it is your version of boatswain/bosun does?

[Elements]

Meanwhile Bella claims a role name you literally gave her on a platter when I claimed and that gets no suspicion at all.

I'm actually still very suspicious of this, exactly for the reasons you stated! But, I trust Bellaphant, and that is enough.

I mean I even soft hinted that I am the BOSUN, so.... me trusting Bella has far more to do with their behavior, with my solve, than their role name. I decided to trust it cos I trust them I guess? If I were scum and Bella crew I'da cc'd that ultra-hard, maybe.

Bilous odours simmering under noses...

Well, that's all from me.

So you had a fake PR claim lined up with softing it?

[Elements]

You're counterclaiming Bella? Now?

No, Eira is saying he had that claim lined up and softed it
Then passed it to Bella when she needed it

[Elements]

Bella's role and claim are the definition of convenient

[Radical Rat]

Bella's role and claim are the definition of convenient

How? Had she not said anything at all, what would have been different?

[Eiralox]

So you had a fake PR claim lined up with softing it?

Absolutely! A Loyal Sailor can haz some fun ; )

Following my progression though, seeing when I claimed, you'll see me saying I ain't gonna claim fake results. So. Nothing ever happened with it, and I'm glad, cos I trust Bella. If I had claimed Bosun at any point.... well, then Bella might never have even considered trusting me, as the Boatswain.

Ugh....

Yeah.

I gotta skedaddle.

[Eiralox]

Bella's role and claim are the definition of convenient

You are...... Ship's Commissioner?

[Elements]

Bella's claim was just a scum play
Doing things scum wouldn't do is what scum tries to do no?

[Radical Rat]

Okay, so you're NOT actually a PR...

I don't have enough sleep in the tank for this

[Bellaphant]

???

I'm obv town Elly. This is just confirming you are scum

[Eiralox]

You're counterclaiming Bella? Now?

Can you explain what it is your version of boatswain/bosun does?

Oh lol, no!


I'm saying I softed Bosun like.... at the very start of the game, so, I'm not counterclaiming at all! My claim remains the same.

I do seem to have a knack for spreading confusion though so *shrug*.

Anyway, my ultimate philosophy remains unchanged: If you, Flea, and Bella talk with each other, things will be very clear here.

Hmmmmm....

there's me again, spreading chaos. Flea is right, and your assessment of me is fair Rat............

I think a lot of what happened here, especially Day 1 with Fenrir, was in part due to my manic mass posting. I have indeed been anti-town.........

Ugh I hate humble pills.

Well.

Be good ya'll.