Newbie 2113 - Shea it ain't So! | Game Over!

[Black]

Regardless how confident you are...anything can happen in those 17 pages. Like someone trying to force the masons to claim idk

Someone tried to out us? You didn't spill the beans did you?

Never :3

But you just did so clean them up

[skitter30]

@furitive why dio

Just seems awkward and scummy

What do u think wrt the last game?

[furtiveglance]

@furitive why dio

Just seems awkward and scummy

What do u think wrt the last game?

Was towny last game. An easy townread

[Black]

Skitter:

Skitter, who do you think has been trying to solve this game more: Dio or Empath?

If you could explain why with your answer I would appreciate it!

[Dionysus]

I will be looking forward to your analysis on the next 17 pages and I'm curious how they will change your current opinions

I don't think they will really, but I'll let you know

You should read the rest of the game!

[KawaiiKame]

Regardless how confident you are...anything can happen in those 17 pages. Like someone trying to force the masons to claim idk

Someone tried to out us? You didn't spill the beans did you?

#519

[Black]

@furitive why dio

Just seems awkward and scummy

I read some of Dio's other game and people sus'd him early for being awkward there too but he ended up being town. So idk if that's necessarily a scumtell for Dio

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Hi Furtive,

Did you replace into a scum slot my friend?

[furtiveglance]

Hi Furtive,

Did you replace into a scum slot my friend?

Yes I did, yeah.

Yeah

I was gonna try and pretend to be town but since you asked so directly I had to come clean. It's like with a plainclothes officer.

Anyway, catch up part 2 coming soon!

[Black]

I just don't think Dio is scum here. Like yeah it's possible but all of the reasons people are accusing him of being scum can easily be explained by him being newtown. I don't think the case is strong at all. I realize that if I'm wrong here it will make me look really bad but w/e, I'm trusting my gut here

[BlueBloodedToffee]

I thought so Furtive.

That's a god damn shame.

[Empathice]

@furitive why dio

Just seems awkward and scummy

I read some of Dio's other game

and people sus'd him early

for being awkward

there too but he ended up being town. So idk if that's necessarily a scumtell for Dio

I just don't think Dio is scum here. Like yeah it's possible but all of the reasons people are accusing him of being scum can easily be explained by

him being newtown

. I don't think the case is strong at all. I realize that if I'm wrong here it will make me look really bad but w/e, I'm trusting my gut here

No, no and no.

[Dionysus]

Still posting about me I see.

[KawaiiKame]

Still posting about me I see.

"IT IS I! DI0! THE MAIN CHARACTER!"

[Black]

Still posting about me I see.

It's a long tunnel chill. He almost reversed out of it last night but I guess there was no other way to go but back in the tunnel?

[Black]

@furitive why dio

Just seems awkward and scummy

I read some of Dio's other game

and people sus'd him early

for being awkward

there too but he ended up being town. So idk if that's necessarily a scumtell for Dio

I just don't think Dio is scum here. Like yeah it's possible but all of the reasons people are accusing him of being scum can easily be explained by

him being newtown

. I don't think the case is strong at all. I realize that if I'm wrong here it will make me look really bad but w/e, I'm trusting my gut here

No, no and no.

Compelling argument lol

[skitter30]

Skitter, who do you think has been trying to solve this game more: Dio or Empath?

Honestly neither

[Black]

This is a quote from Dio in the other game. Seem familiar?

I'm not new to mafia but I am new to this site and I think my playstyle just doesn't gel because I feel like such a noob. Everything I say seems to be wrong and draws suspicion!

I'm normally very good I swear!

[furtiveglance]

Catch up part 2: p11-20

Spoiler: Page 11

Why does Dionysus keep winking and finding everything funny? patchwork's 264, where it's about players in the game, is mostly about themself. I obviously agree about pronouns (btw Black you go to user control panel in the top right to set your pronoun). However I think patchwork's content is lacking in the main in terms of having and pushing scumreads. Hadriaan's 273 looks ab= bit safe in a +scum way, he isn't really pushing anyone in the post.

Spoiler: Page 12

Hadriaan looking at past games is +town. Dionysus' push on patchwork is making me confused, it's uncharitable in a scummy way but patchwork's post isn't towny either. Black's posting is +town, moving the game forward. patchwork still feels +scum to me for posting almost entirely about themself.

Spoiler: Page 13

Dionysus prodding lurkers looks LAMIST. Black and skitter still town. Empathice's reads look really good.

Spoiler: Page 14

WMFM isn't a strong tell yeah. I was pushed a lot in my first game as town and asked why a lot. Dionysus' explanation for voting Herta on page 1, while believable, isn't +town. You can impulsively vote someone as scum - he might have thought it would look town to do so.

Spoiler: Page 15

352from Dionysus looks very self-interested. Black, town can tunnel. I think Empathice is town with a strong read. 359is very weird in its reasoning and conclusion, and doesn't seem to follow up on calling Hadriaan 'lurkscum'.

Spoiler: Page 16

skitter and Black are very town. I think Black is scumsiding.

Spoiler: Page 17

Empathice is insightful, +town. Kawaii feels quite open which is +town. I can see scum motivation for BBT's posting. I can never really read BBT though.

Spoiler: Page 18

Empathice wanting the thunderdome is +town. Dionysus feels a bit weaselly. Kawaii readslist looks town. BBT limpool is ok.

Spoiler: Page 19

patchwork's pop-in is really scummy. No pushing, openly just having no scumreads and being unsure is +++scum.

Spoiler: Page 20

Yeah the patchwork/Empathice interaction is weird.

I'm stuck on Dionysus and patchwork. In more detail though:

reads

Black, Kawaii, skitter

Empathice

BBT

Hadriaan

Dionysus

Patchwork

[Black]

Skitter, who do you think has been trying to solve this game more: Dio or Empath?

Honestly neither

Two of your main reasons for thinking Dio is scum is that a) he's not solving and b) you don't like his scumreads. Why are you not applying this same logic to Empath?

[Black]

Furtive how did you do the cool reads subsection? I like that

[skitter30]

This is a quote from Dio in the other game. Seem familiar?

I'm not new to mafia but I am new to this site and I think my playstyle just doesn't gel because I feel like such a noob. Everything I say seems to be wrong and draws suspicion!

I'm normally very good I swear!

He isn't playing that card here: he's just trying to move everyobe and is rolling his eyes. Like i feel like he knows how scummy he is but is trying to get people to move on by callibg it old news. I don't really feel like he's addressing the meat of the accusations against him

[furtiveglance]

Furtive how did you do the cool reads subsection? I like that

Area tag:

Code: Select all

[area=Reads][/area]

Colors is pretty easy:

Code: Select all

[color=#FF0000][/color]

Make it bigger:

Code: Select all

[size=150][/size]

[skitter30]

Skitter, who do you think has been trying to solve this game more: Dio or Empath?

Honestly neither

Two of your main reasons for thinking Dio is scum is that a) he's not solving and b) you don't like his scumreads. Why are you not applying this same logic to Empath?

Well i like empath's scumreads ... i do feel like he can try to solve elsewhere too tho

[skitter30]

I like that furitive's reads align with mine but it makes me a little nervous